INTRODUCTION
Conflict is defined as “the perceived and/or actual incompatibility of values, expectations, processes, or outcomes between two or more parties over substantive and/or relationship issues” (Cain, p.26, 2013). The authors of this paper will point/counter-point to see if conflict is good for an organization, or if all conflicts are dysfunctional. After the point/counter-point the authors will explain if as a group they were able to come to consensus on the issue and which side of the argument is most strongly supported by academic literature.
Types of Conflict
Conflict can have varying effects on the performance of a team. Once a team is faced with any type of conflict, it is important for the team to work toward a resolution to aid in the team’s overall success. As done so by Behfar and Peterson (2008), it is easiest to group the sources of conflict into 3 main categories to develop a better understanding of what a team may be faced with.
Task or Cognitive Conflict
Task or cognitive conflict is disagreement over differences in ideas, viewpoints, and opinions pertaining to the group’s task (Behfar, Peterson, 2008). For example, disagreement regarding an organization’s current hiring strategies or the appropriate information to include in an annual report (Greer, Jehn, Levine, Szulanski, 2008).
Relationship Conflict
Relationship conflict is disagreement resulting from interpersonal incompatibilities, which includes affective components such as feeling tension and friction (Behfar, Peterson, 2008). Relationship conflicts frequently reported are about social events, gossip, clothing preferences, political views and hobbies (Greer, Jehn, Levine, Szulanski, 2008). “Task conflict is widely believed to be beneficial whereas relationship conflict is destructive” (Jiang, Zhang, and Tjosvold, 2013).
Process Conflict
Process conflict is conflict about dividing and delegating responsibility and deciding how to get work done. An example of this is an argument about who is responsible for writing up the final report and who will make the presentation (Greer, Jehn, Levine, Szulanski, 2008).
CONFLICT IS GOOD FOR AN ORGANIZATION
It is normal to experience conflict when working in team environments. The key to having an effective team is getting its members to work together to overcome conflict. Psychological safety facilitates the performance benefits of task conflict in teams, and psychological safety refers to team members being confident that the team will not embarrass, reject, or punish someone for speaking up (Bradley, Postlethwaite, Klotz, Hamdani, and Brown, 2012).
Causes of Team Conflict in Organizations
“Too little conflict results in organizational stasis, while too much conflict reduces the organization’s effectiveness and eventually immobilizes its employees (Marquis & Huston 1996)” (Lather, Jain, Jain, and Vikas, 2009)
According to Higgins (2003) there are three types of conflict that occur in business teams, there’s process-related conflict, conflict in identifying the task and goals for the team, and personality conflict.
Caudron (1998) identifies three sources of conflict in the modern workforce. First is employees are being forced to “do more with less” and this causes stress which leads to conflict. Second is employees are now making tough decisions due to downsizing and this added responsibility causes conflict. Lastly team-based work is increasing and this naturally leads to conflict.
Outcomes of a Team Conflict
“When basic conflicts are not resolved it is difficult, if not impossible, to develop trust and good interpersonal relationships at work” (Lather, Jain, Jain, & Vikas, 2009).
“Adler and Towne (1990) identified three possible courses of actions when faced with a conflict: (a) accepting the status quo (i.e. living with the problem); (b) using force and mandating change; (c) reaching an agreement by negotiating. Three types of outcomes result from these approaches to conflict management: Win–Lose
Related Documents: Individual Leadership Project Essay
Management and Leadership Level 5 Management and Leadership Contents Page Qualification structures Unit 5001 Unit 5002 Unit 5003 Unit 5004 Unit 5005 Unit 5006 Unit 5007 Unit 5008 Unit 5009 Unit 5010 Unit 5011 Unit 5012 Unit 5013 Personal development as a manager and leader Information based decision making Performance management Resource management Meeting stakeholder and quality needs Conducting a management project Financial control Marketing planning Project development and control Human…
learning and practicing leadership and team skills, the course gives special focus to the individual and group aspects of organizational behaviour through the exploration of personality, values, vision and ethics, diversity, motivation, leadership, decision making, communication and conflict resolution. Leveraging diversity and navigating organizational change provide the context for the course. The course will provide experiential opportunities to develop team and leadership skills. Credit cannot…
SELF LEADERSHIP The concept of ‘self-leadership’ sounds, at first glance, to be self-defeating. Individuals want to be led to greater heights in their career and in the areas of job satisfaction, performance and motivation - but they need to do that by themselves in a vacuum where no one else can openly critique them. Our concept of ‘leadership’ in the traditional sense needs to be redefined in order to fully understand the notion of self-leadership, or as Manz and Neck see it, ‘self-influence’:…
Article Review on Leadership Chava Venkata Hari prasad Project and Change Management Wilmington University Paul McKenna Article Review on Leadership In this article the author shared his view about the leadership approaches in an organization and variable factors that affects the leadership and presented them clearly by using political way of approaches. Leadership has descriptive and prescriptive elements. To understand the difference, one can consider Adolf Hitler and Martin Luther King…
LEADERSHIP SKILLS IN MANAGING PROJECTS CHUKWUDI STEPHEN NWOSU 13182607 Department of Project Management. School of Engineering, Design and Manufacturing Systems Faculty of Technology, Engineering and the Environment Birmingham City University, Millennium point, B4 7XG Abstract Purpose- The purpose of this paper is to succinctly identify the leadership skills exhibited by individuals in managing projects, after due appraisal of relevant existing literatures on the subject. Methodology- Relevant…
MPM332-1501A-02: Organizational Leadership Gabriel Escaffi January 7, 2015 Karen Johnson My entire working career has been in either law enforcement or corrections. I am currently employed by the Department of Justice in the Federal Bureau of Prisons. One of the most important factors that contribute to being successful when working in correction or any career field is having exceptional leadership skills and structure. The truth of the matter is that most individuals can manage but it takes special…
side by side and have briefly listed the differences between the two reviews (Turner & Muller, 2005, w137) (Pirzadeh, 2010, w154). Both our reviews exam ine aspects of human factors in successful project management. The first is a conventional or traditional review of project manager’s leadership style. The second is a systematic literature review on h uman factors in software development. Conventional or traditional review Systematic Review No details of database sources used to identify…
Strategic Management and Leadership Level 7 Strategic Management and Leadership Contents Page Qualification structures Unit 7001 Unit 7002 Unit 7003 Unit 7004 Unit 7005 Unit 7006 Unit 7007 Unit 7008 Unit 7009 Unit 7010 Unit 7011 Unit 7012 Unit 7013 Unit 7014 Personal development as a strategic manager Strategic performance management Financial management Strategic information management Conducting a strategic management project Organisational direction Financial planning Strategic marketing…
My Personal Leadership Style Samuel R. Young II Indiana Tech Abstract The purpose of this paper is to clearly explain my personal leadership style. My leadership style will be described by using concepts such as emotional intelligence, transformational leadership style, and servant leadership. Taking the class Leadership Styles and Development has allowed me to understand concepts of leaderships which describe me as an evolving leader. By defining, examining, discussing, describing, and…
23, 2014 Module 8 Portfolio Abstract This essay documents failures in leadership based on my experience. We will concentrate on an experience in which the negative psychology of an individual impacted leadership and caused challenges within the organization. We will identify potential solutions management could have used to improve the quality of the leadership. Details of the Experience In 2005 I was a project engineer for a firm in California. I worked in a small group of folks who…