Liberalism vs. Realism
Definitions: 1. when realists observe the world system, they primarily see states struggling for power, each trying to consolidate its relative gain in a zero-sum game. The structure of the international system is thus rooted in this struggle, which is why realists contemplate little or no change in the structure of the international system.
2. A liberal, on the other hand, sees interdependence in the world system, a system in which every state cooperates on some level with other states. This cooperation is facilitated by institutions and established norms and ensures that every state maximizes its gain. Absolute gains, therefore, rather than relative gains, are the focus of liberals.
Question: Is there really such thing as "mutual gain" or "cooperation" in IR? Can a system or institution created primarily to benefit some states, in this case the big powers, be a viable framework for achieving mutual benefits?
Analysis: In spite of the level of cooperation and interdependence existing between Nigeria and the United States, for instance, nothing in terms of the benefits accruing to both states could rightly be construed as "mutual." Nigeria's goal may be to try as much as possible to make the most of its oil wealth, even if it means producing below its prescribed OPEC quotas in order to sell at a higher price - a situation many strategists in Nigeria would welcome. America, on its part, may use its leverage as a global power to block any attempt by Nigeria to procure any form of debt relief from IMF as payback for Nigeria's unfavorable oil policy.
The above hypothetical underlies my difficulty in truly appreciating the liberal analysis of the world system. It would seem that cooperation is only a veil used by states to conceal their struggle for power and security. Giant Multinational corporations are, in the same measure, indistinguishable from the world powers; they largely represent the economic interests of their parent
Related Documents: Superpower and Cooperation Essay
This shows the two superpowers on ultimately opposite sites, even if it was not evident in their own conflict it can be seen in who they supported. Therefore, détente was never going to be a groundbreaking peace treaty that would bring significant change to the cold war, it was only ever going to be a temporary solution. The idea of deception can further be seen in the contrast between what Nixon believed and what was going on. Nixon thought that détente allowed superpower relations to get better…
Political Geography: Key Issue 4 Where are States Distributed Rubenstein, pp. 286-295 The Cold War (1940’s-1990’s) 1. Who were the two main superpowers during the Cold War? United States (NATO) “First World” Soviet Union (Warsaw Pact) “Second World” Neutral: “Third World” 2. How has the nature of both alliances and warfare changed since the end of the Cold War? Warfare is less often conventional and more often state vs organization or internal within state Alliances are more often economic…
soon to be a country which many predict will share superpower status with the US alone in years to come, or even exceed it1. However it seems that China’s economic development brings more apprehension than enthusiasm2 from many countries worldwide; according to the Economist (2012, May 5th-11th, pp. 25-7), “at best, mutual strategic mistrust seems too deeply ingrained to eradicate” between the US and China, it’s soon to be rival for exclusive superpower status. The reason for American concern mainly…
Future of United States and China Relations As large nations, both China and U.S. experience significant problems and threats such as terrorism, food and meeting energy. These typical challenges give hope for greater cooperation between the two countries. Yet , there is no territorial disputes between China and U.S. Relations between China and the United States have been generally stable with some periods of tension, most remarkably after the breakup of the Soviet Union…
took place in London in January 1946, with 51 nations in attendance (Department of Public Information, ND). Similarly to the League of Nations, the UN sought to establish world peace, but the UN broadened its horizons by specifically promoting cooperation in solving international economic, social and humanitarian problems. Even with the Franklin D. Roosevelt’s hand in the creation of the UN, the heat of communism versus democracy was gaining strength and the U.S. fought the Soviet Union in the Cold…
China (i/ˈtʃaɪnə/; Chinese: 中国; pinyin: Zhōngguó), officially the People's Republic of China, is a sovereign state located in East Asia. It is the world's most populous country, with a population of over 1.35 billion. The PRC is a single-party state governed by the Communist Party, with its seat of government in the capital city of Beijing.[14] It exercises jurisdiction over 22 provinces, five autonomous regions, four direct-controlled municipalities (Beijing, Tianjin, Shanghai, and Chongqing), and…
Lizbeth Hernandez World History Credit 10 1/28/15 Political World changes in Europe since the fall of the Soviet Union On Christmas day December 25th, 1991, at 7:25pm, Mikhail Gorbachev made a televised speech announcing his resignation as President of the Soviet Union. He declared his office null and void. He then gave the Soviet Nuclear missile codes to the new Russian president Boris Yelstin. The Russians then lowered the Soviet flag and raised…
Trade Bloc Main Characteristics of member countries Purpose of group Benefits of joining this group EU Geographical location, Structural evolution, Economy, Foreign relations, treaties & governance. Top develop a strong economy throughout Europe. It is a supranational organisation which helps to resolve democratic, social and political issues throughout member of states. Political Stability and greater integration amongst European states. Increased trade and competition (this advantages everyone…
to focus their attention on space exploration. The two most notable instances were between the United States and the Soviet Union (USSR). In the time after the Second World War, referred to as the Cold War, there was a conflict between these two superpowers. One of the main components of the War was the Space Race. The US and USSR indirectly fought one another to get to space first. Then to orbit Earth. Then to get to Luna. This competition brought about strong unity among citizens in the United States…
but that is the nice thing about animals and nature: they will adapt and find a new way to live and a new way to migrate. There is always going to be some form of collateral damage for progress but with that being said with the right support and cooperation we can work toward finding a way that we can minimize the damage to any sort of change made to the environment, and also continue to keep some of the land a preserve for hunting and exploring. With new technology it will be easy to promote leaving…