Case Report- DeHavilland Inc.
CASE ANALYSIS CONTENT MARKS AVAILBLE
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY De Havilland had high inventory and high manufacturing cost which has been caused by the high cost of sourcing the flap shrouds and bay doors from Dollard Plastics of Montreal and the company was looking forward to an alternative supplier with a long time relationship. I found they were less of strategy and more tactical.
The total parts cost of Dash 8 airplane at De Havilland represented 60-65% of their total manufacturing cost. It’s is evident that the company has recognized that and they have taken steps to solve this issue. A further indication that the company is operating at high cost is their previous failed attempt when they requested a 25% discount on all parts across the board. Dollard Plastics of Montreal is currently supplying the company with the parts needed but at about 3 times higher than Morton’s quote. The uncertainty that De Havilland was going through at this point in terms of choosing the right supplier who was going to be reliable enough to commit to a 5 year fixed contract with the company.
The company wanted to move to a smaller base of vendors but should not be sore source without a backup plan. The company focused on cost reduction but cost should not be the only criteria of vendor evaluation and selection. The whole structure and process did not respect the strategic role of procurement, as well as tactical approaches that support the strategy. Such as Kim Tomar as a financial analyst was impropriate to make a direct recommendation to SSB. Because the only criteria based on her background was price. She had no idea about other KPIs like manufacture capacity, inventory management, lead time, response and maintenance services ability and new technology invention. The buyer Bob Katz did not involve in the beginning of procurement process like recognition, specification clarification, sourcing and selection. The only responsibilities of Bob was negotiation.
Alternative 1
To develop a negotiation strategy and proceed with vendor selection considering price, safety, quality, manufacture capacity, inventory management, transportation, lead time, response and maintenance services ability and new technology invention. I recommend to give the 80% of total purchasing value to Marton as the lowest vendor and keep 20% of share to Dollard as the experienced vendor.
Alternative 2
Negotiate separate agreements on the same basis and contractual terms with DasComposite and Lakeside Industries who were the next lowest bidders after Morton. These negotiations should be in the same time period as Morton’s and the successful outcome should function as a best alternative to a negotiated agreement (BATNA) for De Havilland if negotiations fail with Morton’s.
I do recommend alternative 1 as the best choice for DeHavilland at this point because this option will solve their problem in 2 ways: reduce their manufacturing cost and establish a long term relationship with Morton.
Need a bid clarification meeting with Morton in order to clarify its pricing and all terms to the agreement and ensure that they are realistic and firm and get a written commitment from them before final decision to award. Bid clarification meeting will include experts from the Material, Finance, and Engineering and Quality Assurance teams of de Havilland. After bid is approved, then both parties will sign the contract so that the supply will commence as per the agreement.
Each party should designate a representative such as key account whose main duty is to meet periodically with the other party’s representative in order to discuss the progress and help troubleshoot any issues. In case of major issues or if any opportunity arises, then a meeting between the appropriate people should be scheduled to deal with it. 5
ISSUES(S) IDENTIFICATION De Havilland had high inventory and high manufacturing cost which has been caused by the high cost of sourcing the flap
The program I am going to talk about in this case report is the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP) in the United States. A brief history about the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program, through 1989, nine Prescription Drug Monitoring Program has been established. Two were located in state Attorneys General offices (California 1939 and Pennsylvania, 1972); two departments of Public Safety (Hawaii, 1943 and Texas, 1981) one in Department of Substance Abuse Services (Illinois, 1961); one in…
squad, you spent your time on 2 cases that are still unsolved. Wouldn’t that question your ability to solve homicide cases? Yes, but they wasn’t enough evidence. [Then why didn’t you hand them over to a different squad member?] You seem very eager to solve a case, especially his one. Why is that? The evidence is clear and that means it’ll be easy to find the murderer The proper police procedure is to interview all potential witnesses that are present in the case. Yet, the only potential witness…
unearthed two human skeletons lying side by side. The police have a lot of missing people cases and are looking for answers. Like whom these people are? Also can bones tell their story and give there grieving families a closure? Summary of findings: I started my research with trying to find the sex of the skeleton. The most variable bones in sex determination are the pelvis and the skull. In most cases a pelvis of a woman will have a sub-pubic angle of less than 90 and a greater sciatic…
Introduction This case is about Zenova, Germany, which produces healthy and beauty products, is planning to choose a new manager of the team from two candidates (Elliot Smith and Silvia Adams) for taking place of Ryan Douglas. Douglas used to lead a team to work out a investigate about job satisfaction in subsidiary companies. Sixteen members were gathered to compete all these works during 18 months. They were from Europe, South America, the United States, Asia and the Middle East with different…
Anika Porter Period 1 10/17/2014 Case Report Introduction Anna Garcia age 38, height 5’4, Hispanic. Her body was found in the kitchen at her house at 9:56 am on August 14, 2012. She was found lying face down with vomit and blood by her face, there was an unusual white powder found, an aspirin bottle with 2 pills on the floor, a bottled of un-opend orange juice, there were shoe prints and finger prints at the scene, unplunged syringe on the floor, shoes are off by her feet, to her right temple, ankles…
Business Management English Presessional 2014 BME COVER SHEET AND DECLARATION STUDENT ID. No. & FULL NAME 1425908 Wang Yankai BME GROUP No. 9 Assessment Group 3 ASSESSMENT TYPE (e.g.: Assessed Case; Assessed Essay; Feasibility Report…) Assessed Case Study ASSIGNMENT TITLE Problem-Solution Case Report: Parcelforce Worldwide HOME TEACHER Michael Tooke SECOND TEACHER Emilia DATE OF SUBMISSION August 14 TOTAL WORD COUNT 1159 FIRST/FINAL SUBMISSION August 14 D E C L A R A T I O N By completing…
CASE REPORT 1: STARBUCKS Team 8 – Jahanzeb Zafar, Justin Pugel, Satyam Bharadwaj, Anthony Pece CAUSES OF SUCCESS Howard Schultz started from group up In 1981, Howard Schultz (Current Starbucks chairman, president and chief executive officer) had first walked into a Starbucks store. From his first cup of Sumatra, Howard was drawn into Starbucks and joined a year later as the Director of Marketing. A year later, in 1983, Howard traveled to Italy and became captivated with Italian coffee bars and…
------------------------------------------------- Assessment 1 - Case Study Report 1 Question 1: 1 Question 2: 3 Question 3: 4 List of References 5 Assessment 1 - Case Study Report | Case: “The success of the iPod and iPhone raises the licensing question for Apple… Again”(Source: Chap 1, Page 33) Question 1: Use the cyclic Innovation Model (Fig1.9, pg. 30) figure to illustrate the innovation process in this case and provide a brief description. Innovation is not only invented…
METAPHATH SOFTWARE CORP. BRIEFING NOTE FINANCING RECOMMENDATION SEPTEMBER 1997 1. PURPOSE The purpose of this briefing note is to provide recommendations for Metapath Software Corp. (“Metapath”) on its financing offers received in September 1997. These two offers came from 1) a fund consortium led by Robertson Stephens Omega Fund (“RSC”) and Technology Crossover Ventures (“TCV”) and 2) CellTech Communications (“CellTech”), a vendor of wireless technology which had recently gone IPO.…
on increasing store units in order to maximize its reach and proximity. Yet Moon and Quelch present the case of a consumer oriented Starbucks Company that finds itself out of a phase with its customers’ wants and facing growing customer dissatisfaction and who is considering a major $40 million labor investment and subsequent task restructuration in order to remedy it. The analysis of this case will be made from a SWOT perspective after presenting the brand’s value proposition, the milestone of its…