Peter Singer-“Famine, Affluence, and Morality”
In the article, “Famine, Affluence, and Morality,” written by Peter Singer, he elaborates on his views of the East Bengal emergency that took place in 1971. This assignment will discuss Singer’s goal and arguments supporting his position. Provide three counter-arguments addressed by Singer. Define his concept of marginal utility and how it relates to his argument. Then, explain how the ideas of duty and charity are different in Singer’s proposed world as opposed to how they are currently used in our society. Lastly, summarize my argument relating to his position.
Singer’s goals on the East Bengal emergency were the hopes of people coming together to provide aide, not just from the government, but every person around the world. He argued “…the way people in relatively affluent countries react to a situation like that in Bengal cannot be justified; the whole way we look at moral issues—our moral conceptual scheme—needs to be altered, and with it, the way of life that has come to be taken for granted in our society. (Singer, 1971)” Singer believed suffering from the necessities in life (food, shelter, and medical) were in essence immoral and wanted to think people agreed with his position. He thought if it were within a person’s control, they would help. Singer’s presentation of value used was to be walking past a pond and see a drowning child. Morally, he believed you see the child drowning and save the child. He correlated this to his position on the East Bengal emergency. He believed it was that simplistic of a thought that people should want to help people around the world, regardless of their location and/or distinctions, based on moral obligation.
Singer’s position on saving a drowning child is correct, provided an uncontroversial appearance. Most people would not think twice about saving a drowning child. However, it is deceptive as he stated. Where in his claim, (1) “ takes no account of proximity or distance…” and (2) globalization, “…makes no distinction between cases in which I am the only person who could possibly do anything and cases in which I am just one among millions in the same position” (Singer, 1971), and (3) support organizations, to receive charitable contributions, making it less understood by the people as to why they should contribute. Singer believed no matter how near or faraway, it was everyone’s obligation.
Singer’s view that numbers made a difference. He hypothesized if everyone contributed 5 Euro, that it would make a difference. The catch is that everyone should equally contribute to the Bengali Relief Fund. If not, then it would leave it open for some to not donate and others to donate more. Again making it to be the moral duty for all and coming to the realization that not everyone would be willing to do so. This defeats the purpose and continues to leave the Bengalis’ without food. So, in fact, Singer proposed everyone that were in a position to give as much as possible and even to the point that it affected their own well being to include their dependents—this would benefit the Bengalis’.
Singer’s distinction on duty and charity could not be drawn, due to it being outside of his scope. It is understood that giving money to a charitable organization is a generous act. If a person elects not to donate, then they are condemned. He believes people should feel guilty for spending money on themselves, outside of their normal necessities, and not donating to charity. In our society, “Individuals send contributions to charitable organizations when there is a humanitarian crisis, and then these organizations rush trained aid workers into the zone of danger and desperate need. But governments also send help, spending tax money that is coercively collected rather than freely given. (Walzer, 2011)” Although, if people do not donate, they are still not held to a standard nor condemned.
Singer’s
assistance for famine relief and/or other disasters or calamities which may happen. In this document, I will describe Singers objective in his work and give his argument with regards to this problem. I will describe 3 counter-arguments to Singer’s view which he tackles, and after that reveal Singer’s reactions to those counter-arguments. I will explain Singer’s idea of marginal…
would of not be accomplished to become a professional singer (Estes & Swanson, 1999, p.13). His singing work has established fight against many diseases and all over the world, started several musical scholarships for students that are poor to start a profession, and establish a foundation to save children lives in other countries. One of just a few African-American male singers had a top ranked international operatic career as a bass-baritone singer. Simon Estes grew up in Iowa in a house without heat…
best way to spare a great many lives? To Singer, if one is ill-equipped to probe people then they have uncovered a type of segregation on the premise of species, known as speciesism. In this paper the condition for legitimized experimentation utilizing creatures is talked about. Singer expresses that if an examination is really imperative it is satisfactory to utilize a human patient, which has the same subjective level with a creature. In such a case, Singer thinks of it as adequate to substitute…
duties regarding animals whatsoever INCORRECT That our duties towards animals are equal to our duties towards humans That we actually have greater duties to animals than to humans Instructor Explanation: The answer can be found on p. 2 of Tom Regan’s “The Case for Animal Rights” Question 4. Question : According to Mill, utilitarian morality holds that: Student Answer: INCORRECT If each individual strives to maximize their own happiness, the happiness of all will follow…
treatment that we give our own species. In Peter Singer’s essay All Animals Are Equal he argues that we should value the rights of non-humans as much as we do our own species. Singer argues that the mindset of valuing our species more than others is the equivalent to humans that value their own race more than another race (Singer, 1989). The idea that one race is superior to another assumes that every person of one race shares the same characteristics that people of an inferior race do not. This is obviously…
teaching uneducated slaves throughout the North. After the Civil War ended, many teachers headed south to teach the newly freedman. Among those that headed south there were three important men: John Ogden, Reverend Erastus Milo Cravath, and Reverend Edward P. Smith.1 John Ogden served in the Civil War as a second lieutenant in the Second Wisconsin Cavalry. While on duty in Tennessee, he was captured by Confederate forces and spent a few months in a prison camp. This however did not waiver his interest in…
examination. In 1967, “eighty percent of the working class earned under $3,000, and the work week averaged 46 hours” (Foran, p. 2). Furthermore, not only as a whole did about one-fourth of families have severely crowded housing conditions, but in rural areas “one-fourth of all houses lacked running water, and half of all French homes had no bathtub, shower, or inside toilet (Foran, p.2; Singer 1971, 84-85, 87). This evidence suggests that French citizens were not being treated with basic humane standards, resulting…
What is the relationship between religion and morality? It is in my opinion that religion is dependant on morality and not the other way around. Through this, it can be stated that morality reinforces the development and evolution of religion. In this essay, I shall show that this is the case drawing from theories proposed by Plato, Kant and Berg. According to Jonathan Berg, “…a way to construe ethics as depending on religion would be on the basis of a ‘Divine Command Theory’ of ethics, identifying…
20 years, commercial influences on scientific research have become increasingly detrimental. Discuss. Scientific researches play a key role to shape of society because they always supply needs of human and are directed people’s future (Pisano, G. P., 2006). Nowadays, people from all over the world prefer to interest in scientific research more than past. This interest is desired to control by commercial powers that have been harmful for academic landscape. During last decades, powerful companies…
period! Maybe it was the accident of all of us working there because of the Depression. Practically every talent you can name. So many, Jerry Kern, Harry Warren, the Gershwins, Dorothy Fields and Jimmy McHugh, Oscar Hammerstein—even Irving Berlin. ” (p.76) Yes, Irving Berlin, the man who was described as the master of the entire range of popular music, was a member of ASCAP. And his famous song “How Deep Is the Ocean” in 1932 was a representation of the rise of music in 1930s. But ASCAP’s good time…