Teaching Note* to accompany the CasePlace.org module, “Preparing to be the Stakeholder Relationship Manager: The Case of Wal-Mart”
This Teaching Note is for: Level: Undergraduate Courses: Business and Society, Business Ethics, Communications, Organizational Behavior Class size: 20-40 Class format: This unit covers three 90-minute classes Purposes: • To examine social impact management in multiple domains: labor, health care, supplier and competitor relations, and environment • To debate arguments that critique and defend large corporate players that affect wage and product prices • To use the internet for research • To practice oral communication skills Introduction: Students relate well to the Wal-Mart case, most have shopped there, many have read about it in the business and popular press, some have worked there. Because they know the basics about the company, it is possible to engage multiple issues at once, which are often treated singularly, week-by-week in a class: labor, health care, supplier and competitor relations, and environment. Teaching Plan: A detailed description of the pace and assignments for this unit appears in Appendix A. Divide the class into four groups for the four issues or themes. Each group will further sub-divide into those presenting critiques of Wal-Mart and those defending the responses (imagined or actually given) by Wal-Mart. For example, in a class of 40, four groups of 10 enact a debate between two sub-groups of 5 each. Because this module on CasePlace.org is similarly divided by these four themes, students can easily start there for their research. Encourage students to use the internet for this topic, because the stakeholders are very active in this domain and new issues and arguments arise. In addition to CasePlace.org, they can search for other articles.
Prepared by Prof. Maureen Scully, based on an advanced undergraduate elective on “social forces and workplace implications,” taught at the University of Massachusetts Boston, spring 2007.
*
1
Students enjoyed sharing interesting articles they found with their group mates on the opposite side of the issue as well as with other groups pursuing other issues. For the presentations, I used an order that I anticipated would move from the most familiar critiques to newer critiques: low wages, driving out small businesses, health care coverage, and environment. Indeed, the debates about low wages and other businesses (suppliers and competitors) were quite lively, reflecting a long history of argument on both sides of these topics. In the debates on health care and the environment, students defending Wal-Mart had a more difficult time. In the environment discussion, they spoke more to Wal-Mart’s aspirations and promises than to demonstrated impacts. We discussed that Wal-Mart had to invest time, energy, and public relations in addressing all of these stakeholders. Silence on the issues does not seem to be an option. We also discussed where Wal-Mart’s position had shifted and where it would cost them most, least, or nothing to take action on these issues. Wages had not increased, but they were using their influence to create “green” practices (for example, in packaging) down the supply chain, costs largely born by suppliers. In the discussion with the class at large, students were more eager to defend Wal-Mart’s wage and product pricing policies as simply pricing what the market will bear. They seemed to shrug that this was the price of free competition. They argued that both workers and shoppers could “vote with their feet.” In the health care and environment domains, students were much more agitated about Wal-Mart’s impacts. They remembered and had taken notes on vivid details, such as Wal-Mart workers’ needs straining California hospitals and a contaminated ground water problem discovered in Georgia, all of which students had uncovered in their own research. Day 3 is crafted to engage the discussion of Wal-Mart’s market power – is it
MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY KAPLAN UNIVERSITY GB540 UNIT 4 ASSIGNMENT BRENT MALONE MARCH 17, 2015 The purpose of this paper is to discuss an overview of the company Wal-Mart. This paper will include a discussion with an appropriate analysis of the firm’s history, an appropriate analysis of the firm’s recent operating results, an appropriate analysis of the firm’s current operating results, an appropriate analysis of the firm’s economic forces that affect the firm the most and an appropriate…
English 115/76 "Wal-Mart is all about the money" "At Wal-Mart we have a 10 foot attitude." I will too if I steal my employees money. At the Wal-Mart stores they do not only have always low prices, they also have always low wages for their employees. They have a very well structured program to control and train their employees to make them believe that Wal-Mart is a great place to work. I t is crucial that the very first day that you start working at Wal-Mart they play they training-brainwashing…
Company Introduction and Analysis Paper on Wal-Mart By: Team A ECONOMICS FOR BUSINESS I - ECO/360 June 13, 2005 Abstract Wal-Mart has grown to be one of the biggest corporations in the world, employing 1.3 million workers worldwide in 2003 in over 4,300 stores with sales around $256 billion. They sell everything from clothing, tools, toys, electronic goods, appliances and groceries. A major force behind its success was the vision, enterprise and daring of its founder, Sam Walton…
November 25, 2013 Research Paper 091A/Professor Lee Should Wal-Mart harm the economy when it comes to town? In resent years, Wal-Mart has become people’s “daily life”: We drive to Wal-Mart to buy a lot of furniture, eat food there and search the goods in Wal-Mart online. However, one man’s meat is another man’s poison. When Wal-Mart comes to town, it pushes other retailer stores closed. While the goal of Wal-Mart is to make people’s life better, does it really bring advantages to…
Are Wal-Mart's Low Wages A Drag On The Economy? New Report Says Yes According to a study released by Congressional Democrats, U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders argued that the minimum wage should be raised, because the nation's largest private employer Wal-Mart-- routinely pays such low wages .Wal-Mart’s poverty wages are so measly that many of its workers are forced to rely on food stamps, Medicaid and other government aid programs to survive, which costs the American taxpayer over $0.9 to $1.75million…
for HR Pros April 26, 2015 Abstract Wal-Mart prides itself on having one of the strictest and most stringent ethics policies in the industry. Employees are not allowed to accept any type of gift, including a cup of coffee. And its 1.3 million employees are encouraged to report any ethics violations that they might suspect or see. With having such a strict policy, Wal-Mart faces around 5,000 lawsuits a year from unethical business practices. Wal-Mart's rating as a company that consumers trust…
Jim Lee Eng 101: Reames December 2, 2010 Wal-Mart Greatly Impacts the U.S. Economy Is Wal-Mart ruining the local businesses in America? Most professional business men can agree that Wal-Mart affects the United States economy in many different ways. Wal-Mart is an American public corporation that runs a chain of large, discount department stores. It is the world's largest public corporation by revenue according to the 2008 Fortune Global 500. However this corporation has contraverisal issues about…
MBA 6008-Global Economic Environment Final Project: Wal-Mart Capella University Theresa Patterson December 30, 2011 Wal-Mart is a successful retail corporation that is known worldwide. The retail company has created economic benefits for consumers that are extremely tremendous. Wal-Mart has provided more choices for consumers at lower prices in communities where local retail monopolies were evident prior…
Wal-Mart’s Effects on America Wal-Mart has a broad group of likes and dislikes from Americans, but after given the facts I can anticipate most would agree that Wal-Mart is troublesome for America. There are numerous ethical problems with Wal-Mart as well as numerous things that just don’t seem respectable with the company. Wal-Mart is nationally known for having terrible wages for their employees. I believe this is unethical mostly based on the fact that what Wal-Mart pays their full time employees…
Wal-Mart Organizational Behavior March 30, 2013 This paper will discuss the structure of Wal-Mart's corporate culture and how it influences their employees. In order to understand an Organization Behavior there are different elements that will create the employees perspective of the organization’s culture such as the management’s philosophy, vision, values, and goals. The driving force of these elements will create the culture of the organization. An organization’s culture will define…