In the film, The God Delusion, Richard Dawkins presents a view held by many, that religious belief is irrational because it cannot be grounded in empirical evidence. In writings years earlier, William James responds directly to this argument. James offers a different view of the concept of faith. He states that when we have a genuine option that cannot be decided solely on intellectual grounds, our passional nature must be allowed to rule. In this essay, I will argue against Richard Dawkins argument that faith is irrational. I will support James’ claim that pure logic doesn't dictate our beliefs—in fact, we are passionate beings with faith in things that may not seem rational, but are, after all, entirely sensible. Richard Dawkins argues that because God cannot be proven through research and science, He simply does not exist. William James argues directly against this—even as a scientific and logical philosopher. He believes that although many things can be proved through science, there are some concepts that have limits beyond which we can root in the sentiment of rationality.
In his paper, The Will to Believe, James makes his famous distinctions concerning options. He claims we all have options for belief, and he breaks them down into three categories. The option, or any proposed belief, can be either “living or dead.” If an option is dead, then it is completely unappealing to us—reasons and judgment do not matter in dead options. If someone asks me if I believe in Judaism, I will have nothing to base my answer off of. But if someone asks me if I believe in God, I can give reason, I can judge my decision based on science or critical thinking, or even belief. Therefore, an option of belief must be living.
The second category is “forced vs. avoidable.” It’s pretty clear what this means. An avoidable decision is whether you are going to have a family in 10 years—you do not know, you must wait and see. A forced decision is one that must be made at that point in time. Will you go to the grocery store with your mom? This is a forced option; an answer must be given. The decision of faith is forced—you believe or you do not believe.
The last category is “trivial or momentous.” A trivial option is one where making a wrong decision does not matter much in the grand scheme of things. Should I wear brown shoes or black shoes today? If my outfit is a little mix-matched, it is not the end of the world. A momentous option is one in which a wrong decision carries huge consequences. Give me all of your money or die, is definitely a momentous decision to all of us. These three categories of options make up the genuine option. The genuine option is one that is living, forced, and momentous. James uses this background information to construct his main argument: when one cannot use one’s own intellect to solve a genuine option, one must emotionally decide. This is where his concept of faith is born. When we cannot rely on science or logic to make a life changing decision, we must look inside ourselves. The most important answers to questions do not lie in textbooks, they lie in our hearts. When we are deciding what to believe in respect to religion, we must inspect ourselves—our emotions, our passions, our faith.
In response to all of James’ argument, Dawkins would be skeptic. He would still question faith because it cannot be rooted in evidence. James, in his view of skepticism, would say that skepticism is not avoiding the option of faith; rather it is an option in of itself. It is choosing
Related Documents: The Will, and the Rationale, to Believe Essay
Provide a rationale for your response. • Imagine that you own a small catering company. Your company is applying for a contract to cater a state congressional luncheon. Determine the three (3) most significant cost factors that you should take into account as the contractor. Provide a rationale for your response. stion. Provide a rationale to support your response. week 6 “Contract Cost and Profit Principle, and Contract…
handicaps and/or special challenges. The study made use of a mixed method design for research. An overview shows that home schooling does have many academic advantages for the students when compared with having a traditional educational process. Rationale: This article was chosen because the goal of study is to determine if home school could be an option for administrators. The focus is to have it be an alternative for students who would normally be distractions to themselves or other students in…
need for unbiased financial reporting. Based on your analysis, determine at least two (2) drivers that may cause financial reporting to be biased. Provide a rationale to support your response. • Analyze the audit opinion formulation process and suggest at least one (1) improvement to the process to strengthen audit opinions. Provide a rationale to support your suggestion. ACC 562 Week 2 Discussion "Topic of Discussion"…
Developmental Age: Patient Presentation: Include historical information including family history and genetic considerations, background as well as symptomology and tentative diagnosis. Questions you MUST answer, providing scholarly sources for rationales. 1. Thorough and concise pathophysiology description showing connection to manifestations or signs and symptoms of the client. 2. Focused physical assessment findings for this client. Include normal results and as well as abnormal based…
Schizophrenia (NCP)Nursing Care Plan-Disturbed Thought Processes Nursing actions Rationale Encourage same staff to work with client as much as possible To promote development of trusting relationship Avoid physical contact. Suspicious clients may perceive touch as a threatening gesture. Avoid laughing, whispering, or talking quietly where client can see but not hear what is being said. Suspicious clients often believe others are discussing them, and secretive behaviors reinforce the paranoid feelings…
functions (i.e., finance, marketing, and operations), and then justify the interdependence that operations have to finance and marketing. Provide examples to support your rationale. The major functions of Verizon Wireless are key to their success. The finance area of Verizon…
Create a scenario where you believe the use of high-risk investments would be beneficial for the investor. Provide support for your rationale. Use four (4) external resources to support your work. Note: Wikipedia and other Websites do not qualify as academic resources. Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements: Be typed…
5. Recommend a performance appraisal method that you believe would be the most effective for the organization and support the reasons for your decision. Provide support for your recommendation. 6. Create a strategy to effectively manage both performance- and behavioral-based employee problems, which will lead…
A. DSM IV CRITERIA DSM-IV-TR Criteria for Dissociative Disorders: Dissociative identity disorder. Presence of two or more identities or personalities that take control of the person’s behavior; loss of memory for important personal information. B. DESCRIPTION OF THE CHARACTER INFLICTED WITH THE PSYCHIATRIC DISORDER Sybil Dorsett, the character in the movie inflicted with the psychiatric disorder Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), is a very simple woman who due to her love for painting…
"Legal Requirements of Fair Pay Programs" Please respond to the following: •As an HR professional, recommend at least three (3) steps you can take to ensure that your company's pay program is fair and equitable. Provide a rationale for your response. Review your job descriptions for accuracy and completeness. Compare them to advertised job postings for similar positions to ensure they contain comparable duties, skills and qualifications. Search similar positions and salary levels on job boards and…