The perils of free trade Free trade is a policy that does not restrict economic activity. Most countries have contracted free trade agreements (FTA), such as NAFTA (the North American Free Trade Agreement) and APTA (Asia-Pacific Trade Agreement), which have established open markets. As the world has been globalized, free trade has been a crucial issue regarding the international economy. However, developed countries force developing countries to contract free trade agreements. Although a free trade agreement does not restrict exports and imports and brings economic benefits to nations, developed countries get benefits while developing countries do not. Free trade has negative impacts on developing countries’ labor markets, environments, and economies.
First of all, free trade has negative effects on developing countries’ labor markets. Free trade causes a decrease in employment because of tariff. Free trade includes tariff cuts, so the price of imported foreign goods is relatively lower than the domestic manufactured goods. Therefore, producers have to cut costs and reduce employment to compete with the price of foreign products. Bogliaccini (2013) states that in the short term, employment increases in export countries. In the long run, however, employment decreases because domestic products are replaced by imported products from the trade partner countries. It identifies that free trade contributes to expanding employments at least in the short run, but affects labor markets negatively, in the long run. Bogliaccini (2013) also states that the percentage of employment in industry in Latin America decreased from thirty-four percent to twenty-seven percent during the twenty years between 1980 and 2000. It shows that free trade results in unemployment in developing countries. In addition, free trade does not protect the rights of workers who have to receive fair treatment in terms of hiring conditions, working conditions, and social welfare. In particular, female and young workers in developing countries are threatened by unfair working conditions. They do not receive protection according to fair labor standards. Needleman (2013) identifies that when firms lay off workers to cut cost, female workers tend to be laid off before male workers. The female workers do not get fair rights as same as male workers. He also states that student workers receive low wages, no welfare, and unstable employment. The students work in risky work places that are tightly packed and unsafe. Accordingly, free trade results in increasing unemployment and risks in working conditions.
In addition to labor markets, free trade affects developing countries’ environments badly. Free trade increases developing countries agricultural production from their exports of agricultural products such as rice, corn and rubber. However, the increase of produced crops increases in using pesticides, fertilizers, water, and land. It results in soil erosion and destroys soil nutrients. According to Suphaphong and Gao (2009), it was found that there was an accumulation of salt in soil and the salinity exceeded critical levels in Thailand. It was also found that salinity exceeded standard levels in cultivation ponds, and tanks. The excess amount of salt in soil connects to the lack of soil nutrients and impact on plant growth. For example, malnutrition causes stunted growth of rice and corn. They have thinner grains, and even stop growing. Furthermore, the increase in industrial manufacturing increases the use of chemicals and raw materials which cause pollution, greenhouse gases and waste. Suphaphong and Gao (2009) also pointed out that free trade would cause an increase in CO2 emissions. In the case of Thailand, CO2 emissions increased by 0.07% and particulate matter (PM10) emissions increased by 0.41% after making a FTA with the U.S. This indicates that structural changes in economic policies affect the level of CO2 emissions. As the industries of developing countries
In Defense of Globalization was written by Jagdesh Bhagwati, an acclaimed international trade economist and *cue spooky music* Council On Foreign Relations Fellow. The inside cover even claims that this is a "Council On Foreign Relations" book. It's no surprise that I picked it up, then. What struck me the most early on in the book was the language barrier: Bhagwati's first language is clearly not English. It is hard to hold that against him, but the crudeness of some of his writing is painfully…
Swiss shareholders. Foreigners holding Nestlé bearer shares were exposed to political risk in a country that is widely viewed as a haven from such risk. The Nestlé episode illustrates both the importance of considering market imperfections and the peril of political risk. 1-9 What’s Special about “International” Finance? Expanded Opportunity Set – It doesn’t make sense to play in only one corner of the sandbox. – True for corporations as well as individual investors. 1-10 Goals for…
on controlling the market because of the lack of interventions from the government and immature law system (Week1). Big business profoundly influenced many aspects in the government such as tax and trade departments, which helped these giant corporations take over the economy indirectly from the free market. Andrew Carnegie (November 25, 1835 – August 11, 1919)and his steel empire might be the biggest example of US big business. He had dominated the entire steel industry by late 19th century. “Eliminating…
Mitt Romney: The Better President? Some people may argue that Mitt Romney had made a big mistake when he ran for president in 2012, but as often as people say that others agree that he should give it a second shot in the 2016 elections. It is debatable whether or not he will achieve the new face as president of the United States for 2016, but since he had experience the close front of elections (48.8 to 48.1 votes to Obama), strong sources can support whether he will evolve from a candidate…
explosion of cotton with “the invention of the cotton gin by Eli Whitney in 1793.”[HO] The cotton boom created a need for northerners to build factories. The invention of the steamboat by Robert Fulton which allowed the northern and southern states to trade in much shorter times and establish a trading schedule was a big addition to the factories which created a big labor force. The last key topic was the issue of national security both foreign and domestic. With the passing of Jay’s and Pinckney’s treaties…
by the 1 economist Jagdish Bhagwati. The two works have a similar orientation and motivation and a shared view of villains and heroes. Both restrict their attention to economic globalization, understood broadly to mean the liberalization of trade in goods, capital, ideas, and people within a multilateral and market-oriented framework. Both denounce its critics for their hostility to liberalism or capitalism. Wolf claims that these antiglobalization critics—the ‘‘new millennium collectivists…
major trade product from Asia | spices | Spanish conqueror like Cortez and Pizarro | conquistador | European settlement; American was this to England | colony | global trade between eastern and western hemispheres | Columbian Exchange | slaves worked on these in the new world | plantations | term for gold and silver during the Age of Exploration | bullion | 3 legs of trade between Africa, New World, and Europe | Triangular trade | leg of triangular trade when…
consumer to take reasonable care”. This precedent has evolved and now forms the basis of laws that protect consumers from contaminated or faulty goods. These protections began as common law but many have since been codified in legislation, such as the Trade Practices Act (Commonwealth, 1974). Neighbour principle. Thirdly, the Donoghue v. Stevenson case produced Lord Atkin’s controversial ‘neighbour principle’, which extended the tort of negligence beyond the tortfeasor and the immediate party. It raised…
they were obliged to permit the slave-trade and to receive the slaves. Jefferson's original draft of the Declaration of Independence made it one of the chief articles of indictment against George the Third that he had " prostituted his negative for suppressing every legislative attempt to prohibit or to restrain this execrable commerce." [...] Before this tremendous development of cotton culture had taken place, slavery had hardly had more than habit and the perils of emancipation to support it in the…
all, military aid” (82). Along with this came the Marshall plan, which laid out the specifics of the aid that would be given to Europe. These measures ensured that U.S. trade with Europe would stay steady, that “Western control over Middle Eastern oil supplies” would remain intact, and most of all, that Europeans would now be free from economic burdens “so they could help the United States militarily” (88). All these changes coincide with the policy of containment. “Containment meant building up…