The topic of justice remains a debatable subject within the book The Republic of Plato. There are three definitions that have been discussed, including Thrasymachus a sophist whose view on justice is the "advantage of the strong", and Cephalus and Polemarchus' views on justice being "giving to each what is owed" or "helping friends and harming enemies". All of these views have been discussed and thoroughly debated, interestingly enough the majority of the commentary in the book consisted of Socrates criticizing the other characters definitions without mentioning his own explanation of justice. However, eventually he does bring up an interesting principle of specialization; in his opinion justice is state in which each person performs the role which they are naturally best suited for. For instance, a carpenter must only build thing and farmer must only farm and be concerned with agriculture. According to Socrates this principle of specialization allows everything to be done at the highest level possible. With this though in mind, Socrates begins to build the foundations of the “healthy” city. To contradict his view he also creates the “feverish” city to explain the repercussions of a city full of luxuries. In essence, the cities that Socrates creates provide insight into his political philosophy and definition of justice. For instance, in the “healthy” city only necessities of life are accepted like food, clothing, health and shelter. Thus, according to the principle of specialization the citizens of the city would be participating in their roles in the “producing class” because their role is to produce objects for use. Also, these craftsmen, doctors, and farmers must complete their jobs without interfering or engaging in any other role. Only in this way, Socrates is convinced, can everything be done at the highest level possible. The healthy city consists only of producers whose only role is to produce what is absolutely necessary for life. The advantages of this type of city are that if everyone is specifically assigned to a role that is best for them naturally they should be happy with their position in society. The citizens would be content with what they provide society with and this happiness would lower the risk of conflict. Since every citizen is responsible to develop a particular skill and to strive toward excellence at that particular craft the healthy city accepts their own natural abilities and acknowledges that each citizen does not have equal abilities. The disadvantages of this type of city are people do not have the ability to choose their own lifestyle, wealth or occupation. Much of the citizen’s lives who live in the “healthy” city would be predetermined from birth and this could lead to unhappiness. Glaucon points out that the type of city is impossible and he even goes on to call it the “city of pigs” since people naturally have both necessary and unnecessary needs. Continuing this further, he argues that people naturally have a desire to want more and crave r rich food, luxurious surroundings, and art. In a similar manner, based on Socrates definition of justice as a state in which every individuals performs a role that is naturally best suited for them” from his outlook there would be very little opportunity for injustice to occur. However, as previously mentioned citizens would only have on responsibility, farmer would farm and doctors would heal the sick, but the people who had multiple talents would be limited to one job and this can be considered unjust. In fact many people believe that “there is nothing worse in the world than wasted talent”. Socrates’ “healthy city is positive in the sense that it promotes selflessness and places a particular emphasis on only having what is necessary, however it is negative because its structure limits its citizens to fully explore and develop their talents and enjoy the luxuries of life. Continuing this further, it was obvious that Socrates had the right
Related Documents: Justice In The Republic Of Plato
nge glare and this is the scene the first part of the novel renders in my head. The city and the city depict a unique city in the world, Besz. It is a city that occupies the same physical space as another city — a more prosperous city, with different architecture, different colors, different language, different laws: Ul Qoma. Citizens are trained from earliest childhood to unsee the other city — not to notice its inhabitants, its traffic accidents, its cooking smells. Crossing borders means Breach…
12 December 2014 Lifestyle Country by the grace of God or born & raised in the city? Sometimes it depends on where you grew up and sometimes it depends on the pros and cons of each lifestyle. There are many differences between the two and all are important to be considered. Green bean casserole or eating out? Personal preference or tradition? It all depends on the person… Or does it? Though most people live in the city and prefer that lifestyle, it is important to consider both citylife and countrylife before choosing which to favor…
A City Of Boredom It’s great to be in a state that has such a reputation of having the greatest time of your life. Louisiana is known for its: Food, Music, and Culture. Which brings a lot of activities like: Mardi gras, Bayou Bowl, and other things. These theme are usually and always held down south in New Orleans. But what do you do when you’re from a city that 6 hours away and doesn’t have a lot to offer? Monroe, Louisiana which is home to The University of Louisiana Monroe is a great city with…
assessment-Describe a city I am standing. Standingm in my grand, lonely hotel room. I take time. Time to be cut off from my busy, bothered life; my ordinary life that is never fascinating, imaginative, or the least bit interesting and I just stare. I reach out and yank the squeaky, clean window handle wide open. Letting in a sudden whoosh of crisp, fresh air that almost leaves me in a dizzy daze. I gaze right out through the curious, city that is off course, Las Vegas; but is this city all that it is…
– 105February, 06, 2013The City of Tifton One place I’ve been that has been siginificant to me is the town of Tifton. Tifton is asmall town in the state of Georgia, and is nicknamed “the reading capitol of the world” . Tifton is a very old looking town that has old parts that makes it look like it’s a town that hasn’t aged a bit.If you passed through Tifton, you would see a few modern stores like mcdonalds,walmart, etc, but as you get deeper you would see lots of very old looking buildings…
In the late 1970s, cultural theorist Michel de Certeau wrote an essay, "Walking in the City," that begins with the author standing at the top of the World Trade Center looking out over Manhattan. From this vantage point, the city is offered up as a whole, graspable image, in contrast with the messy, meandering city that one moves through down below. "Down below" is the realm of lived experience, inhabited by walkers, Wandersmanner, who use and transform space, defying the geometrical discipline imposed…
automobiles, but production had been shifted to help with the war efforts (jeeps, weapons, etc), pent up demand was created for the automobile. Concentric Ring/Zone Model E.W. Burgess 1920 1920: Novelty Stage of Automobiles, cars had little impact on city development. Not many ppl living in CBD district and low income residents live closest to CBD and the “Zone of Transition” (the area of the old industrial core) Wealthiest people were the only ones who could afford living far from CBD.…
people will find a place to go to distract themselves from reality for just a little while, some create memories in those places along the way. My friends and I are not different, we chose a very particular place in the Downtown area of Salt Lake City. It has been our “gossip spot” and our regular visits makes the week better. The little 2 floor square building in the corner of 600 South and West temple is not your typical coffeehouse. The entire block is a parking lot and at first glance it seems…
Jennifer Brennecka English 102-054 Assignment 20 November 20, 2014 Can a City in the Desert be the Most Sustainable City in the World? (1) Beautiful Dubai, just like an oasis in the desert. Over the last two decades, the city of Dubai has been developing projects that incorporate sustainability, won awards, and has reshaped the planet. You can actually see Dubai from space. Dubai has been the center of attention around the world for their innovative and awe-inspiring transformations. If you had a…
Introduction Recently, the interest in innovative development and the need for cities and countries to image position or re-position have been accelerated. The major reason is significant for various advantages domestically and internationally in economic, political, social and cultural development terms (Kotler and Gertner, 2002). According to (Boult, 2014), holistically building a place can attracts multiple and diverse stakeholders such as business, tourism, and citizens. Trueman, Klemm and Giroud…