(4) Superpower Geographies
4.1 Superpower Geographies
4.1.1 What is a superpower?
Superpowers are countries with disproportionate power and influence so that they have more than the rest of the world and thus are the biggest decision makers. Superpowers are usually large countries in terms of population and physical extent. Physical size may provide a natural resource base that the superpower can thus exploit and draw on to develop their power and influence further. These countries have global influence with the world as their backyards, and other countries treat them with respect in the face of such power. Currently, there is only one true superpower – the USA.
The table below highlights the USA in comparison with the rest of the world in 2008 (since grown):
The USA
Rest of the World
USA as a % of the world
Population
305 million
6.5 billion
4.6%
GDP
$13.8 trillion
$40.8 trillion
25%
Military spending
$711 billion
$759 billion
48%
Number of the world’s 2000 largest TNCs
598
1,402
30%
Carbon dioxide emissions
6 billion tonnes
27 billion tonnes
22%
“a superpower must be able to conduct a global strategy… to command vast economic potential and influence and present a universal ideology” (Professor Paul Dukes, University of Aberdeen)
The definition emphasises:
The global nature of superpower status
The economic power of superpowers
The political and cultural viewpoint or vision/ideology that a superpower projects on the world
Superpowers have economic, cultural and military power resulting in global political influence. Other types of powers may not be as influential and do not dictate decisions:
1. Emerging superpowers – these have a growing influence, e.g. China. China has a growing economy and military power but less cultural influence than the americanisation and westernisation influence of the USA. The EU has considerable power, but EU decisions and policies are often compromises because they must be the collective view of 27 member states
2. Emerging powers – these are further away from superpower status. They include a re-emerging Russia, India, arguably Brazil, and the Persian Gulf States. These have powerful resources such as energy, but not an entire set of influential factors required
3. Regional powers –these play an important role in economic and political processes on their continent –e.g. south Africa and Japan
4.1.2 Maintaining power
International influence has to be maintained. Superpowers do this using different mechanisms, some of which are hard (overt) and some of which are soft (more subtle).
Superpowers use hard power mechanisms because these are the most obvious and threatening. The USA has an enormous military reach around the world giving it more military power than any other nation. Its military are present on every continent except Antarctica (but the USA has kept a permanently manned scientific base at the south pole since 1957 and in 2003 opened a new $150million base, reinforcing it’s superpower credentials). The NATO military alliance provides the USA with allies in North America (Canada), Europe and the Middle East. NATO was important during the Cold War period when the USSR was considered the USA’s superpower enemy over the possession of nuclear firearms.
4.1.3 Changing Geographies
The geography of superpowers changes over time as old superpowers decline and new ones emerge. The number of superpowers in existence at any one time can also change:
A uni-polar world is one dominated by one superpower
Bi-polar world is one where two opposing superpowers exist
Multi-polar world is one with three or more superpowers
Timescale
Superpower (s)
Comment
1800-1918
British Empire
The UK is the dominant global power, at one point controlling around 25% of the land area of the world
1918-1945
Transition Period
Increasing power in the USA and Russia, the rise of Nazi-Germany and the maintenance of the power of the British empire; arguably a multi-polar period
1945-1990
USA and USSR
is the fourth-largest in total area, the fifth largest in the contiguous area and third in population. It is one of the world's most ethnically diverse and multicultural nations, the product of large-scale immigration from many countries.[12] The geography and climate of the U.S. is also extremely diverse, with deserts, plains, forests, and mountains that are home to a wide variety of wildlife. Paleo-indians migrated from Asia to what is now the United States mainland around 12,000 years ago. European…
Summer, 2012 GEOGRAPHY BEHIND THE HEADLINES: Geographical Foundations to Current Issues Instructor: Dr. Victor Konrad, Loeb B343; 613 520 2600 extension 2563 (office hours only); victor_konrad@carleton.ca Office Hours: Tuesdays and Thursdays, 16:30-17:30 or by appointment Lecture Class: Tuesdays and Thursdays, 18:05-20:55/ 6:05-8:55 pm in 409 SA Prerequisite: Second year standing or permission Course Description: Geography matters in the events…
Political Geography: Key Issue 4 Where are States Distributed Rubenstein, pp. 286-295 The Cold War (1940’s-1990’s) 1. Who were the two main superpowers during the Cold War? United States (NATO) “First World” Soviet Union (Warsaw Pact) “Second World” Neutral: “Third World” 2. How has the nature of both alliances and warfare changed since the end of the Cold War? Warfare is less often conventional and more often state vs organization or internal within state Alliances are more often economic…
Lesson One Homework 1. Discuss the problems that “geographic illiteracy” can present to a country such as the United States in the Twenty-First Century. Give examples of the need for geographic knowledge in diverse areas such as international politics, domestic politics, economics, and popular culture. Geographic Illiteracy by definition is not having geographic knowledge. For example, not being to point out where the United States is on the map or where the Pacific Ocean is located. Geographic…
Energy security Overview ENERGY SECURITY Why is energy security a problem for the world? Energy supply, demand and security Investigate the different types of energy, classification and their impacts. What is the distribution of energy resources? What are the trends in global energy and demand? Why is energy security rising? The impacts of energy insecurity What are the developments in energy infrastructure? What are the tensions, costs and conflicts of energy insecurity…
The Battle of Stalingrad The battle of Stalingrad may have very well been the most important battle over the course of World War II. Not necessarily remembered for its course of fighting, the battle is more known for its outcome. Not only did the battle turn out to be a major turning point in the war, it may have saved most of Eastern Europe from incomparable destruction. The battle included two of the biggest political and military icons of their time, Stalin and Hitler. World War II was seen…
I. Terns associated with Russia; 1. Russification: The Soviet policy of resettling Russians into non-Russian portions of the Soviet Union, also changed the region’s human geography. Millions of Russians were given economic and political incentives to move elsewhere in the Soviet Union in order to increase Russian dominance in many of the outlying portions of the country. The spread of Russian politics and cultures. 2. Imperialism: An unequal human and territorial relationship, usually in the form…
America’s role in the world. The isolationists wanted no part of the League of Nations, while the interventionists wanted America to assert its role in the world as a superpower. The isolationists won out and America did not join the League of Nations. Not until the end of WWII, did America begin to assert its role as a global superpower. After the First World War and the Great Depression after it, Americans did not want a Third World War. This led to the U.S.’s policies during the Cold War such as…
the U.N. Security Council. China is also a member of numerous formal and informal multilateral organizations, including the WTO, APEC, BRICS, the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, the BCIM and the G-20. China has been characterized as a potential superpower by a number of academics,[19] military analysts,[20][21] and public policy and economics analysts.[22][23] The word "China" is derived from Persian Cin (چین), which is from Sanskrit Cīna (चीन).[26] It is first recorded in 1516 in the journal…
For centuries, Central Europe had always been a subject of concern and an interest to countries and territories that border the area. Whether the area is in the form of separate individual states or a unified country under one ruler, Central Europe is the heart of Europe and it affects the whole Europe economically, politically, and militarily. This “German” question of whether having a unified country or separate states continues to resurface other familiar questions as history repeats itself once…