Article Critique of:
‘Human predators outpace other agents of trait change in the wild’ by Darimont et al.
In this study by Darimont et al. (2008), the authors’ goal was to understand the impact of human harvesting on wild populations. They tested this by comparing observed changes in exploited systems with those subject to natural or other anthropogenic perturbations in the wild. They also looked into which harvesting characteristics produce the most rapid phenotypic changes. The main findings were that phenotypic changes in human predator systems are much more rapid than both natural and other anthropogenic perturbations, and that these changes were found to be more abrupt in commercially exploited systems than in recreational or scientific harvests. The importance of this study is that it provides insight on the extent of the influence human exploitation can have on the wild populations and thus on ecological dynamics.
The study was conducted by combining data from published studies on phenotypic changes of different species. Using the extracted data, rates of phenotypic change (termed ‘Darwins’) were calculated. Darwins were then plotted against time in millions of years. ANCOVA analysis was used to compare the three different rates of phenotypic changes in human harvesting, natural and other anthropogenic perturbations, and to see if there were any interactions between them. They also used AIC with human predator data to compare models with different variables including years, trait type, capture method, and harvest mode.
One flaw observed in their methodology was that ‘magnitudes’ (proportional changes in traits) that were said to be calculated were not used in any analyses. Showing the calculations for ‘magnitude’ seemed meaningless as only Darwins were used to plot and analyze the results. Nevertheless, their analysis that designates human as the most significant driver of change reflects their findings that showed biggest phenotypic change due to human exploitation.
However, in order to contribute to the accuracy of their findings, a different approach could have been taken by using Haldanes in place of Darwins. The article indicated that they did not calculate Haldanes as the collected data lacked values required for the calculation, but better selection of data could have made this calculation available. With the set of Darwins alone, the results can be arbitrary as it assumes that evolution takes place in million-year time scales. Using Haldanes that uses time interval counted in generations can account for better results as evolution can clearly takes place over shorter period of time.
For the most part I agree with the authors’ findings that describes humans as a
Related Documents: Research Article Critique Essay examples
Week 3 Research Critique, Part 1 To purchase this tutorial visit here: http://mindsblow.us/question_des/NRS-433VWeek3ResearchCritiquePart1/2854 contact us at: help@mindblows.us NRS-433V Week 3 Research Critique, Part 1 Introduction to Nursing Research – Theory, Design, and Sampling Prepare a critical analysis of a qualitative study focusing on the problem statement, study purpose, research question, literature review, and theoretical framework. This can be one of the selected articles from your…
on and making meaning of a range of complex information in the health care environment...” (ACU, 2010, p. 1). • What is ‘making meaning’? – Understanding complex information – Being able to critique complex information • To do this: – You need to understand how knowledge is developed. – You need to be able to critique that knowledge. 3 1 18/02/2015 What is critical thinking? • There are many definitions. • critical thinking in Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary – “...1. The ability to interpret argument…
Running head: EARLY CHILDHOOD OUTCOMES OF LATE PRETERM INFANTS 1 Early Childhood Outcomes of Late Preterm Infants: Critique and Personal Reflection Rori Ross Liberty University EARLY CHILDHOOD OUTCOMES OF LATE PRETERM INFANTS 2 Early Childhood Outcomes of Late Preterm Infants: Critique and Personal Reflection Pregnancy is often described as one of the most cherished moments of a parent’s life. You spend months preparing for the arrival of your new bundle of joy. Deciding…
Critique of Research Studies – Part 1 Grand Canyon University Health Care Research Analysis and Utilization Nur-504 February 1st, 2013 Critique of Research Studies – Part 1 Title – Backrest Angle and Cardiac Output Measurement in Critically Ill Patients (Quantitative) An effective title of a quantitative research article should include the dependent variables, the independent variables, and the population studied. Ideally, this should be…
Journal articles are one of the ways in which psychologists in the field communicate with one another about their research findings. It is important to be able to identify the main findings, decipher the research methods, and understand the implications of the research. Additionally, it is important to be able to recognize the differences, strengths, and weaknesses between correlational and experimental research. Your Assignment: You will select two research articles from peer-reviewed journals…
inspires art.” The Guardian. Friday 15 August 2014. Web. 28 January 2015. The article critiques on the relationship between environmental pollution in China and the art that the Chinese artist Cai Guoqiang created. Duggan’s article demonstrates powerfully on how the artist Cai Guoqiang interpret his understanding of the environmental issue in China. The article also mentioned that the beauty of ancient China. The article is really helpful to the exhibition essay because Cai has a similar understanding…
and MAT 115 or PSY 206 Course skills: basic knowledge of biology/microbiology and basic understanding of statistics. Course Description and format: The course covers the scope of epidemiology; designing, planning and analysis in epidemiologic research, design strategies, measurement of exposure, measuring disease occurrence, statistical association and causality, and epidemiological study designs. Principles of Epidemiology 211 will meet twice a week. Classes will include lectures, group discussions…
BEFORE Thanksgiving! Since this paper is optional, if you are doing it, it is because you want and/or need the practice (and points), so this will be doubly beneficial in preparing you for the Exit Exam—“two birds—one stone.” Please use the essay “A Critique of Positive Psychology” as the basis for your test questions. The following are “stem questions” from the actual exams. You MUST use this specific format to receive full credit—no exceptions! You will also submit an Answer Key with the correct…
Unit six is about writing critiques, such as book reviews and evaluating articles. The audience that is targeted by this book are students, it helps them in improving their English language. This unit have a methodology that students can apply to help them make their book reviews. Firstly, one of the positive things is that the author gives many examples for demonstrations and the unit contains many helpful tasks, and have the meanings of new words such as the word critique and where it is from. In…
http://thechart.blogs.cnn.com/2011/08/16/even-a-little-exercise-could-improve-health/?iref=allsearch Researchers from Taiwan’s National Health Research Institutes found that individuals who exercised an average of 92 minutes a week had 14 percent reduced mortality compared with inactive people. This extended to three more years of life expectancy, according to the study published in the Lancet o What type of study was performed? Observational study o How many subjects were involved in the…