Power is something that has been fought over for centuries. In ancient times, there was a struggle between which power, the law of Gods or the law of courts, held more jurisdiction relating to the punishments of wrongdoings. The contradiction between the Apology and Crito is one of many different perspectives. In the Apology, Socrates tells the courts that if they order him to stop philosophizing that he would not obey these laws. This proves to be inconsistent with Crito. Socrates states that he will not escape imprisonment prior to death because that would injure the city of Athens. On the outside, this may seem to be easily classified as a contradiction. When looking deeper into the readings, however, his reasoning becomes clear. Instead of placing importance on the authority of Athens itself, Socrates follows the word of the God of Apollo.
In the Apology, Socrates tells of the oracle saying no one is wiser than he. Socrates does not offend the people of Athens consciously. He is trying to understand what only the oracle sees. “…when the god ordered me, as I thought and believed, to live the life of a philosopher, to examine myself and others, I had abandoned my post for fear of death or anything else. That would have been a dreadful thing, and then I might truly have justly been brought here for not believing that there are gods, disobeying the oracle, fearing death, and thinking I was wise when I was not.” (Apology 29 a-b) To begin, Socrates clearly states to the courts that these are things he believes in. There wasn’t a point in time when he doubted the belief of the Gods. This was shoved into the trial in a later time when Melletus was contradicting himself during Socrates’ questioning. The formal charges came as irreligion and corruption of youth. Secondly, if Socrates did not obey the oracle, it would be a just reason to be
Related Documents: Plato: The Trial and Death of Socrates Essay
Socrates was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens and sentenced to die for his beliefs. From the writings of his followers that were preserved, he was portrayed as accepting of this punishment because he truly thought what he believed was right. The trial of Socrates proved to be an important part in history, impacting the development of Western Philosophy and allowing the beliefs of Socrates to live on to this day. Socrates’ life, trial, and death are all important parts of history and coincide…
matter is the only reality and that things like the mid, thought, and feeling can be explained in terms of matter and physical phenomena Reason-the capacity of consciously making sense of things, applying logic, for establishing and verifying facts. Socrates The sophists Specialized in philosophy and rhetoric Ancient Greece Taught people how to be wise for money Believed in knowledge, but liked money Philosophy in the marketplace-…
Socrates, an ancient Greek philosopher, was a man seen in various ways by many. The diverse personalities given to him by others have drawn both praise and criticism. There are many literary works that portray Socrates to be an all-knowing educator as well as corrupt and immoral teacher. In Aristophanes’ “The Clouds”, he takes a satirical approach showing Socrates as a sophisticated, yet impatient teacher that used his knowledge of philosophy and rhetoric in his teaching techniques to educate individuals…
discuss the argument of Socrates being a corrupter of the youth of Athens and does not receive the gods of Athenian belief but introduces other divinities. To corrupt the youth Socrates would have had to do them harm, which he did not. Socrates claims if he did corrupt the youth he did so unknowingly. (Plato’s Apology 125) Meletus claims that Socrates is an atheist that does not believe in the gods of the state. (Plato’s Apology 143) In my essay I will argue that Socrates was not an evil-doer and…
The Phaedo, written by the famous Greek philosopher Plato, is a dialogue recounting the events and discussions of Socrates’ final moments before his sentenced death from the well-known trial recognized as The Apology. During this time, Socrates explains to his friends that acquiring knowledge comes from a recollection of things in a previous life as a way to provide comfort to his friends about his anticipated death. According to Socrates, if humans can learn anything, they must have known about…
History 11/25/14 Socrates Socrates has been and still is the leader of thinking for generations. His particular way of thinking was the origin of Western philosophy today. Socrates did not record any of his encounters or dialogues. His followers were the ones who are now held responsible for recording his dialogues and life experiences. In this essay I will, obviously, be basing my knowledge off the writings of Socrates’ followers. I feel I could write a much better essay if Socrates had written his…
dialog set in an Athenian prison. It takes place after the trial of Socrates but before his execution. In this dialog, Socrates is visited by his close friend Crito who is trying to convince Socrates for the last time that it is in his best interest to try and escape from prison. Through their discussion we find that Crito presents Socrates with arguments for why he should attempt an escape. Crito’s first argument states that if Socrates does not escape, he will be losing a very good friend. In addition…
the apology, Plato tells the story of Socrates and his trial which the Athenian government sent him to death penalty. Socrates was a peaceful man who has his own morality and willing to face the jury with a certain possibility of death to maintain his integrity and beliefs. Socrates’ philosophical questions made the leaders of society appear to be unknowledgeable. Because of this he was accused of introducing new deities that made the Athenian government sent him to trial. Socrates understood his…
of Greek Philosophy, it is best to take a look into the life of Socrates first. Socrates, (469-399 BCE), was among three very influential philosophers for the Greeks and his work is still studied at length today. He believed in enjoying life and also that truth, beauty, and justice have objective content and that we are born with an innate understanding of their existence. (www.watson.org). The term Socratic Irony came from Socrates claiming that he knew nothing and this form of feigning ignorance…
CHAPTER 3: SOCRATES, PLATO Main Points 1. Plato (c. 427–347 B.C.) was the pupil of Socrates (470–399 B.C.), and Aristotle (384–322 B.C.) was the pupil of Plato. Socrates 2. Socrates was not interested in arguing with his fellow Athenians merely for the sake of argument—as the Sophists were—but rather he wanted to discover the essential nature of knowledge, justice, beauty, goodness, and the virtues (such as courage). 3. The Socratic (dialectic) method: a search for the proper definition of…