The Phaedo, written by the famous Greek philosopher Plato, is a dialogue recounting the events and discussions of Socrates’ final moments before his sentenced death from the well-known trial recognized as The Apology. During this time, Socrates explains to his friends that acquiring knowledge comes from a recollection of things in a previous life as a way to provide comfort to his friends about his anticipated death. According to Socrates, if humans can learn anything, they must have known about what it is they are learning. In contrast, if humans know something without having been taught, then they must have learned it before being born. On the contrary, Plato is trying to argue this by stating that if humans do not know something, they cannot learn it since they do not know anything about it and if a human knows it, then they do not need to learn it. In this essay I will be defending Socrates’ explanation about gaining knowledge before birth.
Plato’s Argument is based on the premise that for one to recollect something there must be previous knowledge of it. He says that it is the soul that has possession of this, and that knowledge exists before birth. This theory of recollection explains that knowledge is not obtained through experience and refers to the idea that recollection, like the soul, is never dying and composes the characteristic of remembering. The knowledge that someone has is already inside of us and we must motivate ourselves to bring it out. In The Meno, Socrates mentions recollection by saying the soul is immortal and before it enters the body it understands all things (Meno’s Paradox). He supports this idea by getting a slave boy and asks him a math question. The slave boy answers the question but has had no previous education, proving that the knowledge was through recollection, and not learned. Even though the first answer was wrong, Socrates mentioned he taught nothing to the boy, and the only reason he was right the next time was because he helped him recollect the answer (The Internet Classics Archive | Phaedo by Plato.")
The knowledge of the equal is an example that adds to the argument that recollection is required for true knowledge. The argument is that we differentiate something by its similarity to the form. We know that two individuals are equal in height because the equality of the two individuals resembles the form of equality. Plato argues that if humans are able to use senses from the time we are born and understand the
Questions-Plato’s Phaedo 1. Whether Phaedo was with Socrates when he drank the poison or if he had heard it from someone else. “Phaedo, were you with Socrates when he drank the poison or did you hear about it from somebody else?” Mystery, death. 2. Philosopher, Socratic Method. Maybe he had a different outlook on death and never knew what Socrates would do. 3. Myth about sacrificing youths (14) to the Minotaur. Socrates would be a sacrifice, Phaedo would be Theseus (survives), Minotaur…
9780451530813 Links to all other course materials will be posted on Blackboard. Course Outcomes Upon completion of the course, students will be able to: 1.Analyze philosophical positions with critical sensitivity and an ordered academic inquiry. 2.Display knowledge of philosophical concepts and theories and, whenever appropriate, associate these concepts and theories with specific philosophers and philosophical movements. 3.Distinguish a number of fundamental branches of philosophy as well…
described our knowledge of equality by explaining that, “even though we have never seen any two things that are perfectly equal, because there will always be some minute difference; and yet we know what true equality (or the Form of Equality) must be.”(2) He thought that the same was true with many other things. Although we experience imperfect examples of these things, we have a somewhat real understanding of what is truth, beauty, or goodness. Plato differentiated this kind of knowledge from the…
PHIL 1001: Human Nature Reading Guide #2 Plato’s Phaedo What is the scene like when Phaedo and Crito first arrive to see Socrates? Socrates is sentenced to death He is unchained because it is the day of his execution. He is lying in his bed with his friends and followers at his side. Socrates’ wife and son are by his side, hysterical Socrates begins to tell stories based on Aesop’s Fables Oddly, Plato is removed from the discussion he is “sick.” According to Socrates, why shouldn’t…
Study Guide for Introduction to Philosophy Midterm 1. What does “philosophy” literally mean? Philosophy literally means the love of wisdom 2. What do the terms, epistemology, metaphysics and ontology mean? Epistemology means the nature of knowledge, Metaphysics is the nature of ultimate reality i.e. god, soul, and substance. Ontology is the ‘what is, how it is, and what makes it what it is’ form of philosophy. 3. Who were the Sophists? What characteristics define them? Sophists are wandering…
CHAPTER 3: SOCRATES, PLATO Main Points 1. Plato (c. 427–347 B.C.) was the pupil of Socrates (470–399 B.C.), and Aristotle (384–322 B.C.) was the pupil of Plato. Socrates 2. Socrates was not interested in arguing with his fellow Athenians merely for the sake of argument—as the Sophists were—but rather he wanted to discover the essential nature of knowledge, justice, beauty, goodness, and the virtues (such as courage). 3. The Socratic (dialectic) method: a search for the proper definition of…
the Soul Jane Smith November 5, 2014 PHIL 1000H Professor James Connelly The topic of this paper is the immortality of the soul. I will explain and assess Plato’s argument for the immortality of the soul, as developed in the Meno and Phaedo. In addition, this paper will discuss what epistemological considerations Plato used to support his view of the immortality of the soul, and how these considerations supported this view. I find Plato’s arguments for the immortality of the soul convincing…
of styles, or possibly from the size of his four head. (Ritchie 3) He had two brothers, Glaucon and Adeimantus, and a sister, Potone. Plato was of the youngest of three children. He uses his brothers as characters in three of his dialogues. (Ritchie 2) Plato’s father, Ariston, died when he was just a young boy. His mother, Pericitione, remarried a man named Pyrilampes. She had a child with her new husband, Antiphon, who also appeared as a character in one of Plato’s dialogues. (Press 14) Plato would…
Socrates was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens and sentenced to die for his beliefs. From the writings of his followers that were preserved, he was portrayed as accepting of this punishment because he truly thought what he believed was right. The trial of Socrates proved to be an important part in history, impacting the development of Western Philosophy and allowing the beliefs of Socrates to live on to this day. Socrates’ life, trial, and death are all important parts of history and coincide…