Leslie Nunez
Mrs. Guevarra
English II – T/Th 2nd
September 19, 2014 In A Modest Proposal, Swift talks about the problems that the whole country, Ireland, is facing. During this period of time, Ireland was a colony, politically, militarily, and economically dependent upon England. It was England's interest to keep things as they were since Ireland was weak, and could not go againts their country. Swift then came up with the idea of proposing his thoughts on how to solve their problems. The state of affais of Ireland are the same of those of the U.S. which is why I agree. Today the U.S. is facing economic problems as well as pregnancy rates, and descrimintion of class. Today the U.S. is facing economic problems as we fall more in debt with other countries, and within our own country as well. Jobs are scarce making it diffuclt for money to reach homes due to the low wages. Taxes are getting higher for the cause of inflation, but will help the economy within our country be stabalized. In A Modest Proposal, the economy is severe since the people aren’t more productive. The povety of the Irish isn’t making Ireland any wealthier for they “…can neither employ them in handicraft or agriculture; we neither build houses (I mean in the country) nor cultivate land” (Swift 2) adding to their poverty and suffering from starvation. Another problem which both countries face is pregnancy. In A Modest Proposal pregnancy is something viewed as dreadful being the cause of “those voluntary abortions, and that horrid practice of women murdering their bastard children” (Swift 1). It’s until Swift voices out his exaggerated ideas to provide economical and social commentary. Swift suggests that the only way to save their country from poverty and overpopulation, as in the journal states, is to kill the babies of the poor and serve them to the upper class. This will create a new source of income, and for the English a new food product to strengthen their economy and eliminate the social problem which Ireland is facing. In the U.S., pregnancy is viewed the same way it is Ireland. Today girls get pregnant wihtout knowing the defiances behind it. Then abortions become more common due to the lack of resources to cover the vastly high costs associated with pregnancy, birth and childrearing especially if they do not have health insurance.
Rich people tend to think that the poor are poor because they chose to be poor. In Ireland the poor were poor because the English would charge high rents so high that the Irish were frequently unable to pay them, and would end up on the edge of starvation espceially women who would not be able to find jobs easily. They would end up being “beggars of the female sex , followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags, and importuning every passanger for an alms” (Swift 1). The upper class would suck the life out of them in labor, and still they would stay as poor no matter how much they worked. The similar in the U.S., poor people will stay poor no matter how much they work. Rich will offend them
Eng 52 Lesley Blake 23-09-14 A Modest Proposal A Modest Proposal begins stating the affairs of Ireland’s poverty, that the children are being fed to the brim with food. The author, Jonathan Swift, came up with a proposal to put the children of Ireland to good use, as he lived in Dublin, Ireland. Instead of feeding food to the children, he suggest that the children should be fed as food to the wealthy citizens, which he then proceeds with the benefits of his proposal. Only a hundred thousand children…
of trying to decipher what irony is and how it is tolerated and concealed. The two texts I will be exploring and deconstructing are ‘A Modest Proposal for preventing the children of poor people in Ireland, from being a burden on their parents or Country, and for making them beneficial to the publick’1 (1729) and ‘The Shortest-Way with the Dissenters: or Proposals for the Establishment of the Church’ 2(1702). Moreover, both of these texts are extremely conscious in employing this literary device as…
A modest Proposal Overpopulation is becoming a large problem in the world, especially in places like China. Living conditions and spaces are becoming limited forcing more poverty and extreme economic problems. Even with the “the one child per family policy” the population is still the fastest growing in our world today. At this rate by the year of 2025 the population will be 1.5 billion, and surely that will continue to rise. With the technology we have access to today and information about the…
Jake Blank Ms. Bravo English 102 15 September 16, 2013 “A Modest Proposal”: Rhetorical Analysis Johnathon Swift, the author of “A Modest Proposal”, is disgusted in seeing the amount of children who are poor begging on the streets of London. Therefore, he comes up with an outlandish proposal in hopes to persuade the country to start considering a realistic possibility. He focuses his proposition on Ireland because the problem is inside their country. “…it is of a much greater extent, and shall…
Mark Tabone English 355 11 June 2015 Rhetorical Analysis: A Modest Proposal In the seventeenth century, people made habit of distributing political pamphlets in Ireland to promote intellectual ideas. Many people threw these pamphlets away and did not pay attention to them. In 1729 Jonathan Swift, author of “A Modest Proposal,” devises this proposal to show how bad and backwards the social class and general state Ireland was in. His proposal was that the infants of the desolate and poor should “contribute…
LIU,Jiacheng ENGL 102 CU01 Word count:571 “A summary of A Modest Proposal” In 1729 Jonathan Swift wrote an essay called “ A Modest Proposal”. In his essay, he talks about helping poor people in Ireland by selling their infant to the wealth English people so that both sides got the benefits. It is a classical satiric novel that satire the English and try to help Ireland. Author states that, in the country there are too many beggars, most their children are compelled to become a thief or fight for the pretender in…
Taylor Ditmer January 14th, 2014 AEL3 Mrs. Skinner “A Modest Proposal” Precis “A Modest Proposal” was a piece written by Jonathan Swift was a satirical piece written to help cure the great potato famine in Ireland in 1729. The country at the time was going through a famine as all the potatoes had died off that year, and most of the country was left to starve. England who had control of them at the time, sat back and watched as thousands if not millions died from starvation and the poverty rate severely…
In his essay “A Modest Proposal,” Jonathan Swift provides a quick and satiric analysis of the economic problems Ireland in the early 1700s faced and offers a “solution” to the problem: serving the children of the poor to the rich as a delicacy. As his earlier reasonable proposals failed to garner any real attention, Swift attempts to shock his audience in a way that both outlines the true dimensions of the problem as well as forces action to be taken to rectify the poverty, starvation, and inability…
Mariette Dekker Professor Wood Eng112 3 May 2014 A Modest Proposal on Sentencing Disparity The chief purpose of a trial is to ensure and secure fair and impartial administration of justice between the parties to the action. A trial seeks to ascertain the truth of the matters in issue between the parties and to apply the law to those matters (“Trial”). The basic concept of a fair trial by jury has been in existence since the signing of the Magna Carta in 1215(Robinson). This idea has been in…
Quinn Derrick and Collin Gluth Mrs. Ochoa AP English 3 Jan. 23, 2015 pd The Modest Proposal Essay Assignment: A Proposition That Will Solve The Dilemma Toward the Many Annual Casualties of Drinking and Driving In todays day and age we are faced with drinking and driving, or “driving under the influence”. Annually about 1.5 million people are arrested for DUI’s, it’s common for a fellow friend to be one of these people and it’s accepted in our present society. Congressmen and Senators pass laws to…