QUESTION ONE
Write a brief outline of how ideology is working in the “Taxi event” news story
EG 1 What appears to be naturalized, timeless, common sense or universally accepted is actually ideology, a construction tied with power that privileges certain groups in society. Within the “Taxi event” video, Shuttleworth communicates a racist ideology privileging Caucasians over Pakistanis. Shuttleworth’s comments alienated Muslim male, Humayun, speaking to ideologies that whiteness is normal and desirable in New Zealand. This perpetuates an ‘us vs. them’ racial binary, estranging the Muslim community as the ‘other’. The Otago Daily Times article attempts to pass such racist ideology as an aberration, or unwelcome exception to the rule. Alcock, a New Zealand Taxi federation representative claimed, “the region appreciates the contribution new migrants make to our workforce, businesses and Southland as a whole.” Thus, racism is presented as unusual and irregular. Through the use of authoritative white voices such as Alcock, the article paints the Southland workforce free of racism and represents this event as uncommon. Shuttleworth asserts, “that he feels no animosity towards people of other religions” and the “stupid mistake” was a by-product of intoxication. Rather, the taxi event is a contingency or reflection of systemic racism in New Zealand. Mrs. Mohammed, the owner of the taxi company, speaks as the nominated Muslim voice in the article. She suggests that verbal attacks are ‘common’ but often unreported. Thus, racist ideology is embedded in white New Zealand society and the attempt to convince readers’ otherwise further estranges the Muslim population. Conversely, a New Zealand Herald article paints Shuttleworth as a remorseful and sincere victim who should be forgiven for his actions, rather than the perpetrator of racist ideology. It reads, “ As he held back the tears, he vowed to meet the Southland Muslim community to become better educated on Islam.” Prosser, a New Zealand First MP said that “opening dialogue about this issue” was a good thing. The text represents the Muslim community as a group whose role and responsibility it is to educate. This clear demarcation between the Muslim and white community speaks to wider racial roles in society, representing a racist worldview and ideology that privileges whiteness. Fairbrother, (Shuttleworth’s partner) casually passes the incident off as “not cool”, reinforcing the hesitance of the white community to admit that racist ideology is pertinent. Media representation of the “taxi event” attempts to fix racist anti-Muslim ideology as an aberration. These articles reinforce racist ideologies, by not considering other versions of reality and simply reinforcing white privilege. Dominant ideology is given power in the media through repetition. In this case the consistent ‘othering’ of the Muslim community demonstrates white privilege and embedded social racism. Mythically, these articles paint New Zealand as non-racist and accepting. They present the notion that drunken racism as fixable and forgivable as truth.
EG 2 In the media representation of the “Taxi event” ideology plays a significant role. Although media has represented the event in a way that outwardly sympathises with Mr Humayun and the Muslim community, they still speak from a nominated position. Humayun and Mohammed both speak as representatives of the Muslim community, while Shuttleworth speaks from the ex-nominated position of being white. So regardless of the fact that the article is sympathetic to the Muslim community after the “verbal racial abuse”, it reinforces an ideological “us” vs. “them”. The “us” being white New Zealanders, and the “them” being the Muslim community. This is reinforced by various references, including from MP Richard Prosser, of the value of being taught about Islam. This implies that the “other” has an obligation to justify their beliefs and behaviour to the “us”. This
Related Documents: Essay about ideology and representation
* Hegemony * Dominant ideologies present in media contents * The case of news media, rap music, popular TV * Advertising and consumer culture Ideological analysis in media * Ideology * A system of meaning that helps define and explain the world and that makes value judgments about that world. * They don’t know it, but they are doing it. Ideology as normalization * Ideology defines what is being normal in society * Dominant ideologies * Taken for granted,…
and discussed many parts of Media/Society by David Croteau, William Hoynes and Stefania Milan. In the first four parts, we spoke about many topics such as the media and social world (sociology of media), the economics part of media, media representation and ideology of media, and the meaning and influence of audiences and how active audiences construct meaning through encoding and decoding. In this essay, I will explain each of these several parts as well as give fully detailed examples of how each…
construction is active process of meaning attribution Key role of media in the process Achieved through representations: discourses and ideologies e.g. language choices: benefit recipient vs welfare scrounger e.g. media trials: Amanda Knox trial; disappearance of Madeleine McCann Mediated nature of reality in 21st C Media ideologies Ideologies as sets of ideas and beliefs Marxist definition of ideology (Abercrombie et al 1980): 1. Dominance: Produced by the dominant groups in society Work in the…
the means. A subtle ideology was introduced to early America to represent that hard work gets a man to a proper title. The ideology of the American Dream, which capitalist exploited as much as possible, an ideology that remains constant and strong in America today. An early writer by the name of Owen Wister contributes to this ideology in his novel The Virginian where he shows a man that move up in the ranks of society through hard work. The novel is a direct representation of the class conflict…
not. The British Parliament passed laws designed to tax the colonists. The issue of economics lead into the political problems and ideology revolutions that came about after the French and Indian War. Ideological: A basic thing to remember about this is the famous phrase "No taxation without representation." The colonists did not want to be taxed without representation. This lit the fire of revolt and started the wheels turning for independence. Additionally, after the French and Indian War, the…
parties, fascists seek total control over society. c) Two Party System: two dominant parties. (1) Electoral Arrangments- single member districts, multi member districts: proportional representation d) Multi-Party System:single m,ember districts discriminate against small parties. (1) Proportional Representation- is a fairer system, although its success depends on coalition. D. Types of Political Parties 1. Party Organization- parties have common goals, field candidates for elected office, winning…
colonization. First of all, the paper will discuss some of the difficulties associated with the study of criminology. Secondly I will briefly discuss the relationship between African and Europeans; thirdly I will be drawing on the issue of over-representation in regards to Aboriginal and Indigenous individuals and will conclude by restating by theses. It is quite evident that the formation of the Romano-Germanic family of law that presides over Europe was created predominately by the Roman Empire…
and political ideologies is something widely discussed in sociological terms. While some sociologists see them as separate entities providing different functions, others see them as one in the same. This is a view discussed by Functionalists, Pluralists, Marxists, Feminists and Postmodernists. Postmodernist Lyotard, for example, talks about science as a ‘metanarrative’ or a ‘big story’ which, according to postmodernists, makes them untrustworthy. Postmodernity discusses both ideology and religion…
for the greatest good for the greatest amount of people, should maintain a Smithsonian, free-Capital market and limit Socialized programs for the reasons of Utilitarianism of equality, longevity of economic infrastructure, and fundamental economic ideologies. John Stewart Mill’s philosophy of Utilitarianism states “the greatest happiness of the greatest number” is the ideal model for a government. This statement derived from a book by Joseph priestly, called the Treatise of Government that explains…
Representations are not merely objective truth, but encompass conscious selectivity and emphasis which shape and define the meaning we derive from a text. The importance of the Smithsonian's Bearing Witness to History site as both a historical and American representation causes a divergence in its purpose, between its obligation for factual accuracy and intrinsic support of specific cultural values. Deepa Mehta's film Earth (1996) demonstrates the manipulation of texts to shape the meaning we derive…