Rhetorical Tradition
October 5, 2011
Greek Rhetorical Theory In the early years of Greek rhetoricians, Aristotle and Plato played a major role in defining and exploring the philosophies of rhetoric. Even though Aristotle spent most of his life being educated by Plato, they have contrasting views on rhetoric. Aristotle defined rhetoric into detailed classifications, while Plato focused more on the soul of the audience in relation to rhetoric. These differing ideas are the pillars for which the uses of rhetoric have been built upon. Plato is usually associated with the belief of divine truth and its accessibility to humans. He believed that before birth, we were granted with the ability to recognize truth. The problem with transcendent truth is that post birth requires us to regain the knowledge of truth that we once had while in the divine. As you would imagine, this could be challenging and seem nearly impossible, but according to Plato, it is a philosopher’s task to help others find their way back to absolute truth. A significant part of Plato’s theory on rhetoric was his view on the soul and the various compartments imbedded within it. According to Plato, the soul was made up of three sections, the white horse, the black horse and the chariot. The chariot symbolizes your conscious and your ability to make choices. The black horse represents the emotional side of the human soul along with the uncertainty and irrationality that comes with it. On the contrary, the white horse exemplifies logic and reason; it is more stable and secure than the black horse. This metaphor of the soul is fundamental to the success as a rhetorician in the eyes of Plato. To truly exemplify one’s skill as a rhetorician, one must know and acknowledge the souls of his audience members. In the Phaedrus, written by Plato, rhetoric is seen as a noble part of life that is only available and understood by the higher class. This higher class that could obtain the knowledge of absolute truths were the Philosopher Kings. The Philosopher Kings were then able to pass along the absolute truth to those who were able to comprehend it. One characterization of understanding rhetoric, which Philosopher Kings possessed, is the ability to classify Aristotle’s multidimensional model of rhetoric and how they are somehow intertwined. The division begins with the two categories of artistic proofs and inartistic proofs. Aristotle continues to break down rhetoric into categories by applying the sub divisions of artistic and inartistic to the new category of ethos, logos and pathos. Aristotle then applies his categorization further by dividing rational appeals into enthymeme, maxim and example (170).
In Aristotle’s Book 1 of rhetoric he outlines four major uses for rhetoric. First and foremost, he believed that rhetoric would naturally bring the truth forward and stand out amongst all other things. The second useful aspect of rhetoric is the ability to persuade and argue a point to a popular audience that could otherwise not be convicted with truth alone. The third use of rhetoric is to argue both sides. Aristotle believed the third function of rhetoric was to argue both sides, which allowed every case or situation to be balanced by the ability to view multiple conclusions. Lastly, the use of rhetoric can be helpful in the form of defense. Aristotle claims that it is shameful if a man is only able to defend himself physically but lacks the knowledge or use of speech to hurt others with words. In Rhetoric, Aristotle attempts to glorify the use of rhetoric in decision making on subjects in which the absolute truth is unknown. While the Phaedrus suggests that when studying the souls of audience members, you should apply rhetoric in order to appeal to the their individual souls.
As previously stated,
emphazied shared foods, common life,and observance of the torah Form criticism- type of historical criticism form- identify the different forms used in creation of the document Gospel- Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John new testament Hellenism- Greek culture became dominant cultural force Hermeneutics- type of bible study readers reflect upon messages communicated to the original audience so that the meaning of the word of god can shape and reshape the daily life of todays Christians in…
over the world believe “GOD” or “An Intelligent Designer” made all the living things. Modern science believe that all living things came to be through evolution. The theory of evolution states that billions of years ago a complex chemical soup suddenly became a single cell organism that replicated and evolved through time. This theory is based on a natural selection, which defines as “a process in nature in which organisms possessing certain genotypic characteristics that make them better adjusted…
The remaining fragments of Thrasymachus’ writings provide few clues about his philosophical ideas. They either deal with rhetorical issues or they are excerpts from speeches (DK 85b1 and b2) that were (probably) written for others and thus can hardly be seen as the expression of Thrasymachus’ own thoughts. The most interesting fragment is DK 85b8. It contains the claim that the gods do not care about human affairs since they do not seem to enforce justice. Scholars have, however, been divided whether…
Breaking down traditions: The “Clouds” and the “History of Peloponnesian War” Undeniably, the ancient Greek society places a heavy emphasis on values and traditions. The two texts of the “Clouds” by Aristophanes and “History of the Peloponnesian war” by Thucydides, although contextually divergent, are actually conceptually convergent. Both texts are built around the central theme of the collapse of conventional values. While the breakdown of traditional values in the “History of the Peloponnesian…
life, times, and philosophy of Socrates whose philosophy became the paradigm for Western philosophy. Objectives: The student will learn how to interpret philosophical texts, how to recognize philosophical arguments, how to understand philosophical theories and locate them in terms of a methodic approach to philosophy, and will be able to evaluate intelligently the significance of Socrates for the foundation of Western Philosophy and the importance of that foundation for our way of life today . Philosophy…
ENTERTEXT Identity as Cultural Production in Andrea Levy's Small Island Author: Alicia E. Ellis Source: EnterText, “Special Issue on Andrea Levy 9,” (2012): 69-83. Abstract Andrea Levy's Small Island (2004) presents a counter-history of the period before and after World War II (1939-1945) when men and women from the Caribbean volunteered for all branches of the British armed services and many eventually immigrated to London after the war officially ended in 1945. Her historical novel moves…
The Rhetorical Triangle Key #1 Persona a mask, the character the audience perceived behind the text, the character a writer or speaker conveys to the audience "It is to my other self, to Borges, that things happen. I walk about Buenos Aires and I pause, almost mechanically, to contemplate the arch of an entry or the portal of a church; news of Borges comes to me in the mail, and I see his name on a short list of professors or in a biographical dictionary. I am fond of hourglasses, maps,…
id/1764/1/LITERARY%20CRITICISM%20materi%202.pdf http://www.saylor.org/site/wp-content/themes/saylor/curriculum/curriculumQAAJAX.php?action=getcourseunitqas&courseunitid=8300 History Prior to formalism, there were only two literary theories present: historical theory and psychological theory. Formalism primarily started in Russia around the 1900’s, hence the term Russian formalism was given before. Russian Formalism refers to two specific works: the work of the Society for the Study of Poetic Language founded…
the quality or fact of being greater in number, quantity, or importance. Learning the tools of critical reading and writing not only teaches you the “what” of an issue, but also helps you think about and respond intelligently to the relative strength of the writer’s opinions, ideas, and theories. Critical thinking, reading, and writing enables you to distinguish between informed ideas and pure speculation, rational arguments and emotional ones, and organized essays and structurally deficient ones. Active reading means learning to annotate…
delicious or fragrant Ameliorate: to make better; improve, enhance Amelus: individual exhibiting Amelia (the congenital absence of one or more limbs) Amethyst: deep purple; deep-purple gemstone Amnesia: partial or total loss of memory Amphisbaena: Greek mythological being, a two-headed snake with a head on each end Amphora: ceramic, two-handled vase with a narrow neck, usually containing alcohol Amulet: a charm against evil or impurity, often a piece of jewelry Analemma: sundial, figure-8 indicating…