I. Introduction
II. Test-Evidence Hiding
III. Ignoring the options
IV. Economic vs. Ethical Decision
V. The Numbers
VI. Lobbyist Techniques
VII. Conclusion
I. Introduction
The Ford Motor Company debuted a new line of cars called Ford Pinto in 1971. In order to compete in a new American market of subcompact cars, with the advice of Lee Iacocca, the automobile was designed and produced in one of the shortest production planning time. In addition, Iacocca enforced the engineers to have the car less than 2,000 pounds and not cost over 2,000 dollars, also known as “the limits of 2,000”. While it was successful in releasing it on time and follow “the limits of 2,000”, the lack of production planning time caused a serious design flaw: a Pinto’s gas tank ruptured and the car would ignite on fire when it was rear-ended. The Ford Motor Company had an access to a much safer gas tank design, but refused to implement the design, which would have cost 11 dollars per car. The reason was because Ford was able to argue in terms of accepted cost-benefit analysis to determine that the new gas tank design costs were greater than the benefits of saving 180 lives per year. The cost-benefit analysis included a dollar value on human life of 200,000 dollars.1 While Ford Motor Company used accepted cost-benefit analysis to determine if the implementation of the new gas tanks was beneficial to the cost, I believe that it was unethical to use different lobbying techniques to delay Standard 301, which would have forced rear-end provisions, and have killed 180 lives per year by negligence.
II. Test-Evidence Hiding
As mentioned in the article by Mark Dowie, because of the shorter production planning process, they were tooling even before the product was fully developed. After they developed the car, they secretly tested the car. It was a known problem internally that the gas tanks will always rupture when rear-ended at a relatively low speed. Ford officials knew of this problem. However, they held these tests at a top-secret site and have kept the internal company documents hidden for years. To combat this issue, they tried and passed three tests unbroken gas tanks with three different modifications.2 However, they did not implement any of these modifications to the mass production and rolled them out of factories. I believe it is unethical to hide the truth from the public. The consumers have the right to know what tests have been done and what the results of that tests were. Ford Motor Company failed to be transparent and even denied under oath having crash-tested the Pinto.
III. Ignoring the options
When designing and developing Pintos, the engineers have found the flaws and reported them as unsafe. Iacocca, president of the project, knew of the issue as well, but did not take any actions because he did not want to the Pinto to cost over 2,000 dollars. This put a tough limitation on the production team. When Ford officials found out about the issue, they have tested different ways to prevent rupturing gas tanks. As I mentioned before, there were three different ways that passed the rear-end test. One method used an inexpensive plastic baffle. Another method used a piece of steel. Third method used a rubber bladder to use as lining the tank. All of these three options were ignored to cut the cost in manufacturing. In addition, during the pre-production planning, engineers considered using the same tank as used in the Capri models, which was found to be successful over 50 crash tests of rear-end impacts of 60mph. This option was also ignored. All these safer options were ignored by all the Ford officials and the firetrap automobiles were mass produced for years. This is another reason why I believe Ford was unethical. They had multiple opportunities and options to save thousands of lives, but they turned their eyes and decided to focus on the profits instead of
Social, Legal and Ethical Issues What is Ethics? What is the origin of ethics? What are the different approaches and teachings of ethical reasoning? How are these approaches used to make an ethical decision? How are ethics relevant to both an individual and a corporation? The origin of the term ‘ethic’ has been around for centuries. The word ‘ethics’ is from the Greek word ‘ethos’ which is translated to equate to English as ‘character’ or ‘custom’. Furthermore…
Week One – Ethics Essay Jessica Jackson ETH/316 Karen Harvey University of Phoenix June 29th, 2015 Ethical Theories The concept of ethics deals with human behaviors and moral development is crucial in today's society. Throughout history, there have been many different theories. When thinking ethically an individual must think about and differentiate between what is wrong and what is right. Virtue Theory, Utilitarianism, and Deontological ethics are all parts of normative ethics. The purpose…
Personnel Ethics Ethics 316 2-12-2014 Professor In order to understand ethics lets define it. “Ethics: an area of study that deals with ideas about what is good and bad behavior: a branch of philosophy dealing with what is morally right or wrong” (http://www.merriam-webster.com/) Trust in chooses individuals make in support of their company or themselves is defined by their character. In today’s companies the thin line between trust in individuals as well as in products are…
Ethics Essay ETH/316 February 10, 2014 Ethics can be described as a value system of principles that we all follow in life this value system can be the guide to everything we in life. Ethics deal with the question of what is morally right or morally wrong. These morals not only deal with your personal life but also your professional life. There are three major theories when it comes to ethics these include; virtue theory, utilitarian and deontological theory. Virtue theory…
How have you educated your boss, peers, or direct reports about what you are learning in class? We hold bi-weekly team meetings to ensure cohesive communication. Over the last month, I presented the ethics benchmarks to our team and we discussed how it applied to our organization. The staff became highly engaged in these exercises, as it brought us together to think about how our organization conducts itself in a more ethical manner. The owner of our organization, also present in the meetings, was…
ETHICS ESSAY Kenneth MACHOL ETH 316 April 23, 2012 Karen Harvey ETHICS ESSAY Ethics plays a very important role in society. Also, a devotion to certain ethical and moral principles has a optimistic growth of a person’s moral nature. In addition detailed living experiences can help out assured individuals to bring out the growth of his or her ideals and principles. This essay will look at the similarity plus difference of virtue, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics. I will also give details…
Advanced Nursing Ethics and Values Essay It is often hard for healthcare workers to understand why a patient would refuse care or treatment that could potentially save their lives. We are trained to treat, heal and care for our patients; when they refuse care or treatment because of religious, cultural or even unknown reasons we often question what’s best for this patient. Should they be forced to accept the treatment? Should we rally their family to help “convince” them? Is it ok to refuse…
Ethics and Social Responsibility Eth/316 Feb. 22, 2014 Rhonda Lawrence Ethics and Social Responsibility Ethics is the science concerning the right and wrong of human action (Boylan, 2009). As children we are taught by our parents right from wrong, but as adults we have to make decisions to do the right or wrong thing. My personal experience is when I went to Wells Fargo Bank to cash my check. The teller over paid me by fifty dollars. When I realized the teller overpaid me, I return to the bank to…
enter their own personal account to accumulate other people’s points. Companies have established policies and procedures to make sure that the company is always in benefit and everything is correctly done that the CEO would agree with. The Code of Ethics of a company is mainly to assist members in making decision while working. Some decision are “wrong” and some are “right” according to the company policy. Within the document, the company’s values and mission statement are woven in between it. Many…
Ethics in the Work Place I chose ethics in the workplace because it is a topic that is very important in my opinion, but one that gets overlooked so many times. Each person has their own views and thoughts of what is right and what is wrong and how to deal with them. While you may think that one particular person may not necessarily be right or wrong the law would beg to differ on certain situations. Other times what one considers to be an ethical decision is not always a legal matter, so the line…