BA 644
Case 10-4 Fraudulent Misrepresentation
Dr. Speronis
2/25/2015
Annie Ashton
Esprit Log and Timber Frame Homes v. Wilcox
691 S.E.2d 344 (2010)
Facts
Ricky and Sherry Wilcox entered into a contract with Esprit Log and Timber Frame Homes (Fireside Log Homes), where Fireside agreed to manufacture and supply the Wilcoxes with the logs to build a manufactured home which could be assembled in seven to ten days (Esprit Log and Timber Frame Homes v. Wilcox, 2010). The Wilcoxes agreed to pay $128,600 for the material and services and tendered $65,000 as a deposit. The Wilcoxes ultimately paid Fireside $125,260. When the materials were delivered, they were not build-ready, and the project took an additional ten months and the Wilcoxes paid an additional $100,000 in materials, labor and expenses, as well as investment interest totaling $166,915.The Wilcoxes were able to sell the home after completion for $1,620,000. Fireside Log Homes sued Ricky Wilcox and Sherry Wilcox seeking damages for breach of contract. The Wilcoxes answered and asserted a counterclaim against Esprit Log and Don Mahaffy, d/b/a Fireside Log Homes (collectively, "Fireside") for breach of contract, negligent construction, conversion, fraud, and attorney fees. Fireside appealed.
Issue
The issue in this case is whether the court’s erred in overruling Fireside’s motion for a new trial. Fireside’s claim is that the verdict on Wilcoxes counterclaim was excessive and unsupported by evidence, the punitive damages were not supported by evidence, and the Wilcoxes received a double recovery.
Rule of Law The rule of law pertaining to this case involves fraudulent misrepresentation and breach of contract. “Under contract law, a plaintiff can recover against a defendant on the grounds of fraudulent misrepresentation if (1) a representation was made; (2) that was false; (3) that when made, the representation was known to be false or made recklessly without knowledge of its truth; (4) that it was made with the intention that the plaintiff rely on it; (5) that the plaintiff did rely on it; and (6) that the plaintiff suffered damages as a result (Legal Information Institute, n.d.). It is the right of the defendant to appeal the verdict passed down by the court if it believes the decision was incorrect or faulty.
Application
The application of law in this case is that when deciding if there was a breach of contract, the jury needed to decide if there was non-performance of a contractual duty. The original suit against the Wilcoxes is irrelevant, as per contract details, they did in fact pay $125,260 of the $128,600 agreed upon, including a $65,000 deposit. The countersuit filed by the Wilcoxes for breach of contract, negligent construction, conversion, fraud, and attorney fees is valid. By entering into a contract for specific goods, knowing that they were incapable of rendering a specific product, Fireside was committing fraudulent misrepresentation of services. The contract also stated an amount of time for completion, which was seven to ten days. This was grossly inaccurate, as Fireside did not have the
Korea is an “ideal” market for American fast food chains, however I do believe some limited success could be seen there with alterations to the products and services. 2. If you were Matthew Wolf, would you recommend his company to pursue the South Korea market at the present time? The information presented in the case study has led me to believe Wolf should not enter the market at this time. To begin, Mr Wolf and his team need to be highly educated on the location, culture, people, habits, traditions…
Daniel Serna MBA Case Study 2 Enron How did the corporate culture of Enron contributed to its bankruptcy? These leaders was motivated by greed, money and power. Enron was once one of the Top Fortune 500 Company. The culture of this company was to make profits and as the company gain momentum, many people join the bang wagon of deceitful practices and the demise grown amongst the upper management for Enron. However, the accounting method was question by the accountability of people for the organization…
Case Study Analysis – 2 California Miramar University 1. What is the basis of Red Bull's competitive advantage in the energy drinks market? Red Bull’s success is largely credited to its innovation capabilities. Red Bull is launched in 1987 when there is no similar product in the market. This provides a sound foundation for Red Bull to obtain the biggest market share when it comes more and more popular in the world. Red Bull uses its unique marketing strategy to build its…
Nursing Case Study #2 Acute Pancreatitis (Chapter 60 text) You are a charge nurse on a medical unit of a large teaching hospital. The Emergency Department (ED) is sending you a new admission, a female client, age 48, with a medical diagnosis of acute pancreatitis. Upon her arrival to your unit, you fully assess your client. Included in your assessment findings are the following data: • VS: T, 100.2° F; P, 104; R, 22; B/P, 100/60 • Sharp pain in the mid-epigastric area radiating to the back, rated…
Case Analysis of an organisational behaviour using the Job Characteristics Model Word Count: 2500 Introduction The purpose of this case analysis is to apply the theory of Job Characteristic Model (JCM) to my own work experience and provide insightful recommendations for more effective organisational behaviour in the future. This will be achieved through the discussion of literature review, diagnosis, recommendations and reflection. Literature review Job design does not increase work…
MGT 495 Case Study #2 “The Whistleblowers” 1) The Whistleblower Protection Act, gives a legal protection to those employees who engage in Whistleblowing. It provides privacy and protection from reprisal to federal employees, former employees or any others who report a claim of mishandle of gross, fraudulence, or misuse of power. This Law was enacted in 1989 and its primary purpose was to strengthen and make better the defense and security for the rights of federal employees to avoid any unfair…
Abstract Jack Greenburg Inc. is a whole sale meat company that marketed a variety of meat, cheese, and other food products along the eastern seaboard of the United States. In the early 1980’s due to his health Jack Greenburg decide to place his two sons in charge of the company Emanuel and Fred Greenburg. During the mid-1980’s and early 1990’s the companies prepaid inventory account increased dramatically which set off alarms to the company’s independent audit firm Grant Thornton. After a more thorough…
Erin Fitzpatrick Rigor Mortis Case Stud BIO 317 Construct a time-line of the events from Saturday evening through Monday morning as described in the story. Around 11:30 Steve hit his head and was knocked unconscious. Steve’s injuries most likely caused his death in the early Monday morning hours. Jackie most likely died from the substance that was thrown in her face by Leslie. Jackie most likely died very soon after Leslie threw the substance at her. This would have been at approximately 12:30am…
Thank you for choosing DTH external consultanting, we have been hired by your company’s Staffing Service. We have looked over your Company and the staffing problems your company is experiencing. It seems to us that your company is concerned with how to staff your new stores, as well as, your stores that are already in business in order to keep your company’s goals. In this report you will find that there are many things we see eye to eye on that your organization does, on the other hand there are…
Airline Distribution Systems in 2013: A Case Study Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Worldwide Abstract Airline distribution systems are undergoing a dramatic change in the way airline tickets are distributed due to the influence of different factors such as new technology, low-cost demands, and the changing needs of travelers. This paper will discuss those factors and discuss Global Distribution Systems (GDS) and what advantages airlines would gain from being in control of ticket distribution…