Why Let the Rich Hoard All the Toys?
By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
Published: October 3, 2012
Imagine a kindergarten with 100 students, lavishly supplied with books, crayons and toys.
Yet you gasp: one avaricious little boy is jealously guarding a mountain of toys for himself. A handful of other children are quietly playing with a few toys each, while 90 of the children are looking on forlornly — empty-handed.
The one greedy boy has hoarded more toys than all those 90 children put together!
“What’s going on?” you ask. “Let’s learn to share! One child shouldn’t hog everything for himself!”
The greedy little boy looks at you, indignant. “Do you believe in redistribution?” he asks suspiciously, his lips curling in contempt. “I don’t want to share. This is America!”
And then he summons his private security firm and has you dragged off the premises. Well, maybe not, but you get the point.
That kindergarten distribution is precisely what America looks like. Our wealth has become so skewed that the top 1 percent possesses a greater collective worth than the entire bottom 90 percent, according to the Economic Policy Institute in Washington.
This inequality is a central challenge for the United States today and should be getting far more attention in this presidential campaign. A few snapshots:
• The six heirs of Sam Walton, the founder of Walmart, own as much wealth as the bottom 100 million Americans.
• In 2010, 93 percent of the gain in national income went to the top 1 percent.
• America’s Gini coefficient, the classic measure of inequality, set a modern record last month — the highest since the Great Depression.
This dismal ground is explored in an important and smart new book, “The Price of Inequality,” by Joseph Stiglitz, the Nobel laureate who was chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President Bill Clinton. It’s a searing read.
“We are paying a high price for our inequality — an economic system that is less stable and less efficient, with less growth,” Stiglitz warns.
The problem is not that the rich are venal or immoral, and I buy into the Chinese mantra of the reform era: “To get rich is glorious.” But today’s level of inequality is unusual by American historical and global standards alike, and, as Stiglitz notes, evidence is mounting that inequality at the levels we’ve reached stifles growth and employment.
As I see it, the best way to create a more equitable society wouldn’t be Robin Hood-style redistribution, but a focus on inner-city and rural education — including early childhood programs — and job training. That approach would expand opportunity, even up the starting line, and chip away at cycles of poverty. If the cost means forcing tycoons to pay modestly higher taxes, so be it. The economy wouldn’t suffer.
After all, the United States enjoyed strong growth in the 1950s when we were a more egalitarian country, even though the top income tax rate in that decade was always more than 90 percent.
Indeed, it was only in 1987 that the top income tax rate dropped below 50 percent in the United States. So the 15 percent rate that some tycoons pay because of the
Related Documents: Why Let The Rich Hoard All The Toys?
Ordinance-Created 6 states, Minnesota, Illinois, Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, and Wisconsin b. Louisiana Purchase- Doubled the size of the United States c. War of 1812- Even though America did not gain or lose land, this was gave Americans newfound confidence and pride in their nation d. Monroe Doctrine- Stated that there could be no more colonization of European colonies in the Western Hemisphere and America would not butt into any country’s affairs provided they didn’t butt into America’s…
want to consume a beefy cheeseburger and juicy fries? All those bad habits have caused us to become the country with the highest obesity rate. With 30.3% of obese citizens in the U.S. we beat Mexico and the United Kingdom and we’re still getting fatter by the day. Out of our 50 states, 33 states have an obesity rate equal or greater than 25% (CDC). Due to the modern conveniences like fast food, the obesity rates in the US are increasing tremendously. Mean while, nothing in the government is being done…
absolutely nothing but get money from the government or other financial sources just because they are to lazy to go out and look for a job or would just rather sit at home and do nothing. Moreover, there are those people out there that bust their butts to make money to provide for their family and try but make very little money. I believe that if the government would spend less money on people who were just to lazy to go look for a job because I would almost bet that those people do not have an American…
colonial times, and its position in the world of business relations. Boike Rehbein states, “Brazilian society remains characterized by vertiginous social inequalities and widespread poverty” (Rehbein,2011,p.95). I believe that once Brazil reduces poverty and criminal violence, its position in business relations will improve. These problems could be solved by modifying economic and social reforms and giving the state more control of the country. The judicial system also has to be overhauled because…
returned to San Antonio. When he came back he proposed! It was a gold plain band, I didn't care I was going to be Mrs. Foster forever!! After awhile, he graduated from training as a combat medic. I was so proud of him. He was my solider of the United States Army. He was stationed at Fort Hood, Tx. We built our lives there. Together we had the best time. We made each other laugh, he adored me and I adored him. I felt and knew I was the luckiest woman on earth. We balanced each other. He was so patient…