This case consists of mainly two parts: one is the formation of a contract and the other one is the operation of the contract. Thus in this paper I will discuss it in two individual parts.
[PART I]
ISSUE:
Is the advertisement “mere puff”? Or is there a binding contract between Michael and Slimy Motors Pty. Ltd.or the manufacturer who authorized the advertisement?
RULE:
Five elements which must be established before a contract can be formed- offer, acceptance, agreement, consideration and intention;
If a statement is mere puff, it will not be an offer because the maker of the statement did not intend it to be so.
FACTS:
Let us analyze these five elements in this case one by one:
[Intention]
The advertisement on the television is obviously an intention to treat by the manufacturer.
[Offer and acceptance]
Regarding the representation ”The best car in the world”, any reasonable person would understand the statement as conveying no more precise meaning than that the regarded itself as offering the best deal.[1]
“The advertisement invites members of the public to come and test drives the new model” means the advertisement was an offer to anyone who had watched it.
In Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 AT 261-2K Lindley LJ [2]said: Advertisement offering rewards are offers to anybody who performs the conditions accepts the offer. In point of law this advertisement is an offer to pay to anybody who will perform these conditions and performance of the conditions is the acceptance of the offer.
Communication of acceptance is not necessary for a contract when people's conduct manifests an intention to contract. Thus in this case, satisfying conditions for testing drives one of their cars within 12 hours of this advertisement appearing on television constituted acceptance of the offer.
[Consideration]
And there is also benefits for both parties in this case: Michael get a chance to win a car and the dealer get more customers attracted by the ads and coming to the show room thus get more potential sales and the manufacturer get more potential sales as well.
[Agreement]
Although there is no traditional written agreements in this case, in Empirnall Holdings Pty Ltd v Machon Paull Partners Pty Ltd (1988) 14 NSWLR 523, it was said ‘Where an offeree with a reasonable opportunity to reject the offer of goods or services takes the benefit of them in circumstances which indicate that they were to be paid for in accordance with the offer, it is open to tribunal of fact that the offer was accepted according to its terms.’ So in this circumstances it can be shown that each party has assented to the contract.
The case does not mention whether there is another contract between the dealer and the manufacturer, but they must have close relationship and we can believe the dealer is aware it will involved in the contract between customers and the manufacturer thus has a binding contract with Michael as well by tacit even if there is no written agreements with the manufacturer.
[Mere puff]
“Full details will be made available at the time of test driving the car” showed the serious intention of attracting audiences to be involved in the competition which evidenced that the advertisement was not a mere puff.
[Conclusion]
Michael has a binding contract with both the manufacturer who authorized the advertisement and the dealer who gave him the test drive.
The representation -”The best car in the world” is a mere puff thus is not a binding promise. And after testing driving the car, Michael asked for the details of being eligible, which implies Michael basically was satisfied with the quality of the car.
[Part II]
ISSUE:
1) Is the representation -”The best car in the world” mere puff? (Or can Michael get compensation because of the disappointment of the quality of the car)
2) Regarding to the disclaimers, is this a misleading or deceptive conduct or it is Michael’s mistake.
2) Is the competition a fraudulent
Study Guide to accompany Canadian Business and the Law, 5th edition Chapter 6 CHAPTER 6 FORMING CONTRACTUAL RELATIONSHIPS Objectives After studying this chapter, you should have an understanding of • how negotiations lead to a contractual relationship • how negotiations can be terminated • the legal ingredients of a contract • how contracts can be amended or changed Learning Outcomes • • • Understand how business negotiations can result in the formation of a contract or terminate without legal…
Tiffany Ly Business Law February 11, 2011 Robinson Law and Business Natural law is one of the oldest of its kind. The natural law theory believes that there is a higher law and it applies to all human beings and if a law is unjust then it does not have to be obeyed. Natural law is based on fairness and equity and this can easily relate back to the world of business. One major question that lies in international business is whether or not foreign employees should have the same protection…
the Congress can regulate a local business if doing so is in the national interest. This includes situations where the actions of many small businesses taken together could have an inter-state effect. In Heart of Atlanta Motel v. United States case, the court decided that a local hotel would have to comply with federal stature and follow the requirements of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, because it is part of the commerce/travel. Even though it is a local business, the Congress has the power to regulate…
Business Law Term Paper Legal Analysis of Dating Site User Agreement Chosen Site: eHarmony BUSI 2601B Dr. G. Levasseur March 8th, 2015 Table of Contents I Executive Summary 1 II Introduction 3 Overview and Objectives: 3 Methodology: 3 Business Relationship: 5 III Clausal Description and Explanation 6 Document 1: Privacy Policy (3 pages) 6 Document Two: Terms of Service (five pages) 18 IV Application of Legal Principles 32 V Lessons Learned, Recommendations and Example Scenario 46…
Business Law “The doctrine laid down in Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd [1897] AC 22 has to be watched very carefully. It has often been supposed to cast a veil on the personality of a limited company through which the courts cannot see. But that is not true. The courts can, and often do, draw aside the veil. They can, and often do, pull off the mark. They look to see what really lies behind” - Lord Denning in Littlewoods Mail Order Stores v Inland revenue Commissioners [1969] 3 All ER 422.…
Chapter one Business Law Law is a set of rules, enforceable by the courts, which regulate the government of the state and governs the relationship between the state and its citizens and between one citizen and another. There are various ways in which the law may be classified; the most important are: * Public and private law * A) Public law is concerned with the relationship between the state and its citizens. Specialised areas are: 1. Constitutional law is concerned with the workings…
sovereign power. State regulatory powers are often referred to as: police powers. In an equal protection inquiry, when a law or action distinguishes between or among individuals, the basis or classification, is examined. Depending on the classification, the courts apply different levels of scrutiny or “tests” to determine whether the law or action violates the equal protection clause. The courts use one of three standards: strict scrutiny, intermediate scrutiny, or the: “rational…
Resources in a Business Context BUS 746 Law Assignment 1A Amit Bhanot S12003170 Question Two ‘Equally, it is recognized that the formal and rather intimidating atmosphere of the ordinary courts is not necessarily the most appropriate one in which to decide such matters. Even where the dispute cannot be resolved internally. In recognition of this fact, various alternatives have been developed specifically to avoid the perceived shortcomings of the formal structure of law and court procedure…
Business Law Law- the body of rules that can be enforced by the courts or by other government agencies. Sophisticated Client- Person who understands the role of a lawyer and knows when to represent himself/herself and when to get the help of a lawyer. They understand the cost associated with a lawyer and how the process works. Legal Aid- Legal help for people who cannot afford a lawyer. Civil Law- A list of codes that judges apply to cases. Common Law- Law based on past decisions made by the…
Name of Partnership: The name of the partnership shall be JDM Lawn Care. Place of Business: The partnership’s place of business shall be at 123 Green Way, Greenwood SC 29649 Purpose of Partnership: The purpose of the partnership are for regular lawn care maintance, landscape design, and project management. In addition to the specific purposes set above, the pupose of the partnership is also to conduct a lawful business in which the partners might come engage.…