What was the legal issue in this case?
This case was a review of citations for violations of several OSHA standards mandated for construction contractors that R. Williams Construction (Williams or the Company) had been cited for. The court was asked to review the citations and decide if they should be upheld. The legal issue in the case was whether the Company had actually violated OSHA safety standards.
What did the employer do or fail to do that violated the OSH Act?
Williams was cited for a total of five violations that were linked to the collapse of a trench that the company had excavated for a new sewer line. Two workers were caught in the trench collapse. One worker was rescued with serious injuries, while the other was killed in the collapse (Serrano, 2003).
One of the citations was an alleged willful violation, which was reduced to a serious violation during the original hearing conducted by an OSHRC administrative law judge (ALJ). “The first citation charged the Company with failing to instruct its employees in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe conditions and in the regulations applicable to their work environment.” (Fletcher, 2006, para. 5)
The ALJ found that Williams provided no training in the hazards of trenching for at least two of the employees that had been working in the trench. “Joseph Goforth, an employee who started working for Williams four days before the trench collapse, testified that he occasionally worked in the trench and received no training when he started work.” (Fletcher, 2006, para. 9) Goforth also stated that there had been no discussion around rules and he had not been shown a safety manual. Palomar, the employee who survived the trench’s collapse, testified that he had not been given any training in trench safety in the entire nine month period that he had worked for Williams (Fletcher, 2006).
There was testimony given by a supervisor of the work site, who was supposed to be responsible for employee safety, that he had never made himself familiar with the safety manual provided to him by the Company. Due to this testimony, the ALJ also found that there were no Williams’ supervisor familiarity with OSHA regulations (Walsh, 2010, p. 483).
The second citation that the Company was charged with entailed how far an employee had to travel to reach a safe place to exit the trench. The Company was in violation of regulation 29 C.F.R. § 1926.651(c)(2) “…by providing only one safe means of egress at the east end of the 45-foot trench.” (Fletcher, 2006, para. 7) The company failed to have additional areas of exit that allowed workers to have to travel no more than 25 feet in order to leave the trench. “A violation is established so long as employees have access to a dangerous area more than 25 feet from a means of egress.” (Fletcher, 2006, para. 8)
The third citation was for the violation of an OSHA regulation requiring for the construction company to ensure that a knowledgeable individual with detailed training in soil analysis, which could also recognize safety concerns during daily inspections of the trench, was present at the work site.
Williams failed to have a supervisor that was aware of the basic principles to ensuring a safe work site. There was no one at the work site that was “…capable…of identifying and correcting existing and predictable hazards in their surroundings.” (Walsh, 2010, p. 483) Testimony by John (JP) Williams, the previously mentioned supervisor, confirmed that the Company had failed to have the required OSHA trained “competent person” due to his only training being what he had gotten while on the job. “He was unfamiliar with OSHA sloping and trenching requirements and did not conduct any physical tests on the soil in the trench.” (Walsh, 2010, p. 483)
The fourth violation of OSHA regulations was cited due to the Company’s failure to protect its employees from cave-ins. The walls of the trench were not properly sloped or
Related Documents: R. Williams Construction Vs. OSHRC
Introduction R. WILLIAMS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, Petitioner, v. OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY 7 HEALTH REVIEW COMMISSION; Elaine Chao, Secretary of Labor, Respondents, No. 04-74247, Decided: October 3, 2006. This case proceeding arises under the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 (29 U.S.C. Section 651-678: hereafter called the “Act”). The respondent, R. Williams Construction Company (Williams), maintained a place of business at the Chumash Casino Project, Santa Ynez, California, where it was engaged…
Assignment #4 – R. Williams Construction Co. v. OSHRC Sarah Barnard February 26, 2012 Business Employment Law - HRM 510 Dr. Zelphia A. Brown, SPHR, Instructor Assignment # 4- R. Williams Construction Co. v. OSHRC 1. What were the legal issues in this case? This case is based around the laws and regulations of OSHA. OSHA is an Occupational Safety and Health Act that has been put into place to ensure the safety of employees while on the job. These regulations are put into place to help…
ACTG 351 HW #1 Answers 1. Curtiss Construction Company, Inc. entered into a fixed-price contract with Axelrod Associates on July 1, 2011, to construct a four-story office building. At that time, Curtiss estimated that it would take between two and three years to complete the project. The total contract price for construction of the building is $4,000,000. The building was completed on December 31, 2013. Accumulated contract costs incurred, estimated costs to complete the contract, accumulated billings…
, i · log−1 (−˜ ) − YA (Z − 1, e) n Y e∼Z = = 1 : kℵ0 ≥ lim inf −1 O→1 G ≥ i × 1: 1 > (−i, . . . , 0) . Recently, there has been much interest in the description of subalegebras. We show that γC,J is distinct from y . G. M. Williams [35] ˆ improved upon the results of K. Jackson by classifying factors. Recent interest in sub-prime, Gaussian, positive triangles has centered on describing degenerate, super-trivially Artinian, contra-almost everywhere null domains. 1…
A) Gerald R. Ford B) Carl Levin C) Philip A. Hart D) Arthur H. Vandenberg 17.Who was elected Detroit's first black mayor? A) Dennis Archer B) William Hart C) Coleman A. Young D) Kwame Kilpatrick 18.In 1973, when the Michigan Chemical Corporation accidentally mixed its highly toxic chemical fire retardant, P.B.B., with "Nutrimaster…
Canada created a crown corporation, Canada Harbour Place Corporation (now known as Canada Place Corporation), to develop the Canada Place project on the Pier B-C site. Construction began when HM Queen Elizabeth II arrived on the royal yacht Britannia with The Right Hon. Pierre Trudeau, Prime Minister of Canada and The Hon. William R. Bennett, Premier of BC to initiate the first concrete pour. During Expo ’86, the Canada Pavilion at Canada Place was opened by HRH Prince Charles and The Right Hon.…
Business Source Complete, EBSCOhost. [Accessed 11 March 2013] | Aim / Purpose of article | To define how the way leaders and managers perceive and categorize their own perspective about the difference between leadership and management. Especially in construction industry. | Sample, location, method of data collection and analysis | Interviews - conducted with 49 leaders and senior executives. Sample - Combination of purposive and snowball sampling. Selected through a peer nomination process. | Findings/Interpretations…
incorporated in Seattle by William Boeing as “Pacific Aero Products Co” July 27, 1928 - the 12-passenger Boeing 80 biplane made its first flight Commercial Airplanes and Defense, Space & Security Corporate offices in Chicago 169,000 employees in 65 countries History of Union In 1936 – First industrial union agreement About 10 different Unions – International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers (IAM) In 1988 19 machinists vote to form a union - IAM Thomas R. Buffenbarger 13th…
Crime at its simplest is an act prohibited by law upon pain of punishment (Hall-Williams 1964). Theorists such as McCabe (1983:49) stated that no word in legal and criminological terms could define the word crime for the varying content in which an act is categorised. Due to the broad spectrum surrounding crime, differing understandings about human subjects and premises lead to the development of several theories, assumptions and forms of criminal law. Michael and Adler (1933:2) are often cited…
celebrity culture, which has historically developed from the mid-Eighteenth Century. Referring to Andrew Spicer’s lecture on ‘Celebrity Culture and Stardom’, naming Lord Byron, that become: “…One of the great figures of British Romanticism together with William Wordsworth, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Shelley and Keats.” These celebrities, as well as artists and composers, became famous, more or less on their own steam, as they were exceptionally talented in their own field, considering the fact there was…