So by having a story that casts doubt on the novels veracity, he is obliging the reader to think about these questions. The book is 'about' the Vietnam war, at least it uses the war as a platform, and the war itself does raise huge questions about truth and fact, about the use of propaganda and misinformation and about the credibility of politicians and military leaders. 1. I think the story Rat tells is even more compelling because it has elements of fantasy in it. Fantasy is made to draw people into a story when they might otherwise not be. I believed the majority of it, and I liked all the seemingly exaggerated details of the story. I think this story fits perfectly with O'Brien's criteria for a true war story. At first it didn't because Rat added his personal bias, but after he stopped doing that, he really pulled people into the story and got them completely immersed in it. It was so compelling that it got me, as a reader, to believe everything that was being said. Rat later admitted to making parts up, but he got the people listening to believe everything was true, so he succeeded at getting people to hang on his every word and believe him. They didn't question what he told them until after he said he had created some parts himself afterwards.
I think O'Brien casts doubt on the truthfulness of the novel to continue supporting the point that everything ever said about a war is not entirely truthful. War has such a profound impact on people that they can't help but add a little bit of their own personal feelings and experiences into a story about the war. He wants the readers of the novel to understand that even what HE is saying is not entirely truthful. It's an interesting point that he makes, but part of me wishes that everything he says about the Vietnam War is true because the stories are so interesting. It decreases my understanding of the novel somewhat because now I don't know what to distinguish as real and fake. The difference between "story truth" and "happening truth" is that the happening truth is what actually happened. The story truth is for when people are telling others about what happened to them and the others that were with them, but addend new details to the story, ultimately making it more interesting. The story truth is
all the time. There are times when the story truth can be truer, I think, than a happening truth” (120). Many literary scholars have struggled with the “truth” in one of O’Brien’s most famous works, The Things They Carried, a collection of twenty-two tales on the Vietnam War that stand alone just as strongly as they tie together. Although O’Brien is a Vietnam War veteran, unwillingly drafted in 1968 and serving until 1970, he purposively fictionalizes the war experience throughout The Things They…
Samuel Spence 4/20/2014 Professor Dunick EGL 1020 The short story “ The Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien he wrote this story pertaining to the Vietnam War. The war actually changed to mindset of Tim O’Brien and it gave him even more of a reason to write about it. The Vietnam War drafted many 18 year olds to fight for their Country, being though most haven’t ever touched a gun. This story displayed from the young soldiers a physiological loss of innocence. Also the emotionally…
there’s been always war of communism in the United States during the 1960’s, the United States had incrementally learn the values of their previous wars. Inequality between races had finally come to and understanding and the voice of many United States citizens made a decision and the words and ideas grow greatly. At that time war also covered the hall nation with negativity as of media lies and political views with bad views. The new Americans were talking about Vietnam War that had taken a lot…
will write about. For Tim O'Brien, the Vietnam war will change his life entirely, and change the way his life will turn out. There is influence of the Vietnam War may be seen in every single one of O'Brien's works of literature, and being as involved as he was with the war, it gave him special insight into what war is really like which is very obvious from reading his writing. It has also given experiences in which to base his novels and short stories around, he is able to make his fictional…
‘Television brought the brutality of the war into the comfort of the living room. Vietnam was lost in the living rooms of America – not on the battlefields of Vietnam.’ (Marshall McLuhan, 1975). What evidence exists to demonstrate that the American media coverage of the Vietnam War influenced its outcome? There are only two comprehensive inferences that can be drawn upon when assessing the impact and legacy of the reporting of the Vietnam War on America and its media; the impact was enormous…
from Scar That Binds: American Culture and the Vietnam War and the article by Coe (2011), compare and contrast public opinions and support in United States for the Vietnam War with the war in Iraq. What role did propaganda play in shaping public opinion? Throughout the 60’s, television was becoming the major source of news for Americans as it grew from news briefs to half hour narratives on what was going on in the country and the world. The war in Vietnam in all its seriousness and death was brought…
wrote the short story collection: The Things They Carried, approximately 20 years after his experiences at the Vietnam War. His collection of Vietnam War stories stood out for me because O'Brien is more interested in subverting the status quo of traditional Vietnam stories, so it isn't just a typical shoot'em up collection. I also liked O'Brien's intimate describing of his experiences, and how his stories all have interesting elements to them because he was a soldier of the Vietnam War. We read about…
celebrating their thirtieth reunion. It switches between stories of the reunion itself and stories of each of their pasts. In this way, July, July closely examines the generation represented. The Things They Carried follows a young man, named Tim O’Brien, who is drafted to fight in the Vietnam War. It chronicles his life before, during, and after the war. Though The Things They Carried is largely based on the experiences of O’Brien during the war, ultimately, it is fictional. However this does not detract…
1c. Herr emphasizes how the American military ravaged the jungles of Vietnam. More importantly, he uses the jungle to depict the devastation American soldiers did to Vietnam. “..we never announced any policy at all..” America was in Vietnam to search and destroy anything that whiffed of Communism. Herr describes the damage of the ecosystem in a way that displays pride in being an American. “Employing saturation-bombing technqiues…” There is a vivid description on the imprint of America’s patriotism…
Anh Do’s story is a timely reminder of the plight of refugee in our country. Discuss the Happiest Refugee in the light of Do’s universal message about the suffering of human beings during times of war and the struggle to make a better life in a foreign country. The Happiest Refugee is a memoir written by Anh Do which was first published on the 1st of August in 2010. It is regarded as one of the most influential and well-received novels in the world of literature for its great insight on the life…