UCMP Teacher Website on Evolution: Summary of Evaluation Methods and Findings
Rockman et al (REA), an independent research and evaluation group with expertise in technology interventions in education, conducted a thorough, multi-component evaluation of WWW.evolution. Over the course of the website’s development, the evaluation explored multiple aspects of the website and its constituent elements, ranging from its appeal and utility, to its ability to help users understand new concepts and acquire strategies for and confidence in teaching evolution. The evaluation included both formative elements intended to help the design team create an appealing, user-friendly, and useful website, and summative elements designed to explore the impact of the site on its target populations.
Evaluation Methodology
A national database of prospective evaluation participants was generated by aggregating contact lists from UCMP and Rockman et al (REA). The database contained entries for 246 individuals at the time of the first evaluation activity (Fall 2001), and grew to contain 402 entries by the time of the final evaluation activity (Spring 2005). This pool was comprised of formal and informal educators who had previously attended one or more UCMP-sponsored workshops or short courses on evolution at a regional or national conference and expressed interest in learning more about evolution, as well as educators who were referred by state science teacher associations, science and science education organizations, their school districts, or teacher colleagues that agreed to advertise the trial program and the opportunity to participate in its evaluation. The evaluation activities were thus promoted both among teachers who were highly motivated to teach evolution, as well as teachers who may have been less likely to teach evolution. The recruitment pool also included educators who, rather than being referred by an organization or colleague, volunteered independently to participate in evaluation activities after browsing the UCMP website.
REA staff emailed potential participants an invitation to complete a brief online survey, hosted on REA’s server, to gather demographic information about their educational background, amount of teaching experience, level of expertise in teaching evolution, and grade levels and subjects taught. The educational levels taught by the volunteer pool included elementary, middle and high school, and college.
With the exception of the web site log file analysis, recruitment for each evaluation activity was carried out by email invitations from REA staff. For two of the evaluation activities, namely the Fall 2001 online survey and Fall 2003 section review/impact surveys, REA staff initially targeted all participants in the database, in an effort to maximize the sample size.
In general, selection of participants was guided by sample specifications that were defined by UCMP staff and approved by REA researchers. UCMP staff were interested in the selection of samples that would represent, to the greatest extent possible:
• A range of geographic areas in the U.S. (e.g., West, Midwest, South, Northeast); • A range of grade level(s) taught—elementary (K-5), middle school (6-8), high school (9-12), and college, with an emphasis on middle and high school; • Varying amounts of expertise in evolutionary concepts, based on the subject of the participants’ degree or certification, as follows: • Novice - any non-science subject, such as English, Education, Special Education, etc. • Intermediate - Science Education, Composite Science, Secondary Science, etc. • Expert - Biology, Zoology, Genetics, Plant Breeding, etc.
Recruitment for some activities purposefully included or excluded individuals with prior exposure to the website. For example, for the pre/post assessments of teacher knowledge, REA staff initially sent invitations to a selection of 200 educators, drawn
Related Documents: UCMP Teacher Website On Evolution
True? No, false. Have you ever been given information that you believed to be true, just to find out years later that it's false? Your mind is so set on believing that that information is true; so, when given the actual truth, you have a hard time changing your mindset. That false piece of information is still true in your mind, and the truth is far fetched and unbelievable. Up until today, I believed that you couldn’t start a sentence with “but”. Ever since I learned how to write I was told…
Allahu la ilaha illa Huwa, Al-Haiyul-Qaiyum La ta'khudhuhu sinatun wa la nawm, lahu ma fis-samawati wa ma fil-'ard Man dhal-ladhi yashfa'u 'indahu illa bi-idhnihi Ya'lamu ma baina aidihim wa ma khalfahum, wa la yuhituna bi shai'im-min 'ilmihi illa bima sha'a Wasi'a kursiyuhus-samawati wal ard, wa la ya'ooduhu hifdhuhuma Wa Huwal 'Aliyul-Adheem The night was chilly. I remained still, refusing to shiver. Any movement would be heard by prey I stalked. Even my breathing was slow and…
conflict that we each must face within our life. We should always believe in ourselves and feel confident about the choices and decisions we make. In addition, Batmans willing to make the ultimate sacrifice to save his city. This action showed us the true meaning of heroism. Being a hero could mean getting fired from a job, arrested, injured, or even facing death to sacrifice for others A hero is someone who we looked up to as role models someone who we can trust and call upon to when we need help…
Dreams Come True Walter E. Disney once said, "You can design and create, and build the most wonderful place in the world. But it takes people to make the dream a reality." He was a man that turned his dreams into reality with the help of his many followers, which showed his true leadership. Today, Disney is one of the important entertainment businesses; bringing remarkable profits not to mention the abundance of joy it brings many people. It has not always been this easy for Disney however. It…
True Friendship Do you know what kind of friendship is true? People always think about this question for a long time. Society always has a lot of definitions. However, how many people know someone who has true friend in their life? I think true friends must listen to you, take care of you, and tell you when you make a mistake. First, true friends must listen to you when you want to speak. People always have a number of disappointments in life. You want to speak to other people about your disappointment…
to subject matters within Psychology. True experiment is one of the main experimental methods which are believed to bring a high level of precision; it is also the only process that can assuredly establish causal relationships between variables. However, there is no experimental method that will provide perfect precision. A true experiment is carried out when the experimenter has total control over the fluctuating factors of the study. The main aspects of a true experiment are randomized assignments…
What is a true hero? What makes a person heroic? Many think that the only heroes are the ones on television like Batman or Superman. Or they think that firefighters and policeman are the heroes in our community because they save people from danger. A hero is someone who sacrifices things that they have for the better of other people. Now if you think about it, the heroes we think of are the firefighters and police officers, but what they do is their job. They are supposed to save that person from…
convicted in 2009 of abducting his young daughter in Boston after his wife divorced him. The best estimation of what causes a person to become a psychopath is a combination of genetics and environment, Mr. Silver said. Research shows that with a true psychopath, there is less mass in the area of the brain that processes emotions, and that impairs the ability to sense other people’s emotions. For instance, such people have difficulty sensing and understanding when a person’s face is showing fear…
True Honor The Red Badge of Courage is a tale of values, honor, conflicted motivations, and a crisis of purpose and meaning. The main character, Henry, is a young man who is forced to reconcile his naïve belief that war is desirous, glorious, and that the appearance of pain and suffering is honorable, with the horrible truth that war is frightening, destructive, and terrifyingly painful for those who are inflicted with a red badge of courage. The reader first meets Henry as a young man who maintains…
Jackson Hull Jake Schwaller English 101-17 25 October 2012 Abortion: The True Story Abortion!!! These days it’s one of the most contentious topics around, especially with the 2012 presidential election and women’s rights all being affected by it. One of the most notable happenings in the world of abortion politics would be the new law in Arizona that outlaws abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy, this law was put in place due to studies cited by many pro-life politicians that indicates that…