The slow pace of institutional change in the Italian food system
Maria Paola Ferrettia,Ã, Paolo Magauddab a Centre for European Law and Politics (ZERP), University of Bremen, Bremen, Germany b Department of Sociology, University of Padova, Padova, Italy
Abstract Recent surveys show that Italians have little trust in the food they eat. This seems at odds with the world-wide popularity of Italian food, and the very prominent role that the agro-food sector has in the national economy and culture. This paper aims to explain this apparent contradiction by examining recent political and economic changes in the food sector. From the analysis it emerges that, facing institutional crises and food scandals, Italian politicians have left the task of reassuring consumers to the market. However, the market actors’ strategy has been to prioritise the discourse of food quality, but give little weight to some other important preoccupation of consumers, such as safety. To address these concerns a more proactive role of the State would be required. An actual concern of public institutions with consumer needs, institutional efficiency, transparency and accountability emerges as a crucial factor in restoring and maintaining trust. r 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Trust; Food safety; Institutions; Regulation; Typicality; Italy
Introduction: gourmands who do not trust In Italy, the agro-food sector is not only crucial for the national economy, but it also represents a strong factor in cultural identification. Pizza, spaghetti, olive oil and icecream are but some of the symbols of Italy abroad. Italians are proud of their culinary tradition and its fortune abroad, and many have cherished the recent decision to locate the European Food Safety Agency (EFSA) in Parma as due acknowledgment of the city as the European capital of food (Interview Coldiretti; INALCA). However, the comparative survey carried out by the TRUSTINFOOD research project reveals that levels of trust in food in Italy are some of the lowest in Europe, and most importantly, this attitude does not seem to be related to particular products that have been the object of recent food scandals, but is generalised to all foods (Poppe & Kijarnes, 2003). This data seems to corroborate the findings of other studies on trust levels. Already in the 1950s Edward
ÃCorresponding author.
E-mail addresses: Ferretti@zerp.uni-bremen.de (M.P. Ferretti), paolo.magaudda@unipd.it (P. Magaudda). 0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2006.05.005
Banfield called ‘‘amoral familism’’ the deep mistrusts that Italians show toward others, except members of one’s own family (Banfield, 1958). More recently a wealth of empirical data has attested to a lack of trust in many basic institutions such as political parties, unions, big industrial companies and courts (see for example: European Values Survey, 1999–2000). These observations help us to put into context the findings from the TRUSTINFOOD survey; it would, however, be too simplistic to understand the level of trust in food simply as a reflection of the general mistrust of institutions. In fact, this cannot explain many of the peculiarities of the Italian consumer emerging from the survey. In particular, when compared to other European consumers, Italians seem to give a remarkable relevance to aspects such as personal relationships with the staff of the shop where they purchase food, and its origin. Moreover, they declare a strong preference for food produced locally and nationally, and a high concern for the taste and safety of beef. On the other hand, they tend to be less concerned with the importance of the dietetic aspects of food, as well as its price, as illustrated in Fig. 1. This article suggests that the survey findings can be explained by looking at the changes and
beyond soup; Pepperidge farm cookies, goldfish crackers, Arnott’s, Kjeldsens and Royal Dansk biscuits; V8 juices; Bolthouse Farms super-premium beverages, carrots and dressings; Plum Organics premium organic baby food; Swanson broths; Prego pasta sauces; and Pace Mexican sauce History: Joseph Campbell (a fruit merchant) and Abraham Anderson (an icebox manufacturer) form the business in 1869 in Camde, New Jersey In 1876 Anderson leaves the partnership and in 1882 Arthur Dorrance joins Campbell to form…
International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimated world growth for this year at 0.5%, even though the forecast still had been 2.2% in November 2008. These data are not only the worst since World War II but they have evolved at an unprecedented breathtaking pace, which makes it very difficult to have an overall view of what the longterm impact of the crisis will be once it is over. Opinions on its duration and depth are diverse and changing as this article is being written. In January 2009, consumption went…
Isabella Clark Ryan Hernandez Tamera Panjalingam Manny Lemos Cori Wong 3.2.5 Metabolism Bios: Jeremy Brown is a 24yearold man who has always been in good health. A busy law student, Jeremy finds he has less and less time to exercise. He used to cook most of his meals at home, but now he grabs whatever he can when he is on the way to the library or to class. His doctor just called him to let him know that his routine physical results revealed a mildly elevated LDL and a low HDL level…
Walmart Case Analysis Situational (SWOT) Analysis Internal Factors (Strengths & Weaknesses) Strengths With a store available in each corner, nationally and internationally, Walmart is a superpower retail brand. Using an immaculate pricing strategy, Walmart has imprinted on the minds of the consumers the “Everyday low prices, rollback, and special buy.” Walmart provides an immense variety of products that reaches all cultures and social levels. “Walmart helps people around the world save…
Assignment 2 – Individual Assignment 1 Case 6 – Domino’s Pizza: A Case Study in Organizational Evolution Overview of Domino’s Pizza Domino's Pizza is an international pizza delivery corporation headquartered in Michigan, United States. Founded in1960, Domino's is the second largest pizza chain in the United States and has more than 9,300 corporate and franchised stores in 65 international markets and all U.S. states. Question 1: Internal Analysis of Domino’s Pizza The internal analysis…
Marketing Plan Erik Wohler, Adnan Otovic, and Joshua Adamson MKT/421 – Marketing March 28, 2013 R. Scott Bluemel Marketing Plan: Phase I Overview of the Organization The entertainment industry is a vastly changing business, although the ideology has stayed the same throughout history. Since the earliest documented cases started appearing, stories and music were used to overcome and surpass dark times in cultures throughout the world. In more recent historical examples, during the great depression…
Engaging young people Local authority youth work 2005–08 Engaging young people draws upon evidence from local authority youth services inspections which took place as part of Ofsted’s joint area reviews of children’s and young people’s services from 2005 to 2008. It reports on the quality and impact of youth work. The report tracks recent but early developments in the introduction of integrated youth support. Age group: 14–19 Published: March 2009 Reference no: 080141 Contents Executive summary…
PART ONE Medical-Surgical Cases 1 1 Cardiovascular Cardiovascular Disorders Case Study 1 Heart Failure Difficulty: Beginning Setting: Emergency department, hospital Index Words: heart failure (HF), cardiomyopathy, volume overload, quality of life X Scenario M.G., a “frequent flier,” is admitted to the emergency department (ED) with a diagnosis of heart failure (HF). She was discharged from the hospital 10 days ago and comes in today stating, “I just had to come to the hospital today because I…