Arizona Immigration Law
The Constitution of The United States was built on the purpose to provide rights and protection for all citizens as well as instructions on how the government should administrate the people. The United States has faced a great challenge in determining the precise necessities of its inhabitants when it comes to illegal immigration. Consequently, politicians whose strategies emphasize on battling illegal immigration have in the past received much public support from American citizens but, the new Arizona law seems to be taking a different turn with some citizens supporting it and others strongly opposing it. In April Arizona lawmakers approved one of the harshest immigration laws of all time which is living in the United States of America without the proper registration credentials. This law grants the police the authority to stop, question and examine the immigration status of people whom they suspect to be illegal immigrants in the United States.
Arizona’s new immigration law, known as SB1070 or Senate Bill 1070, was approved by Arizona lawmakers and signed into law by Governor Jan Brewer. Signed April 23, 2010, the law provoked massive public attention both locally and internationally. The problems drawn out by this heated debate are connected to the impact of the law on individuals, employers, employees and Arizonian citizens in general. This law prohibits state, city or county officials from carrying out a punishment that goes against the immigration laws and permits Arizonians to bring a court case on any official who puts into effect a policy that opposes the federal immigration law. Lawsuits are extremely discouraged because the law states that if one sues and loses the case he/she must compensate the accused official. The law also requires the police to search the immigration status of people they logically suspect of being in the U.S. without the right credentials needed. As long as they have sufficient justification to think that a person may be an illegal immigrant, police officers do not need a warrant to arrest the suspect.
The Border States crime levels are very high. As a result, some Arizonians claim that the non-Arizonians opposing the law are not affected by illegal immigration that much as they are and are not aware of the situations they must deal with on a daily basis. Supporters claim that if crime levels are reduced to insignificant levels, then the Arizona immigration law must be allowed to take its course. Supporters of the SB1070 law, with consideration to social costs and jobs, claim that the law may save the government and American citizens from arising social costs from illegal immigrants and competition of job. When illegal immigrants get sick, they go to the same hospitals as other citizens and many times fail to pay their medical expenses. Hospitals must continue running so those costs are transferred to the government and taxpayers and must get paid; many Americans argue this is an economic hold up for the entire U.S. society.
Excessive police force, bad press images of the Arizonian government and other related issues have a big risk in disagreements against this law; racial profiling is the most common issue among the problems of the Arizona immigration law. Although many Americans support the new law, several cities have staged protests against the SB1070 law. Those against the law claim that it will spread racial profiling and the authorization given to the police will cause the most discrimination against African Americans and Hispanics who are the most defenseless to federal laws and other laws as opposed to American Natives.
Opponents claim that the grounds of suspicion offered by the law are not clear and the law therefore gives excessive authorization to law enforcers. Police in the past been reported for racism. Opponents claim that the undefined clauses give the police officers unjustifiable freedom to persecute people based on their own judgments.
Related Documents: The New Arizona Immigration Law Essay
2012 Arizona Law Faces Discriminatory Issues We are all victims of discrimination. It is inevitable by all who live in any society. Recently, the United States has encountered a new face of discrimination. The number of illegal immigrants has increased causing the U.S. to create ways on bringing numbers back to balance. The new Arizona law allows officials to question people to prove their legal residency if they have “probable cause” of being an illegal immigrant. Both news stations, Fox News and…
Governor of Arizona, signed one of the toughest bills gearing towards illegal immigration." (New York Times, 2010) The Arizona immigration law, also known as SB1070, is a law stating that if a person fails to provide the proper documentation showing that they are a legal alien they are convicted of a misdemeanor. This law also allows law enforcement officials to ask any suspicious person for documentation papers after any lawful contact. I strongly agree with the SB1070 law for many…
Arizonas law "Stopping Arizona's Anti-Immigration Law." Editorial. The New York Times (April 30, 2010) http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/30/opinion/30fri1.html This New York Times article outlines the author's perspective on Arizona's new immigration law. The author questions the beliefs in which this country was founded upon saying, “Is our core belief still the welcome and assimilation of newcomers?” This article is suggesting that it is time for the federal government step in and put an…
Contemporary Proposal A seemingly controversial topic over the course of American history has been immigration and the formation of the laws for the issue. Throughout our country’s history, if one wasn’t an American born citizen, they were then considered an immigrant. Over the years certain measures or laws were made to restrict or reduce the number of immigrants allowed into the Continental U.S.A. Only until Ellis Island open in 1892 were immigrants allowed to flow into America and granted…
Mexican Immigration Outline SOC305/CULTURAL DIVERSITY DR. Alex Espadas May 27, 2013 By: Jamie Burrell, Sherrelle McCloud, and Kimberly Ramirez Economic Opportunity A.Issues in the labor force with Mexican immigrants i. Hard to find good paying jobs in The United States ii.Many Mexican immigrants are low skilled iii.As the labor market changes it is causing migration back to Mexico (Portes, A. 1997). B. Many immigrants are employed in low wage, dangerous jobs i. The health of the immigrant…
United States v. Arizona: The Support Our Law Enforcement and Neighborhoods Act is Preempted and Discriminatory Melissa Goolsarran Table of Contents I. Introduction 1 II. Perspective: Immigration, Discrimination, and Limitations on State Laws 3 III. Background: United States v. Arizona 9 A. S.B. 1070 and the Legislature’s Justification 10 B. The Decision: United States v. Arizona 18 IV. Analysis: S.B. 1070 is Preempted by Federal Immigration Law and Also Discriminatory 23 A. The…
States Immigration Policy Our economic times, international relations, and terrorism have shaped our countries immigration policy. These issues have driven us to pass legislation opening and closing our borders in response to current events. Though not always at the forefront of concern, it has been a constant struggle that has affected the dynamics of our country. Arizona’s recent passing of tough immigration laws aimed at identifying and deporting illegal immigrants has again put immigration at…
administration has attempted dealing with is immigration. According to Homeland Security as of 2012, there are an estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the U.S., and according to an ABC news report titled “Expensive Aliens: How Much Do Illegal Immigrants Really Cost?” illegal aliens cost U.S. taxpayers more than $100 billion each year. I find these numbers extremely disturbing and the numbers are why I think the Obama Administration policy on Immigration need a through analysis. In this paper, I…
Alabama’s Immigration Law In the last few years, States such as Arizona, Utah, Georgia, and Indiana have all passed illegal immigration laws. The latest state to pass an immigration bill is Alabama. HB 56 is 72 pages long, and was passed in June, 2011. The new law took effect on September 1, 2011. This paper focuses on three of the most talked about provisions in the Alabama illegal immigration law, although the many lawsuits filed consist of other provisions that…
Employment Law Compliance At your request, I am developing an employment plan to enforce the law to help you with the extension of Clapton Commercial Construction. There are employment laws that you should be made aware of to get (HR) department of Human Resources ready for expansion in Arizona. This document is determined by federal and state labor laws, which relate to the minimum wage required job postings, occupational health and safety, immigration reform and legal professionals, as well as…