Essay on Terror: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Amendment
Submitted By tcpjets2
Words: 2981
Pages: 12
Lundquist & Massey, Politics or Economics? (HuskyCT) Journal #5: What is a push factor according to Lundquist and
Massey?
Paived roads, political stability, economy, social…,capital, sympathetic of migrants from Nicaragua because of political ties
Journal #6: Explain the Supreme Court’s decision to deny Verdugo-Urquidez the right to a 4th Amendment? Should aliens kidnapped by U.S. authority be entitled to the 4th Amendment? The supreme court decided held that the “Fourth amendment does not apply to the search and seizure by United States agents of property owned by a nonresident alien and located in a foreign country.” Many in the court believe that there is no legal use of a search warrant if it is being used outside of U.S. borders. A US magistrate simply does not have the legal power to authorize such a warrant. The court felt that the fourth amendment secured only the members of the US community (“the people”). They don't consider Uraquidez to have a legitimate connection to this country. Thus, Uraquidez is not a part of “the people” and should only be afforded fifth and Sixth Amendment rights for criminal procedures. They held that the framers of the constitution designed the fourth amendment with no connections to aliens residing outside US borders. The federal governments actions shouldn't be restrained by the fourth amendment when conducting foreign operations. Aliens that are kidnapped by us authority should be entitled to the fourth amendment. The dissent believed that Uraquidez would have a fourth amendment worthy connection to this country for he was placed, “among those governed by federal criminal laws and investigating him for violations of those laws.” It would only make sense that the laws of the country that he initially broke them in would be used in his criminal judgment. Another view spoke about the significance for obtaining a search warrant in all investigating procedures. The warrant assures that investigating officers wont consider the land beyond US borders as the lawless Wild West. “As a matter of United States constitutional law, a warrant serves the same primary function overseas as it does domestically: it assures that a neutral magistrate has authorized the search and limited its scope. The need to protect those suspected of criminal activity from the unbridled discretion of investigating officers is no less important abroad than at home.” I believe that fourth amendment rights should protect every human. Federal officers cannot have the power to initiate raids without receiving legal authorization. When every person isn’t believed to have equal protection an enormous grey area is created. That grey area has consisted of the kidnapping, torturing, and murdering of innocent people.
The court held that the text, “the people” meant that the fourth amendment only protected a specific class of individuals. The dissent states that, “Throughout that entire drafting process, no speaker or commentator, pro or con, referred to the term "the people" as a limitation. “The People” refers to every person on earth.
given protection Nor is the Warrant Clause inapplicable merely because a warrant from a United States magistrate could not "author- ize" a search in a foreign country. Although this may be true as a matter of international law, it is irrelevant to our interpretation of the Fourth Amendment. As a matter of United States constitutional law, a warrant serves the same primary function overseas as it does domestically: it assures that a neutral magistrate has authorized the search and lim- ited its scope. The need to protect those suspected of crim- inal activity from the unbridled discretion of investigating officers is no less important abroad than at home.14
The conditions and considerations of this case would make adherence to the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement impracticable and anomalous. Just as the
Related Documents: Essay on Terror: Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution and Amendment
American Government The Fourth Amendmet March 21, 2011 Amendment Number IV Amendment number IV was added to Constitution of the United States on December 15, 1791. This amendment gives the people of the United States protection from government agencies and other agencies from entering or searching their homes, and their own private property without a search warrant. Search warrants are obtained by a government official, in most cases a detective…
these civil liberties is free speech the first Amendment protects this right to free speech and expression. Although all of our rights have their restrictions the point is we should be grateful to have them. Because many countries are subject to their countries unfair laws and also unfair taxes just to name a few. A prime example of when freedom of speech can be threatened is when it is considered harmful to others. “In its 1919 Schenck v. United States ruling, the Supreme Court addressed a free…
a plant of rapid growth." -George Washington The Declaration of Independence The U.S. Constitution and its Bill of Rights The Enlightenment and Political Philosophy Expected Outcomes To understand the philosophical principles behind the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, and how these principles influence the structure and process of government. Overview The United States, as a nation, was born of the American Revolution of 1776. This revolution cut the political ties…
Abraham Lincoln suspended the writ of habeas corpus. Additionally, dissidents were imprisoned for criticizing the way the government was fighting the war. There is no evidence that this aided the fighting of the Civil War in any way. Ultimately, the United States Supreme Court declared unconstitutional Lincoln’s suspension of the writ of habeas corpus.2 During World War I, the government aggressively prosecuted critics of the war. One man went to jail for ten years for circulating a leaflet arguing that…
Habeas Corpus and the War on Terror POL201 Instructor Looney 5/31/2014 When an individual is imprisoned they have the right to be brought before a judge to have their case analyzed to determine whether their detained status will be permanent or temporary. This right is called a writ of habeas corpus and it was created in the English legal system, it has now expanded to many nations (Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia.2014). A writ of habeas corpus ensures…
on this nation’s government, security and people. The incensed citizens of this country demanded action and as a result, several different laws were passed. The centerpiece of these laws was the USA PATRIOT Act. The Patriot Act infringes the Constitution by lifting restraints on governmental interference on its citizens’ privacy and should have never been signed into law. 9/11 led to the passing of laws that violate the civil liberties of the people in this country. When discussing the Patriot…
Vespucci.[28] The first documentary evidence of the phrase "United States of America" was in an anonymously written essay published in the Virginia Gazette newspaper in Williamsburg, Virginia on April 6, 1776.[29][30] In June 1776, Thomas Jefferson included the phrase "UNITED STATES OF AMERICA" in all capitalized letters in the headline of his "original Rough draught" of the Declaration of Independence.[31][32] In the final Fourth of July version of the Declaration, the pertinent section of the…
-England +Anne is the Last Stuart -> no heir -Lurking around like Stranger Danger is James the Old Pretender +1708 -> Going to make an attempt along with his followers (follow rightful heir) in England to take the throne; try to overthrow Anne -Scottish and English supporters and an army, but are unsuccessful -Anne dies in 1714 -James the Old Pretender never gave up his claim to the throne, just left +Parliament knew this, so they were forced to go to the HRE to one of the German Provinces…
Notes to accompany Chapter 1 Sources of Tax Law The Constitution The Constitution is the basic law of the land, and the statutes passed by Congress are valid only if they are consistent with it. For much of the history of the United States there was no income tax and there was some controversy over whether the Constitution permitted one. This controversy was resolved when the Sixteenth Amendment was passed in 1913. The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from…
the delegates, a permanent chairman is elected. The convention then votes n a platform, drawn up by the platform committee. By the third or fourth day, presidential nominations begin. The chairman calls the roll of states alphabetically. A state may place a candidate in nomination or yield to another state. Voting, again alphabeticaly by roll call of states, begins after all nominations have been made and seconded. A simple majority is required in each party, although this may require many ballots…