Constructive Discharge
Constructive discharge is defined as the action made by the former employee to terminate his or her relationship with the company based on the existence of a hostile environment. In order to justify a claim of constructive discharge, it is common for the former employee to prove that he or her was subject to sexually harassment or discrimination based on sex, religion, age, or national origin. In this case, the former employee is making a claim that discrimination occurred based on religion, due to the enforcement of the new production schedule. The new production schedule required all employees to work on alternating weekends, which includes holy days of the former employee’s religion. The existence of a hostile work environment is based on the pretext that a “reasonable” person would find the work environment to be hostile. This means that the company made working conditions so unbearable that the employee was forced to quit.
Civil Rights Act of 1964
The former employee has filed a claim against the company under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which protects employees from discrimination by the company on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. These groups are known as protected classes, which are groups of people who suffered discrimination in the past and protected by the judicial system from discrimination. Discrimination on the basis of his or her protected class is known as disparate treatment.
The former employee’s claim of discrimination is based on religion. Title VII protects against discrimination on the basis of religion, which includes all aspects of religious observance and practice. Title VII also states that employers must reasonably accommodate to an employee’s religious observance or practice, as long as doing so does not cause an undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business. Company Response
It is recommended that the company’s human resource department, under the guidance of the Equal Employment (EEOC) conduct an investigation, which would include interviews of coworkers, supervisors, managers, and the former employee. In discrimination cases, the organization is responsible for gathering information in order to defend itself.
In the case at hand, I would recommend that the company motion for a summary judgment because the former employee did not make any efforts to contact management about the situation, did not submit any request for paid-time-off or unpaid leave for religious purposes, nor did the former employee file any complaints with human resources that a hostile environment existed, which caused the resignation. The former employee made no efforts to work with management to accommodate time-off for religious purposes.
Legal References
According to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, if the employee can show that 1) he or she had a bona fide religious belief that conflicts with an employment requirement; 2) he or she informed his or her employer of this belief; and 3) he or she was fired for failure to comply with the conflicting employment requirement, then the burden of proof is placed on the employer.
The burden of proof being placed on the employer was established in the Griggs v. Duke Power decision in 1971. Then a 1989 Supreme Court case, Wards Cove Packing Co. v. Antonio, had the effect of placing more of
Related Documents: Task 1 Human Resources Memo Essay examples
old, had been hired as a rig worker in response to an advertisement by Tiger Resources Inc. (“Tiger Resources”) for a “young, strong man, early twenties, who has an Italian background and no history of criminal offences”. John had worked for Tiger Resources for about 1 year, but never signed an employment contract. Eric is 65 and has worked as a field operations manager (under an employment contract) for Tiger Resources for 25 years. Eric is familiar with all aspects of a drilling rig operation…
PART 1: PREWRITING Activity A: Analyze a Task 1. David’s primary purpose in sending a message is to inform the reader that the car company will not honour the customer’s claim. The writer’s priority is to inform the reader that the company would like to honour the claim, but point out that it could not happen because the warranty is expired. 2. David’s secondary purpose in sending a message is to promote goodwill on behalf of the company. He does not want to make the company look bad in the eyes…
Week 1 .what is an organization? An organization is collection of people working together with a division of labor to achieve a common purpose Organization performance Productivity – the quantity and quality of work performance; with resource use considered Performance effectiveness – is an output measure of task or goal accomplishment Performance efficiency – a measure of resource cost associated with goal accomplishment Week 3. Who are Entrepreneurs? An individual who notices opportunities and…
staff of the medical association are successfully trained. There are several parties that will need specific communication and the techniques used to communicate will vary. The parties involved in this project included executive leadership, human resources, legal personnel responsible for conducting the training, office managers, records specialists, administrative assistants, transcriptionists, nurses, doctors, and patients of…
Human Resources Task Human Resources Task 1 Western Governor's University 1 Human Resources Task 2 Interoffice Memo – Kyds Toys To: Jay Kyds: Chief Executive Officer From: Division Manager – Elementary Toys Division Subject: A. K. Whitter Claim of Constructive Discharge Date: 08.03.2014 cc: Legal, Human Resources I. Claim and Constructive Discharge Definition Having received notice of a claim being filed by A.K. Whitter, a former employee of Kyds Toys, alleging forceable resignation due to…
d on what customers ordered. Resources needed for this project include two team members and new equipment which has been outlined in the feasibility reports. The reason for this is that the new ordering system will allow for more customers to reach Lowell Pizza, reduce times of orders, and bring in new customers. This system will use Microsoft Access as well as Java to get the task done. It is recommended that that some activities be done along side other tasks between the two team members in order to meet the time frame of 6 months…
MEMORANDUM To: Senior Vice-President of the Company FROM: Director of Human Resources DATE: October 20th, 2012 SUBJECT: Human Resources Analyze and Report _____________________________________________________________________________ Per your request, the following memo addresses each situation. For each individual incident, I investigated the details of each situation and analyzed the federal act that may apply to the case. Situation A The Law - Situation A is addressed by the…
DESIGN AND IMPROVE APPROPRIATE SYSTEMS 10 Introduction I’m going to use a company called Masters Advertising Ltd., for the entire tasks of this Assignment. The company is an Advertising Agent which having its business in Sri Lanka for the last 46 years. Task 1 a) Examples of Business Decisions Strategic level business decisions. These are the business decisions taken by the top level management by foreseeing the company’s future in…
HUMAN RESOURCE TASK 1 Memo To: CEO Date: 08/01/2013 Re: Lawsuit claim by a former Employee A. CONSTRUCTIVE DISCHARGE A former employee has recently brought a lawsuit against the company claiming a constructive discharge. He/she claims the company has religiously discriminated against him/her and was asked to work during days which his/her religion considers as a holy day which has forced him/her to quit the job because the company has made his/her working conditions unbearable. This memo is…
PAUL LEVY CASE ANALYSIS Levy Makes an Impression even before He’s Hired We first must analyze the decision process and execution of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) to hire Paul Levy as CEO. The hospital was in desperate need of a competent leader who possessed the qualities that would turn around and save the not-for-profit company. In comparing the situation faced by BIDMC with Groysberg’s “Are Leaders Portable?” article, it becomes clear Levy possesses many “portable” qualities…