Shakespeare uses the theme of identity to drive the plot. How successful is this comedic technique?
In ‘The Taming of the Shrew’ identity and mistaken identity drives the comedic impact. Many elements are used to create humour within the play, such as social class, gender roles, disguise and personality. As well as providing a light-hearted portrayal of Elizabethan life, the humour also casts a interrogatory gaze on society at the time, particularly the role of women and expectations surrounding their conformity.
The use of disguising identities is seen as the main and obvious form of mistaken identity, this is shown by characters cross-dressing and swapping roles. The first time the audience experiences cross-dressing in the play is in the induction when Bartholomew, a page boy, dresses as a woman and pretends to be Christopher Sly’s wife. This introduces strong willed women from the outset as Bartholomew doesn’t back down from acting as the wife even though Sly really believes that Bartholomew is his wife and wants Bartholomew to “undress you and come now to bed.” This is comedic as Shakespeare uses dramatic irony to ensure that the audience know that Sly’s wife isn’t actually female but male, a fact of which he is completely unaware. This then highlights how the audience are constantly aware of all the tricks and deception that continues throughout the play. The use of disguise is then also used when Lucentio wants to get closer to Bianca and dresses as a schoolmaster and gets his servant to dress and act as Lucentio, “Thu shalt be master, Tranio, in my stead;”. This is comical to an Elizabethan audiences as its ridiculous and Elizabethans were used to others swapping costumes. Tranio, Lucentio’s servant, acting as Lucentio also creates anticipation in the audience as this deception won’t last and someone will discover his true identity.
Another main catalyst of humour in the play is social class. This is initially seen in the induction when the Lord tricks Sly, who is a drunkard, and says that he is the Lord. This emphasises a contrast between social classes as Sly is actually poor but the Lord is saying that Sly is the Lord and has many wealthy possessions such as “Thy horses” who’s “harness studded all with gold and pearl.” Elizabethan and modern audiences would find this comical as we know that sly isn’t actually the Lord but actually a poor drunkard. Another example of the comedic impact of social class would be when Lucentio and Tranio swap identities so that Lucentio can get closer to Bianca. This shows a strong divide between master and servant as Tranio is now acting as if he’s rich when in reality he’s just Lucentio’s servant, this is absurd and complex which is why both Elizabethan and modern audiences would find this humorous. Tranio is “content to be Lucentio” as he now gets to take charge and have “A sulken doublet, a velvet hose, a scarlet cloak and a capatain hat” even when they aren’t actually his to keep, each of these possessions have connotations of wealth and luxury which is a contrast to his true identity. Tranio as Lucentio demonstrates a lower class character acting as an upper class character which would be unthinkable in Elizabethan times. Another character acting as upper class when he’s lower class is the merchant who Lucentio wants to act as his father, Vincentio.
As well as disguise and social class, gender roles are used to create humour throughout the play mainly using Katherina, but the audiences first see reversed gender roles in the induction with Sly and Bartholomew. Sly doesn’t know that Bartholomew is actually a page boy as he is dressed as Sly’s wife and because of how good Bartholomew is in disguise Sly falls for his act and this brings about Sly’s sexual inclination to Bartholomew. However, Bartholomew doesn’t break character as he “let me entreat of you” but “To pardon me yet for a night or two” so he doesn’t get caught as not actually being female. Gender roles is also
The representation of women in Shakespeares “Taming of the Shrew”. The women in the taming of the shrew are representative of male dominant society and the pursuit of determination of a male and his quest to win the heart of the shrew. The female shrew Katherine is tempestuous in different, independent, opinionated and not easily interested in any male liaison which becomes a challenge for a particular type of male to tame her. As opposed to her sister Bianca, who is portrayed as a more of a daddy’s…
The Taming of the Shrew Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew includes different kinds of characters. The play’s main characters are: Katherine Minola, Petruchio, Bianca Minola, Baptista Minola, Hortensio, Lucentio, Tranio, and Gremio. Katherine is regarded as a “shrew” a badtempered, assertive woman. Although her father, Baptista, is very wealthy and will provide a large dowry, Katherine has no suitors. However, her younger sister, Bianca, has many suitors because of her more modest, meek character – traits that were the ideal for…
wicked wench. Before stirring chaos over the controversial title, think about how different the women are today as compared to 400 years ago. Just take the movie, 10 Things I Hate About you, which is closely modeled after the Shakespeare play Taming of the Shrew, for example. The only difference is that the newer version has way more sex involved in the story. Thus, Shakespeare’s stereotypes are basically the same, besides the fact that our generation of ladies has become somewhat uncontrollably promiscuous…
How to identify a shrew Taming of the Shrew is a satire book that shows that a shrew is not what just a label that can a placed on anyone because they are uncooperative. shrew is a term that most people don’t know the meaning of, so there for you can get confused on who is the shrew in the book. In Taming of the Shrew the people of the town label Katharine as a shrew not only because she is loud and out spoken and does not want to do as she is told but because she is very aggressive in her actions…
Comparing and Contrasting Shakespeare In my fourth period class, we had to read a play called The Taming of the Shrew written by the famous William Shakespeare. The play was very long, and had a ton of interesting parts to it. Also, in fourth period we watched a movie called 10 Things I Hate About You which was based off of The Taming of the Shrew play. Between the two stories there were many similarities as well as differences. For example, both plays had the same characters, but in the movie…
A ‘Journey’ is an imaginative, spiritual, or chosen life plan that someone will experience or wish to experience during their life. ‘Journeys’ create a person’s life lessons as they progress and age. These ‘Journeys’ contain the obstacles a person may overcome to achieve who they are destined to be. ‘Siddhartha’ is a text which takes us through the journey of enlightenment and knowledge, which is reached by Siddhartha learning from his own personal journeys and seeking opportunities to fulfil his…
Year 10 English In the Shakespearian play: The Taming of the Shrew, deception is one of the major concepts. A tangled web is created in the play through deception of character behavior and the change between clothing and class. Most of the deception in the play have particular motives behind them and create dramatic irony. Shakespeare has used dramatic irony to create a comedic play. Character deception in The Taming of the Shrew is used largely, and Lucentio one of the main characters…
The Taming of the Shrew Lecture Notes I. Introduction a. The Taming of the Shrew is one of Shakespeare’s earliest plays—written around the late 1580s or early 1590s b. Shrew is known for having amusingly combative protagonists engaged in a never-ending battle of wits. II. Type of Play a. Shrew is a comedy that satirizes courtship and __marriage, often through force. b. farce —a type of comedy that uses unlikely and exaggerated situations…
2. The silliest part in this act to me is when Petruchio and his servant are going back and forth arguing about the dress. It is made clear in the scene that Petruchio did indeed order the dress to the requirements in which it was made to. If the dress was made how he wanted, then why is he arguing and yelling at the servant? Petruchio does this to show his assertiveness, and dominance. They exchange lines such as “well I don’t like the sleeves” and “in grief the gown is not for me.” They are arguing…
Sara Rudokas Mr. Treherne English 101 17 November 2010 Disguises Are Your Demise In The Taming of a Shrew by William Shakespeare, there are many characters that disguise themselves to be someone they are not. These characters take advantage of the people around them by making them think that they are someone other than themselves. These disguises cause difficult conflicts throughout the play. There are many disguises in this play that do not turn out how they are expected to. Lucentio is one…