Opposing Views on Medicinal Marijuana
The legality of medical marijuana possession is as hot a topic as exists in the discussion of possible drug decriminalization in the United States. Some agencies, both federal government and non-governmental advisors, urge continued vigorous prosecution of marijuana offenders because they see medical marijuana as both a gateway to hard drugs like heroin and cocaine and as a smokescreen for an effort to decriminalize marijuana for general use (Marshall, 2005). In contrast, various medical authorities and some state-level Attorney Generals have acknowledged that the use of medical marijuana is beneficial in treating chronic pain patients, cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy, and other similar medical situations where ordinary prescribed pharmaceuticals are not working effectively for some patients (Koch, 1999). Both doctors and patients have pushed for clinical trials to determine the extent of beneficial effects for such patients from marijuana use. Second, one of the key issues in the debate has to do with the Controlled Substances Act of 1970 (CSA) and its apparent conflict with various state laws – most notably in early cases in California. This seems to be an issue of federal laws and rights versus states’ laws and rights (2005). Third, while America is currently in a 16 trillion dollar deficit, the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) is spending billions of dollars annually in an attempt to arrest, prosecute, and incarcerate marijuana offenders defined by the CSA. In contrast to the DEA’s enforcement costs, as many as seventeen states are now gaining revenue from taxes imposed on the licensed and supervised sale of medicinal marijuana (ProCon.org, 2012).
Prior to 1970, only the 1937 Federal Marijuana Tax Act, which imposed a high tax on the growth and use of marijuana, placed any limits on marijuana (Marshall, 2005, p. 135). However, in 1970, Congress passed the CSA which immediately prohibited the possession of Marijuana. The CSA affected both the use of and medical research upon marijuana by categorizing: drugs into five “schedules” based on their medicinal value, potential danger and potential for abuse or addiction. Marijuana is listed in Schedule 1, which is reserved for drugs that have no recognized medical use and are considered highly dangerous and addictive, including heroin. As a Schedule 1 drug, marijuana cannot be legally possessed, prescribed or distributed under federal law (2005).
In 1972, President Nixon “declared war on drugs, and said this war would result in a drug-free world” (Famdale, 2012, p. 14). Supporters of the CSA often point to “public safety” as a main reason for their support for the criminalization of marijuana. In terms similar to those used to describe second hand smoke from tobacco use, the Mayo Clinic stated that “Burning marijuana smoke contains higher amounts of some cancer-causing chemicals than does tobacco smoke. Smoking marijuana increases the risk of cancer of the mouth, larynx and lungs” (Marshall, 2005, p. 141). Calvina Ray, Drug Free America Foundation executive director, says the marijuana is an addictive and “dangerous drug. It’s a harmful drug. It’s currently classified as being illegal. We don’t see anything good that can come from legalizing it” (2005). In addition, there are those that say the push for legalized medicinal marijuana is a smoke screen for the legalization of marijuana for all users. The DEA states, “The campaign to allow marijuana to be used as medicine is a tactical maneuver in an overall strategy to completely legalize all drugs” (2005).
In 1998, federal agencies closed six marijuana dispensaries in Oakland, California, and both the California Medical Association and the California Nurses Association submitted a “friend of the court” brief to the “United States v. Oakland Cannabis Buyers’ Collaborative.” The brief by the medical and nurses’ associations stated:
Neither federal prosecutors
Related Documents: Medical Marijuana Research Paper
AP Government Review Cases • McConnell v. Federal Election Commission o Court said that ads that only mentioned but did not “expressly advocate” a candidate were ways of influencing the election o Upholds 2002 campaign finance reform law • Schenck v. United States (1919) o Speech may be punished if it creates a clear-and-present-danger test of illegal acts o Anti-draft pamflats were handed out o “clear and present danger” • Chaplinksy v. New Hampshire (1942) o “Fighting words” are not protected…
John Stumpf Mrs. Schmidt English 10 Pre-AP, Period 5 1 May 2013 The Problem with Marijuana There are many issue facing America and all of Earth today. One of the biggest is on if marijuana should be legal or not. The answer should be that it should stay illegal, but many people today would not agree. This issue is big as marijuana is one of the most used drugs today and probably will stay that way for a while. This first recorded use of cannabis started in 2300 B.C. when a plant was discovered…
Alexys Allen August 1, 2014 Part Three: Court Cases 1. Marbury v. Madison(1803): Designated as a justice of the peace in the District of Columbia the last minute appointment were never fully finalized Precedent: when the constitution conflicts with an act of the legislature that act is invalidated established the supreme courts power of judicial law 2. McCulloch v. Maryland(1819): The state of Maryland passed legislation to impose lanes on the bank, McCulloch the cashier, of Baltimore…
branches are the Legislative Branch, made up of the two houses of Congress, the House of Representatives and the Senate. The second branch is the Executive Branch which consists of the President and Vice-President. The third branch, headed by the Supreme Court, is the Judicial Branch. The framers also wanted to make sure that the federal government’s three branches were all equal in power and had ways to ensure that balance stays in play so they implemented a system of checks and balances. The first…
prison rates in California are higher than in any other state in the United States. “California has, by the largest general population of any state in the nation, with more than 36 million people. Therefore, it cannot be a surprise-or unexpected-that we also have the largest prison population, with 172,000 inmates” (Reynolds). California has always been considered to be a state that stood on its own accord. Once considered the most powerful state in the nation, California now suffers one economic crisis…
Neither Congress nor any state may pass a law in conflict with the Constitution. The Constitution is the supreme law in this country. The Constitution is the source of federal power and to sustain the legality of a federal law or action a specific federal power must be found in the Constitution. States have inherent sovereign power—that is, the power to enact legislation that has a reasonable relationship to the welfare of the citizens of that state. The states delegated the power of the federal…
have closely approximated monarchies Democracy: Rule by many Democracy: literally means “rule by” “many” Political authority is vested in the people Also known as “popular sovereignty” History Earliest democracies were found in Greek cities states Democracy as a form of government did not become widespread until the mid 1840’s Most popular form of government today! Types of Democracies Direct (Participatory) Democracy: citizens participate in gov. as individuals Have direct control over…
The behavior of homo sapiens -- human beings tend to pursue their own interests. They behave in ways that promote individual interests, and are motivated by incentives (both positive and negative). This is one of the reasons proposed for the development of governments: groups of individuals all acting in their own interests leads to collective action problems, and governments exist as a solution to those problems. Collective action problem -- this occurs when a group of individuals, each acting…
also called marijuana, reefer, ganja, weed, pot, hash, hashish or benj. In fact, the American name marijuana is a mostly American word with racist tendencies in the history. The racist connotation of the term comes from when cannabis was first being introduced to the American Southwest. Marijuana is the Mexican word for cannabis so when cannabis was becoming illegal the American government used the term and create a negative persona of the word and the Mexican’s that use it. “Marijuana” is an prejudice…
9.00 As the United States grappled with the challenges and changes of the modern era; it began to experience a renewed interest in conservatism and other ideological and cultural issues. America sought to reassert itself globally, both politically and economically, leading the way in the globalization of the world. Along with the vast, awe-inspiring changes in science and technology, the U.S. would also be inspired by the growth of Christian fundamentalism and a reduced faith in the government’s…