We walk around the world with a bewildering network of opinions, beliefs and judgments, some of them ephemeral (I think that I won’t need an umbrella today) and some vital (I trust that person).
Why is the sky blue? Why do you believe you are mortal? Why is four twice two? How do you know that George Washington actually existed?
If we have an opinion about such a question, then when we are challenged, we offer what we think counts for evidence. We hope, of course, that our evidence persuades our challenger (i.e., we hope that our rhetoric is up to the task), but, more importantly, we hope that our evidence really justifies our opinion.
It is striking, though, how different branches of knowledge — the humanities, the sciences, mathematics — justify their findings so very differently; they have, one might say, quite incommensurate rules of evidence. Often a shift of emphasis, or framing, of one of these disciplines goes along with, or derives from, a change of these rules, or of the repertoire of sources of evidence, for justifying claims and findings in that field. Law has, of course, its own precise rules explicitly formulated.
1 As is perfectly reasonable, Darwin reserves the word “fact” for those pieces of data or opinion that have been, in some sense, vetted, and are not currently in dispute. The word “evidence” in “On the Origin of Species” can refer to something more preliminary that is yet to be tested and deemed admissible or not. Sometimes, if evidence is firmer than that, Darwin will supply it with an adjective such as “clear” or “plainest”; it may come as a negative, such as “there isn’t a shadow of evidence.”
Even the way the word “evidence” is used can already tell us much about the profile of an intellectual discipline. To take a simple example, consider Charles Darwin’s language in “On the Origin of Species”— specifically, his use of the words “fact” and “evidence” — as offering us clues about the types of argumentation that Darwin counts in support, or in critique, of his emerging theory of evolution.1 Sometimes Darwin provides us with a sotto voce commentary on what shouldn’t count — or should only marginally count — as evidence, such as when he writes, “But we have better evidence on this subject than mere theoretical calculations.”
Darwin spends much time offering his assessment of what one can expect — or not expect — to glean from the fossil record. He gives quick characterizations of types of evidence — “historical evidence” he calls “indirect” (as, indeed, it is in comparison with the evidence one gets by having an actual bone in one’s actual hands). These types of judgments frame the project of evolution.
The subsequent changes in Darwin’s initial repertoire, such as evidence obtained by formulating various mathematical models, or the formidable technology of gene sequencing, and so on, mark changes in the types of argument evolutionary biologists regard as constituting a genuine result in the field — in effect, changes in what they regard evolutionary biology to be.
If we accept that the shape and mood of a field of inquiry is largely, or even just somewhat, determined by the specific kinds of evidence needed to have consensually agreed-upon findings or results in that field, it becomes important to study the perhaps peculiar nature of evidence in different domains to appreciate how these distinct domains fit into the greater constellation of intellectual effort.
Mathematics — a realm in which one might think the issue of evidence to be fairly straightforward (you prove a theorem or you don’t) — will, as we shall see, turn out to be not at all clear, and it has its own history of the shaping of types of evidence.
In the fall semester of 2012 I had the pleasure of co-running a seminar course, “The Nature of Evidence,” in the Harvard Law School with Professor Noah Feldman. It was structured as an extended conversation between different practitioners and our students. A number
Running Head: Smoking between Science and Non-Science Majors A Comparative Study on Smoking between Science and Non-Science Majors Student’s name North Lake College Abstract There has been a great talk about what do you fear the most. This study evaluates which one out of the two things that you fear most. Those people fearful of spiders reported having a family member with similar fears, but the study was unable to separate genetic factors from environmental ones. According…
Mr. Feazell said he is concerned that Dell's focus on the buyout will distract the computer maker and that Mr. Icahn's involvement adds more uncertainty to an already risky situation for customers. Some Dell customers said they aren't fazed by the silence, however, because they have plans to ensure they aren't too reliant on Dell products. "I'm not too worried," said Daniel Petlon, chief information officer of Enterasys Networks Inc., a Salem, N.H., part of a joint venture between Siemens AG…
21, 2014 Is the Study of Paranormal Phenomena a Legitimate Science? “The new improved version of “science” now encompassed all the activities which collectively serve aim of the natural word and how it works.” (Hill, 1) This means that science is the study of the natural world and how it works. “Paranormal researchers” who use cool gadgets and use extremely scientific terms, think that they are conducting scientific experiments when researching the paranormal. However, the study of paranormal phenomena…
Mr. Blake Ocean science 12/11/14 1. This article is in the science field of biology because it talks about the human body and how diseases can be cured. 2. A non-surgical injection of programmable biomaterial that assembles into a 3-D structure could fight and prevent cancer and infectious disease like HIV. Biodegradable structures made from silica, can be loaded with biological and chemical drug components and then delivered by needle. 3. Two of the most interesting things are “cancer is so deadly…
LGC Health Sciences – Change Management Case Study Description: Acquistion of HFL from Quotient Bioresearch by LGC On the 23rd December 2010 Quotient Bioresearch sold half its business (HFL) to LGC. Although it was a core business at the group’s formation in 2007, over time the HFL business had become a relatively small part of Quotient’s total business portfolio. Although within Quotient there remained considerable appreciation and awareness of what the Medication and Doping Control and the…
Ancient Foundations of Science Ionia (Rise of Cities) Scientific Enterprise (600 BC) Same as rise of Greek cities (polis) OR Maritime Technology Need for boats was the beginning of the scientific revolution Greek sailors sailed around Africa Democracy in Greece Placed priority on logic Free exchange of ideas (basis of science) Ionian = Pre-Socratic Philosophers Natural explanations of material things 2 questions: what is the universe made of? What causes things to change…
Science Study Notes Heat and Temperature Unit C Grade 7 Part A) 1. Theories of heat Caloric theory of heat- Heat energy was a substance (like a liquid or an invisible fluid) which flowed from a hot object to a colder one. But there is one weakness for this theory; why doesn’t the mass of the objects change if the ‘substances’ are flowing in and out of the objects. If the caloric theory of heat was real, the mass of the objects would change. Heat as energy theory-…
Science Exam Study Guide Meiosis Purpose: to transmit genetic material from an organism to its offspring to create genetic variation within a population produces sex and germ cells (gametes and spores) divides the amount of genetic material by half, with one haploid set of chromosomes per cell a zygote contains two haploid sets of chromosomes (1 from each parent) Process: Interphase I: Chromatin is inside nucleus and chromosomes are duplicating Prophase I: Nucleus dissolves and…
Motion Unit: -Displacement includes distance and direction Displacement is the measure of how far an object has moved. The direction and length of a straight line from the starting point to the ending point of an object's motion is displacement. -Motion occurs when there is a change in position -Formula to calculate speed, distance or time is (s=d/t) -The velocity of an object must have both a speed and direction Velocity is the speed and direction in which an object moves. If you…
Science Exam Study Guide I. Properties of waves and sound. a. Know and be able to describe the following: Wave: A disturbance that transfers energy from place to place Transverse wave: A wave that moves the medium in a direction perpendicular to the direction in which the wave travels. λ (wavelength): The distance between two corresponding parts of a wave. Compressional/longitudinal wave: A wave that moves a medium in a direction parallel to the direction in which the…