Celeste Montelongo
Professor White
Research Methodology
17 January 2013
Comparative Analysis Popular topics in our world and culture consist of alcohol and drug usage, as well as, the abusive side of these influences. Therefore, many articles can be found about these intriguing topics; however, not all of the articles are proficient or commendable. Drew K. Saylor created a better argument with her article, “Heavy Drinking on College Campuses: No Reason to Change Minimum Legal Drinking Age of 21”, than Richard M. Eckersley did in his article, “’Cultural Fraud’: the role of culture in drug abuse” because Saylor was dedicated to her argument and supplied adequate examples while Eckersley appeared to not stay on topic. By reading the title, “Heavy Drinking on College Campuses: No Reason to Change Minimum Legal Drinking Age of 21”, by Drew K. Saylor, you would know exactly what the article is about. Saylor does not stray from her viewpoint that the MLDA 21 should not be lowered. Instead, she believes that, “…we should seek to add to and improve this effort with increased enforcement, additional legislation, and efficacious interventions” (Saylor 332). Not only has there been a plentiful amount of research that supports the MLDA 21, such as, it “…has had more subtle but equally important effect on alcohol-related traffic injuries and fatalities by increasing the separation between drinking and driving among the under 21 population”, but Saylor also reinforces her argument with the account of the negative effects that occurred in New Zealand when they lowered their legal drinking age. In regards to other forms of ending alcohol abuse on college campuses, such as, “…brief motivational interventions”, the MLDA 21 effectiveness is far superior (Saylor 331).
In addition, Research Coordinator of Behavioral Health and Technology, Drew K. Saylor’s literature review, “Heavy Drinking on College Campuses: No Reason to Change Minimum Legal Drinking Age of 21” asserts that lowering the MLDA 21 would be greatly ineffective. She supports this claim by stating that there is not any evidence that supports lowering the legal drinking age, and if the age limit was lowered, then other laws in association would be negatively affected; therefore, causing chaos and confusion. Saylor’s purpose is to persuade readers to believe that we must remain committed to enforcing the laws that have already been established. She adopts a strong argumentative tone for her audience, the readers of Journal of American College Health and others interested in the topic of heavy drinking on college campuses and reasons to not lower the legal drinking age.
In contrast to how vigorous Saylor is in her argument, author Richard M. Eckersley can be considered impotent with his argument in his article, “’Cultural Fraud’: the role of culture in drug abuse”. Eckersley means well by illustrating the many aspects of culture, and by defining it as, “…-associated with minority status, ethnicity or race;”, and “the underlying [assumption] of an entire way of life, [that allows] us to make sense of the world and our lives” (157). His argument is that “aspects of modern western culture are a potent and under-estimated social factor behind drug use and abuse”; yet, he fails to truly commit to describing and supporting the connection between culture and drug abuse (Eckersley 157). Instead, he mentions and emphasizes the connection between culture and the general heath of people. For example, in contrast to his title, Eckersley explains that, “The paper is, then, concerned less with the need for specific policy or programme interventions to reduce harmful drug use than it is with the case for a deep cultural change to promote better population health and well-being” (157).
Lastly, in the article, “Cultural Fraud: the role of culture in drug abuse”, the author Richard M. Eckersley, BSC (Hon), asserts that aspects of
SAT VOCABULARY LIST 1 EXTENDED DEFINITION ASSIGNMENT 1. ALIENATE a. to make indifferent or hostile b. verb (-ate) c. alienating (verb), alienated (verb), alienator (n), realienate (verb), alienates (verb) d. break off, come between, disaffect, divorce, set against e. be friendly, join in, disarm f. The child (alienated) himself and thus had trouble making friends. Source: www.dictionary.com 2. ELATED a. very happy or proud; jubilant; in high…
SAT Vocabulary word SMART abash – v. to make ashamed; to embarrass abase – v. to belittle; to diminish abdicate – v. to step down from a position of power or responsibility abject – adj. hopeless; extremely sad and servile; defeated; without hope abnegate – v. to deny oneself things; to reject; to renounce; giving up oneself abortive – adj. unsuccessful abscond – v. to escape without permission abrasive – adj. rubbing away; tending to grind down abridge – v. to shorten; to condense absolute…
Ominous - Definition: indicating the nature of a future event, for good or evil; having the significance of an omen; being a portent Sentence from book: “'There is something ominous behind the silence.'” Chapter 15 Synonym: menacing Original sentence: The dark storm clouds created a rather ominous environment for Katie. Pacifistic - Definition: of or pertaining to pacifism or pacifists Sentence from book: Synonym: peaceable Original sentence: Interestingly, the author does not…
The College Board Official Study Guide 2012 Test #8 Vocabulary (Jackie PREP ) Phlegmatic – (adjective) self-possessed, calm, or composed Nick was phlegmatic when his internet broke down when he got home. But why would he be? Apathetic – (adjective) having or showing little or no emotion; not interested or concerned One should be apathetic when they get a low SAT score because they know they will do better next time! Conciliate– (verb) to overcome the distrust or hostility of; placate;…
Courtney Woodall February 04, 2015 Period 2: AP English Mrs. Detamore Martin Luther King Jr. sat at a well used desk that could fall apart at any moment from being so worn and beaten in a jail cell in Birmingham, Alabama that smelled like disinfectant mixed with urine and sweat. Despite the horrible smell and the chaotic noise going on around him he sat at that beaten desk and wrote one of the most extraordinary and intellectual letters to the clergymen who challenged his beliefs. In Martin Luther King Jr…
for each word. Then fill in the next column (Guess the Meaning) with your own definitions for the words based on context clues. Use the Merriam-Webster site to find the actual definitions and write those in the last column (Actual Definition). Vocabulary Context Clues Guess the Meaning Actual Definition Edifice Familiar words located around the word (the door of which was heavily timbered wooden, tall gray houses, connected to) A building a large and usually impressive building (such…
are generally used in the field of education to assess the academic performance of students. Two commonly known types of standardized tests in the United States are the SAT and the ACT. The SAT is the most widely used and most heavily researched college admissions test in the country (Caperton).The SAT evaluates skills in vocabulary and mathematics, while the ACT has more to do with a broader range of knowledge and includes additional subjects, such as science. Research and experience show that standardized…
language. Maybe the most important component of the communication is words. As it is said, vocabulary is not merely king, it’s god emperor of the universe. There is also a saying; it doesn’t matter what you say but it does matter how you say it. To verbalize our thoughts in the most effective way, we need a large size of vocabulary. So, we can easily understand how important to have a good size of vocabulary to be able to communicate and to have a better understanding of others. Beside providing a…
One of the longest debates in recent times has been whether or not the SAT is a proper mechanism for Universities to use, when deciding which students to admit. The issue of whether the SAT is biased to a certain type of group has also arisen. These issues being that upper middle class Caucasian students are at an advantage while lower SES minority students are at a disadvantage for various reasons. I believe that the SAT does not at all provide an accurate representation of what a high school…
anxiety. Indicate two times when you employed stress-reducing strategies during the Module. Be sure to provide details. |Module 3 |Mon. |Tues. |Wed. |Thurs. |Fri. |Sat. |Sun. | |Due Dates for Upcoming | | | | | |Module 3 or be | | |items this Module (be | | | |…