ALLEGIANCE AND AMBIVALENCE
Some Dilemmas in Researching
Disorder and Violence
AL I S O N LI EB L I NG and BETSY STAN KO *
This issue arises from our deep commitment to criminological research and the need for honest accounts of its complexity and emotional intricacy. We wished to share, with neophyte researchers but also with others, some of the dilemmas we have faced and what these dilemmas signify. We aimed to encourage those who have embarked on difficult and sensitive research topics to reflect upon, and find meaning in, their own dilemmas.
As scholars, new and experienced, we write about actions that cause the suffering of many individuals—law breakers, law enforcers and victims. Yet by and large, we criminologists are professionals whose task is to observe and analyse account after account of the kinds of havoc individuals, groups or the state mete out. We are expected to do so in objective and reasonable prose, often discarding the turmoil encountered as irrelevant and standing in the way of the data. We rarely consider that such turmoil constitute data
(Liebling 1999; and see Pickering, this issue). We face moral turmoil, as we witness or become part of, scenes of violence, struggle or maltreatment. Why is there so little dialogue on these matters? Haines and Sutton (2000) writing in this journal have likened criminology to a ‘secular religion’ that should be characterized as a paradigm with a moral discourse. The authors assert that ‘all work—our own included—has a religious or moral dimension’ (Haines and Sutton 2000: 147). With this we agree. But both of us have come to understand that no matter what our individual reputations in criminology as a discipline1 we cannot avoid squalid politics and ethical predicaments when researching crime and violence.
Some criminologists may wonder why others are affected by the unhappy subjects we choose to study. In a presentation a few years ago, a leading criminologist mused that he could have been a professional bird watcher rather than a student of crime. At the time,
Stanko envied this criminologist’s honesty when he admitted that the substance of criminology seemed to him uncontroversial and apolitical. Of course, bird watchers must get worked up about the deterioration of the environment that affect the life and happiness of feathered creatures. There are probably more people with membership of animal and bird welfare organizations in the UK than criminologists in the world. But somehow bird watchers can be uncontroversial voyeurs of birds because it is pleasurable.
Although some criminologists have been accused of being voyeurs of others’ suffering, the controversy about politics and the emotional toll of criminal harm never seem far
* Respectively, Senior Research Associate, Cambridge Institute of Criminology, UK; Professor of Criminology, Royal Holloway,
University of London.
1
Stanko is known as a feminist advocate; Liebling is known as a relatively tame critic of the prison, albeit one whose choices of research topic might belie this image.
behind. What is wrong with us that we have had sleepless nights from doing the kind of work we do?
This issue had its inception in a seminar for researchers of violence sponsored by the
ESRC Violence Research Programme in April 1999. Throughout this seminar, we assumed that the kinds of experiences we have had as researchers—sleepless nights, encounters with danger, problems with articulating what violence means to different people in different contexts—were common to all. Many of the funded projects on the
ESRC’s programme raised methodological issues few researchers have addressed or resolved in print. How does a researcher safely and accurately collect information about violence and prostitution while conducting interviews with working women in the
Title: Is There a Link Between Domestic Violence and School Exclusion? Table of Contents Page No. Initials Introduction 2 MB Background 2 MB Theoretical perspective 3 MB Literature Review 3-4 MB Methodology 4 MB Ethical Issues SM Data Collected 5 SM Analysis of Data 6 SM Research Findings 6-7 SM Conclusion 8 SM References 9-10 SM References 11-13 MB…
The level of presence is likely to influence the effect of media violence. This project examines the causes and consequences of presence in the context of violent video game play. In a between subjects design, 227 participants were randomly assigned to play either a violent or a nonviolent video game. The results are consistent with what would be predicted by social learning theory and are consistent with previous presence research. Causal modeling analyses reveal two separate paths to presence:…
Violence on Television Mande Breen Com156 June 3, 2012 Violence on Television Studies indicate that many children today spend more time in front of a television set than they do almost anywhere else, with school being one of the only exceptions. It is important to know what children are watching and what possible effects this can have on their attitudes and behaviors. Television has the ability to influence many aspects of a child’s life, with attitudes and behaviors possibly being the…
I will discuss the former in greater detail now. It is widely known that the gang problem is complex. Children in gang-impacted areas often suffer from single-parent houses, poverty, and PTSD. Their reasons for joining gangs vary from coping with violence, to protection from other gangs, and even for finding a place to belong. Jorja Leap records Bo Taylor, a gang interventionist, as saying that children in gang-impacted neighborhoods only see jail or death as reasonable options; “they need family”…
regard to violence men are predominately seen as the problem so they should also be seen as part of the solution (Flood, 2001; Berkowitz, 2004). Not to say that woman cannot be violent but figures for Australia and worldwide indicate there is a 90% chance that if an incident of violence is recorded the fact is it will predominantly be a male who is the perpetrator (Flood, 2011; Hautzinger, 2003). Discovering why men are more prone to violence has seen decades of discourse and research surrounding…
viewpoints as to why there has been an increase in woman criminality. In a more recent article, Constituting the Violence of Criminalized Women, author’s Elizabeth Comack and Salena Brickey discuss research they conducted in order to diminish the female violence stereotypes of “victim,” “mad,” or “bad.” The author’s conducted their research by interviewing female violent offenders. This research gave women charged with violent crimes the ability to represent themselves apart from the typical stereotypes…
Running head: LEGESLATIVE PAPER Gun Violence: Effects on Healthcare Ashley W. Crowley University of South Alabama 1 Running head: LEGESLATIVE PAPER 2 February 2, 2012 The Honorable Senator Bill Nelson 716 Senate Hart Office Building Washington, DC 20510 Dear Senator Nelson, I am currently enrolled in a family nurse practitioner program and attempting to raise awareness of the importance of gun control legislation in relation to healthcare. Your voting record on gun control…
bullying experiences, fear of school violence, and social support were investigated in 24 students with disabilities (SWD) in self-contained special education classes and 24 peers with no known disabilities (Peers) who participated in a pilot recreation-focused inclusion program, Peer EXPRESS. Middle and high school students were invited 10 and 34 weeks after the beginning of school to complete the Reynolds’s Bully Victimization Scale (BVS) and School Violence Anxiety Scale (SVAS) and Harter’s Social…
Compare and contrast the approaches of Cohen and Hall et al. to the role of media in relation to social disorder In this essay I will look at the theories of Stanley Cohen a social scientist, born in South Africa in 1942 and Stuart Hall a cultural theorist and sociologist, born 1932 in Jamaica. I will be analysing and comparing their theories and separating the differences in the views of Cohen and Hall et al. and noting the similarities in their ideas. Their theories are in regards to the effect…
the chance to present intimate partner violence to you I will be brief here. I want to talk about intimate partner violence. We will look at why people stay involved with this type of relationship. Group Rules: 1. Try to be courteous to one another and their opinions. 2. Take turns as adults do with grace. 3. Participation is appreciated by whoever wishes to or has time to 4. Let’s learn together. Intimate partner violence Group Questions 1. If you have…