i) Analyse the essential ideas in the argument for the existence of God based on religious experience.
A religious experience is a non-empirical encounter with the divine, which often makes the individual feel as though there is something beyond our physical being. They have thus long been the foundation for religious belief as they offer personal evidence for the existence of God. Religious experiences present a tremendous challenge to philosophers who may in turn attempt to offer an alternate explanation.
As there are a great variety of religious experiences and each has a unique quality, it is vital that these be all considered when arguing for the existence of God. The first essential idea can be found in the work of William James, who sought to characterise mystical experience. A mystical experience is one in which a person experiences the ultimate reality; James lists the four different characteristics of this. Passivity; a feeling of being taken over by a superior authority, ineffability; a state of feeling that defies description, noetic quality; revelations of universal and eternal truths and transiency; a brief but profoundly important experience. James concludes that these feelings verify that, to the individual, something has occurred, however, he argues that this religious experience is not philosophical proof of God’s existence. However, the psychological impact on the individual is indisputable, as a religious experience may have a life altering effect as seen with St. Paul’s conversion on the road to Damascus (Act 9). Thus the essential idea that has been highlighted is that psychological state is key to religious experience.
A further essential idea in the argument citing religious experience as proof of God’s existence arises from induction. An inductive argument claiming the existence of God is as follows; Premise one states “experience of X indicates the reality of X’”, premise two follows “experience of God indicates the reality of God”, premise three claims “it is possible to experience God”, and thus it concludes “God exists”. This suggests that God’s existence is logical, empirical and synthetically verifiable. An essential idea here is that religious believers use logicality and rationality to argue for the existence of God based on religious experience. Furthermore, this inductive argument allows religious believers to look at the subjective testimonies of others and draw the conclusion that their experience can only be attributed God. Richard Swinburne is amongst those who argue inductively, although is not a universally favoured approach, for example, Kant rejected the possibility of such experiences as he argued we do not have to senses to experience God due to his belonging in the noumenal
Realm.
A further essential idea in the argument for the existence of God based on religious experience arises from the work of Richard Swinburne who emphasises that we must show a willingness to believe individuals who claim to have had a religious experience. Swinburne demonstrates this through the use of his principles of credulity and testimony. The principle of credulity highlights the notion that you should believe an individual if they are claiming a religious experience as Swinburne argues the way things seem to us, or another, is a good guide to what they actually are. He the principle thus “If it seems to a subject that X is present then probably X is present.” This flies in the face of scepticism, as it allows no room for doubt. Furthermore, Swinburne claims we should generally believe what people say, thus the principle of testimony, much like credulity, assumes people usually tell the truth. Swinburne ultimately aims to reason that we have no good grounds to doubt the accuracy of religious experiences in light of these principles unless the prior probability of God based on other factors is very low. Thus the essential idea here is a willingness to believe. However, Dr Peter Vardy used the
AS Religious Studies Exam Preparation for UNIT 1 Picking topics for paper 1 – a suggested approach Philosophy of Religion Ethics Row 1 The Design Argument The Cosmological Argument Religion and Morality Utilitarianism Situation Ethics Row 2 The problem of evil Miracles Sexual ethics War and peace 1. On the unit 1 exam, you will answer 3 essay questions. Either 2 philosophy and 1 ethics, or 2 ethics and 1 philosophy (you choose) in 1 hour and 45 minutes. Each 2 part question takes 35 minutes to…
Aesthetical, Ethical, and Religious Lifestyle Søren Kierkegaard indirectly authors three different essays detailing the aspects of the aesthetic, ethical, and religious lifestyles of humans using multiple pseudonyms. The purpose of using false names was primarily for the reason to separate his life from the lives he was writing about; however, it is quite clear that he is using his own life experiences to depict the advantages and shortcomings of each lifestyle. In the first essay, Kierkegaard depicts…
speaker explains the tradition and describes the feelings and personal problems associated with fasting for the religious holiday. In the essay A Hunger Artist by Franz Kafka, we learn about a man whose job is to starve himself for multiple days as a performance. We as readers, see his perspective on starvation as a profession and why it is a dying entertainment. The poem and the short essay both have similar themes of starvation, hunger, desire, and internal conflict. However, they differ in style…
amazing essays. It took me a few times to read a few of them to truly understand them. Once you understand what the writer is trying to tell you, it is truly an amazing essay. They all are. To read a piece written by a famous person so well known, someone I have heard one once or twice, or maybe never heard of at all, and to see and understand a part of them is great. These essays have so much put into them that no one would ever realize unless you sit there and think. I read each and every essay in the…
with super natural; science deals with natural”. In this assignment I will first evaluate Mr. S. J. Gould's essay “there is no conflict between religion and science” and then I will also evaluate R. Dawkins “Religion and Science Cannot Be Reconciled” and lastly I will state my personal opinion regarding this matter and why I believe religion and science can coexist together. In his essay “there is no conflict between religion and science” Stephen Jay Gould argues that both religion and science…
Discuss the ways in which religious language can be understood There are many different views on how people speak of God. Some agnostic thinkers believe that God is something we can neither no or speak of and any attempt to do this is meaningless. Theists, however, have always tried to communicate their understanding of God through language, for example, Islam has 99 different names for Allah whose description includes ‘The Gracious’, ‘The Merciful’ etc. Jews describe God as the ‘creator’, ‘the…
How to write a Philosophy essay Skills required • • • • • Analysis Critical evaluation Reasoned argument Justification Expand (examples can EXAMPLIFY a point • *Maintain an argument Introduction • A PoR essay has a main point or THESIS (a proposition that you are seeking to establish as valid). • A thesis, in one or two sentences, sets the direction for the essay in the introduction and sums up what you are trying to establish as your eventual conclusion “Religious language is meaningless”…
forward to insist that their full humanity be acknowledged in the religious as well as the social realm. In a process begun in the nineteenth century and accelerated in the twentieth, the great religions of the world became truly global in the geographic distribution of their adherents and so…
Noah Entrekin Silas Marner Essay Assignment Mrs. Nichols Honors 10 3rd period 9/22/2014 What is the importance of Marner’s return to the lantern yard? Perhaps the complete destruction of the religious power that once stood. Perhaps it was the change in culture. Maybe it’s the dramatic change in scenery. It could also very well be the disappearance of Marner’s old comrades. Let’s start with the religious power. First off people must realize how ridiculous religion is. Religion is an omnipotent…
India that also serves religious coulters and ideas that has developed in India for more than a thousand years. The Hindu tradition recognizes that there are many ways by which people may seek and experience religious understanding. The Hindu society worships one or more gods that are called Deities. The Hinduism religion is originally from the ancient Vedic tradition and other indigenous beliefs gradually created over time. The Hindu religion is a collection of religious beliefs from cultures all…