The Debate Addiction is a complex wildly misunderstood disease of the brain. The issue of drug addiction and whether addicts should be treated criminally or medically has been a source of ongoing debate in the forms of prohibition and legalization. Critics of prohibition have declared America’s “war on drugs” a disastrous failure that has resulted in a public health crisis. Ethan A. Nadelmann, an influential prohibition critic, is founder and executive director of the Drug Policy Alliance and has written several books and countless articles on the subject of drug legalization. In Nadelmann’s, “Commonsense Drug,” he compels readers to accept societal drug eradication as unrealistic and to strip criminalization of addiction down to a human rights issue. Nadelmann argues that current drug policy is devoid of commonsense, science, and concerns of public health and calls for a focus on reducing negative consequences of both drugs and prohibitionist policies through “harm reduction.” Like Nadelmann, many prohibition and legalization critics have asserted their moral and ethical positions for or against criminalization of addiction. However, the critics on either side of the criminalization issue have failed to take into account the societal stigmatic impact prohibition laws have on the addict, and how it further implicates their drug use.
The Critics
Stigma is traditionally defined as the dehumanization of an individual based on their social identity or participation in a negative or undesirable social category (Fletcher 47). In direct contrast to Nadelmann’s view of the addict and addiction, James A. Inciardi’s and Christine A. Saum’s article “Legalization Madness” speaks out on the legalization of illicit drugs such as marijuana, cocaine, and heroin, etc. In their argument against legalization they propose a substantial increase of violence due to increased drug use in a theoretically legal society. In their attempt to dispute the “enslavement theory of addiction,” which is the concept of the addict committing crimes solely for the purpose of supporting their habit, they further contribute to the stigma of addiction. They refute that there is any solid evidence to support that addicts commit crimes because they are “enslaved” to drugs and go on to reference an analysis of studies from 1920-1960 between the connection of crime and addiction. Although they admit the study has biases and deficiencies, they continue to write “addicts were criminals first and that there drug use was but one more manifestation of their deviant lifestyles” (5). They further this claim by stating “that among the majority of drug users who are involved in crime, their criminal careers are well established prior to the onset of either narcotics or cocaine use” (5). Unfortunately assumptions made to demoralize and dehumanize the addict are the result of ignorance toward the complexity of the disease and the individuals it affects. Addiction does not discriminate against gender, race, creed, age, or social status therefore the authors further subscribe to the barbaric stigma society has placed on the disease of addiction by making generalizations. In the article “Drug Legalization, Harm Reduction, and Drug Policy” authors Robert L. DuPont and Eric A. Voth differ from Nadelmann in their view of “harm reduction” as contradictory when it comes to alcohol and tobacco. The authors refer to a paradox of tightening restrictions when attempting a reduction of harms associated with alcohol and tobacco and lessening restrictions when reducing harms associated with illicit drugs. However, it seems if a substance is already legal then there would be nothing else to do but tighten restrictions associated with undesirable outcomes of alcohol and tobacco use. The authors go on to prove this point by illustrating the hefty undesirable social costs involved with the legal drugs alcohol and tobacco.
Related Documents: Essay Prohibition and Social Stigma
Damir Harris Dr. Mokgadi 3/8/13 Sociology Reflection Paper #3 1. Deviance - is any behavior that violates social norms, and is usually of sufficient severity to warrant disapproval from the majority of society. Deviance can be criminal or non-criminal. * Today, Americans consider such activities as alcoholism, excessive gambling, being nude in public places, playing with fire, stealing, lying, refusing to bathe, purchasing the services of prostitutes, and cross-dressing—to…
Medical Sociology: Concerned with the social, cultural, historical, political and economical dimensions of health and illness. Positivist theory: By August Comp Basic tenets: Objective truth can be discovered only through scientific study.-Society operates by absolute laws or “social facts” that can be measured. Methods used: Quantitative Methods (Surveys, statistics, etc.).“Bird’s eye” view of social life. Seeks to answer “how many” or “how likely” questions. In Medical sociology: Concerned…
States. The large number in deaths through the past years has made driving under the influence a major social issue. Drunk driving has had a long history, with deaths comparable to wars, but can be prevented. This illegal activity can easily be averted by exploiting drunken driving as a danger to younger generations, by bringing more attention to the subject using ads and television and by the stigma that it carries. The first count of drunk driving occurred in 1897 when a New York taxi cab slammed…
undifferentiated treatment (“Sex Workers”, 2013). Rome was not built in a day. These revolts are the consequence of long-time oppression and marginalization. Lacking social identity and a thorough operation system, sex workers are trapped in miserable working condition and almost incapable to protect their basic rights. They are at the risk of losing social insurance, threat, blackmail, or even infecting HIV. Beyond that, the crimes that related to the sex trade are almost out of control. A part of the rates…
jectRESEARCH METHODLOGY Area: Rights of women in India Topic: A Theoretical Perspective on Dowry Deaths in India Objectives: a) To understand the concept of dowry as has originated and evolved in India. b) To conceptualize modern day consequences of dowry system. c) To refer to various laws in India and find out reasons for ineffectuality. d) To analyze the trend lay down in this regard by way of various judicial decisions. e) To critically analyze the reasons for…
should be forbidden - does not distinguish between a burden and a benefit a. Racial classification occur so often and are hard to detect - therefore it is better to pay the cost b/c racial classifications are so likely the consequence of prejudice b. Social consequences of race-based classifications create resentment and perpetuate stereotypes B. Tests 1. Rational Relation: If the classification the law uses is rationally related to a government goal - and the classification is not arbitrary- then constitutional…
shoddy health care that violated the constitutional ban on cruel and unusual punishment (Egelko, 2.) “Get tough” policies and restrictions marginalize ex-felons and repopulate the prison system. Once released from prison, ex-convicts find their stigma affecting their attempts to rejoin society. The justice system imposes a series of restrictions on their person even after they have fully served their sentences. These limitations include, but are not limited to, housing control, government assistance…
SOWK 534- Summer 2013 Assignment #2 Midterm Elizabeth Colombo 7-22-2013 Dr. Bucholtz A. Introduction: Issue, Policy, Problem: Gay Marriage in the United States has been a contentious issue for the last twenty or so years. Many people view being gay as a new phenomenon or socially constructed unit; but the origins of homosexuality extend as far back as the history of people. With the emergence of bullying as a huge barrier to adolescent development as well as teen…
Masturbation — From Stigma to Sexual Health A 15-year old girl asks, "Hi, I'm female, and I'm wondering how my sex is supposed to go about masturbating? I mean, it's easy enough for guys, but how do girls do it without seriously hurting ourselves." A 16-year-old asks, "Is it okay to masturbate?" Another 16-year-old asks, "Is it normal?" A 17-year-old young man asks, "Is it OK for males?" An 18-year-old asks, "It feels really nice, but is it bad for me?" A 15-year-old also asks, "Is it bad?"…
Tracy Ratcliffe Research Paper Legalization of Marijuana 5/12/14 The Pro's & Con's of Legalizing Marijuana: A Look at Both Sides of Reason To say that marijuana has been given a bad reputation over the past few decades is an understatement. If you’re like most Americans, you have been led to believe that marijuana is a dangerous and addictive drug that has destroyed the lives of millions of teens and adults. You have been encouraged to believe that marijuana causes lung cancer and is…