Physician-Assisted Suicide Is the government infringing on an unrecognized right? The choice to die is a highly debated issue. Several people consider assisted suicide immoral. Terminally ill patients begging doctors to end their lives is very common. They suffer unimaginable pain every day. When those patients tire from living though constant agony, death is a way to regain control. They seek out the help of a medical professional to assist with a pain free death. Many people question the law’s involvement in such personal decisions. The opposition of physician assisted suicide has created legislation which prevents patients from regaining control and ultimately forces them to suffer. People place caveats on the act of elective euthanasia, but why should those opinions matter? Although legislation protects citizens’ rights, the unrecognized ‘right to die’ is being violated.
Suicide, in the United States, is generally thought of as being wrong and religion is used as validation. In a study conducted on nurses to test the relation of their views on euthanasia and their religion, the results were as follows: “Bendiane et al.32 observed that nurses who expressed their belief in a God who masters their destiny were less likely to favour the legalization of medical acts that deliberately end a patient’s life” (Gielen, van den Branden, and Broeckaert 312). Christians are known to believe that suicide is sinful, in general. John B. Mitchell claims that suicide was accepted by early Christians to avoid “fates worse than death”. Rape, torture, and arrest qualified as adequate reasons to commit suicide. He wonders why disease inflicted agony fails to qualify for modern Christians (31). The view of suicide being sinful is not the only argument, others choose the ‘Sanity of Life’ approach. Hergameh Hosseini writes, “Sanctity of life. On the basis of both religious traditions and secular ethical principles (such as the principle of autonomy), we can oppose the taking of human life. It can be argued that assisted suicide is morally wrong because it contradicts these religious as well as secular ethical beliefs”(207).
Exponents of ‘right to die’ have compared assisted suicide to abortion and Do-Not-Resuscitate orders (Marzilli 20). The comparison suggests that the decision of elective euthanasia is along the same lines of Do-Not-Resuscitate orders and abortion, which are both legal. There are opponents to abortion but the act is legal. The organization Compassion in Dying briefed, “To hold that the decision [to commit suicide with the assistance of a physician] is less significant, or less firmly grounded in the Liberty Clause, than the decision whether to bear or beget a child, or to use contraceptives, or to send one’s child to private school, would do irreparable damage to this Court’s commitment to principled exposition of constitutional rights” (Marzilli 21). There are states where physician assisted suicide is legal. Those states place a high value on not infringing on privacy. Oregon’s approach to legalization was the argument that the state had no business in private affairs (Marzilli 23-24).
Hengameh Hosseini contemplates opposing physician assisted suicide because of potential abuse. He believes that patients, who lack the financial means or insurance, will opt to choose death to avoid the monetary burden (207). Euthanasia is legal in the Netherlands and it has been abused (Marzilli 17). Alan Marzilli uses Dr. Jack Kevorkian, also called “Dr. Death”, as an example of where the legalization of physician assisted suicide can lead. Dr. Kevorkian, creator of a “suicide machine”, assisted with the suicides of over 100 patients and was convicted of second-degree murder (11-12). The general belief of people against euthanasia is that there is no way to prevent abuse, so it should be outlawed. John B. Mitchell concludes, “In the domain of the slippery
Related Documents: Physician assisted suicide Essay
Pro Choice: Physician Assisted Suicide Assisted suicide can date it origins back to Roman times before the christian overhaul, where doctors gave suffering patients a fatal poison. With the new coming of religon throughout the world the act of “assisted suicide” was deemed a sin. Not until recently in the 20th century has this issue been a frontpage headline that is causing severe controversy. The arguments for and against loosly include that it is murder offends many religons and is inhuman. Support…
Physician-Assisted Suicide Imagine lying in a hospital bed hooked up to all kinds of different machines. Doctors and nurses constantly entering the room to check up on you while you try to capture what little sleep you can muster through the pain. On top of the pain, you are suffering side effects from countless drugs. Breathing becomes an unbearable process. You have lost your appetite because you are constantly nauseated or throwing up. Doctors have given you no hope of survival; therefore, death…
Physician Assisted Suicide Itay Stawski ITT Technical Institute EN 1420 Professor Jeremy Pilarski November 10 2014 The Right to die debate; is the common name of this current issue. It’s legal in the state of Oregon since 1998. Since then more than 341 terminally ill people have taken advantage of it to hasten their deaths. According to Humphry (2013, September) “The Washington Death with Dignity Act, Initiative 1000, codified as RCW 70.245, passed on November 4, 2008” http://finalexit…
Name: Marva Dyer Date: June 3, 2008 Class: PHI1103 Word Count: 1225 Topic: Physician Assisted Suicide 1. Introduction and Thesis Chronic and life-limiting illness can also make a person feel like they have lost all control of their lives. The body isn’t doing what it should and there’s no way to stop it. Physician-assisted suicide (PAS) may feel like a way to regain some of that control. If they can’t control the illness, they can at least control how they die. Quality of life is the…
becoming a shell of their former selves. Without PAS people may commit suicide in a messy, horrifying or traumatic manor. Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is not for everyone, but for someone who wants to end their life because of a terminal debilitating illness, they should have that option with the help of a knowledgeable physician. Physician assisted suicide is defined by the American Medical Association as “when a physician facilitates a patient’s death by providing the necessary means and/or…
Paper 2 The definition of suicide is to kill oneself. In a society where suicide is looked down upon it is no surprise that the topic of physician assisted suicide is controversial. Ethically this action is deemed immoral and there are many theories that would support this claim. Physician assisted suicide is the voluntary termination of one’s own life by administration of a lethal substance with the direct or indirect assistance of a physician. The physician does not actually physically kill the…
Physician assisted suicide Physician assisted suicide (PAS) and active euthanasia has been an ongoing battle for many years now. Some countries have accepted parts of these “end of life” techniques and some have accepted both techniques. There are also countries, like the U.S., that have not accepted either of these techniques but have administered a right to die technique that allow the withholding and withdraw of treatment to terminally ill patients. Two recent court decisions made the…
Victoria Bogosian 10/13/14 Post University Physician Assisted Suicide Currently only four states in America have legalized physician-assisted suicide. The other 46 consider it illegal. The states that allow it are Montana, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. All legislations were passed between 1994 in 2013, so the legality of physician-assisted suicide is relatively new. Each state had its own reasoning for legalizing assisted suicide. Montana ruled that “a competent, terminally ill patient has a legal…
Ethics in Physician Assisted Suicide Christina Hendrickson GEN499: General Education Capstone Kelly Mink July 6, 2015 What is ethics? Ethics are moral principles that explains a person’s behavior. Dr. Jack Kevorkian a formal pathologist, is best known for assisting terminally ill patients with their death which is known as physician assisted suicide. Dr. Kevorkian once said; “In any project the important factor is your belief. Without belief there can be no…
suffering. The follow paper will give reasons as to why I believe that Physician assisted suicide should be legal all across the United States. In The United States it is up the state to legalize physician assisted suicide. There are three states, Oregon, Washington, and Montana that currently allow physician assisted suicide. Other states such as Vermont, New Jersey, Kansas, and Hawaii have bills legalizing physician assisted suicide being considered (Fox news, 2/08). With so many states having this…