Why is the question of Being a fundamental question?
The term ‘fundamental’ is defined as “a central or primary rule or principle on which something is based.” We can infer from this that Heidegger believed the question of Being to be the basis of philosophy, he thought that many philosophers asked whether things existed but ignored trying to ask what it means to exist. In this essay I will explain the three presuppositions made about the question of Being and why these emphasise the significance of the question rather than trivialize it. I will then refer to the formal structure of the question and why it is important to ask what Being actually is before we can ask about anything else in life, and will finally point out that we are the best entities to ask the question as it is our essence; Being only refers to human beings, as any other living thing “merely exists” or is “entirely determined by survival and reproduction” (Wheeler, 2011).
Heidegger first makes the distinction between the being of an entity; a static and structural existence (ontical), and the being in-the-world; a dynamic existence in the world in relation to other things (ontological) (Tietz, 2001, 13). He then points out in ancient Greece the question of Being was a ‘battle of the giants’ – philosophers such as Aristotle and Plato focused greatly on this but Heidegger (1962, 21) argues that the question has long since been trivialized, due to the fact that contemporary philosophers have simply argued that it is an empty concept.
Heidegger argues that the question of Being has been forgotten due to certain presuppositions and preconceptions which lead philosophers to believe that asking the question of Being is a waste of time. (Heidegger, 1962, 22). Firstly, he says people think “Being” is the most universal concept, but Heidegger argues it is the most obscure concept of all, which is why it is so important to try and define it. He claims the universality of Being is not a class or genus, as it transcends any class or genus, the fact it is such a vast concept reinforces how significant it is to try and understand it. He points out “the multiplicity of categories applicable to things” proposed by Aristotle does not make it any more direct and easy to comprehend, if anything it emphasises how much we have to try and understand before we can answer the question of being (Heidegger, 1962, 23). Therefore the universality does not make it the clearest to us at all, if anything it makes it unclear; it is such a transcendent concept that it can take a long time to say we appreciate every aspect.
Secondly, Heidegger claims Being is an undefinable concept, he argued that definitions can only be articulated in terms of class but this is not part of one. (Baiasu, 2014, Lecture 2). Heidegger (1962, 23) argues the definition of Being is not something that can be derived from something higher or represented by something lower, as it is so transcendent to anything we are familiar with. Many might argue that the definition of Being is that of a physical entity, but Being is not an entity and cannot be understood in this way; there is no such character than can be applied in order to make it an entity. Nevertheless, it could also be argued that Being already has a definition as we at least know it does not ‘have the character of an entity’ (Heidegger, 1962, 23), so it must be the other kind of being that we already know.
Heidegger counters this with the point that it is this definition that is the problem, it is the fact that Aristotle has tried to give a definition to this transcendent concept that we are confused and we think we know what Being is and therefore the question does not need to be asked (Tietz, 2005, 14). However, Heidegger (1962, 23) argued that “the indefinability of Being does not eliminate the question of its meaning; it demands we look that question in the face.” Indefinability does not dispense with the question of Being, it forces it upon us,
Related Documents: Philosophical Traditions Essays
INDIAN PHILOSOPHY INTRODUCTION The tradition of recorded philosophical thought of the Indian subcontinent is as ancient, rich and subtle as any in the world. With roots in the insights of rishis, or seers, in the second millennium BCE, the tradition has developed continuously since that time, diversifying into the many schools of Hindu thought, together with Buddhism, Sikhism and Jainism. The thinkers in this tradition investigate all the great philosophical questions: in all the branches of philosophy…
The Taoist tradition can be recognised as being historically divided into a philosophical and a religious dimension and there has both been interdependence and dissension between the two branches. It should be remembered that there are many forms and a network of doctrines contained in the term "Taoism". These different forms of Taoism both waxed and waned and may have both had an influence on and been influenced by other strands of Chinese religious tradition in their turn. The term…
in Christian revelation."[66] With this in mind, Thomas did have respect for Aristotle, so much so that in the Summa, he often cites Aristotle simply as "the Philosopher." Much of his work bears upon philosophical topics, and in this sense may be characterized as philosophical. Thomas's philosophical thought has exerted enormous influence on subsequent Christian theology, especially that of the Roman Catholic Church, extending to Western philosophy in general. Thomas stands as a vehicle and modifier…
element to keep writer or speaker to reach the purpose of inform, persuade, and motivate with particular audience. In addition, rhetoric has played a crucial role in the Western tradition in the past many decades. Plato is one of the people that made huge contributions on rhetoric has played a crucial role in the Western tradition in the past many decade. Truth and justice are the ultimately goals which Plato has his faith on. To be specific, Plato rhetoric requires addressing a right purpose of using…
2. Hinduism and Buddhism are traditions that originated from the Vedic sacrifice practice, and they share a common foundation in their view of existence. What are the similarities, and very importantly, the differences in their respective focuses and goals? Also included in this topic: For a time, Buddhism became a dominant tradition in much of India, but then Hinduism rose to become the dominant tradition. There are relatively few Buddhists in India today, especially in comparison to the number…
meanings that draw lines between the real and unreal, the mortal and the immortal, the conscious and the unconscious and even the divine and the profane. In addition to that, academically, we have come to understand Māyā as a core ideology of Hindu Traditions which envelopes the critical comprehension of illusion. Maya and the Vedic era Rewinding time to 1200 BCE teaches us that this idea of Māyā has had different roots. As mentioned earlier, the concept of Maya is over 3,000 years old and it first…
faithful in God and he who has no sins on themselves. For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life – John 3:16. Islam is a monotheistic religious tradition that developed in the Middle East in the 7th century C.E. Islam, which literally means surrender, was founded on the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad as an expression of surrender to the will of Allah, the creator and sustainer of the world. The…
The Enlightenment, also called the Age of Reason, was period in history when a philosophical movement during the eighteenth century that emphasized the use of reason to analyze once accepted doctrines or ideas and focused less on superstitions. During this movement, individuals placed an emphasis on experience and reason, mistrust of religion and tradition, and a slow emergence of the ideals of liberal, democratic societies. One of the major figures of this movement was Voltaire. Voltaire was born…
The predominant and indigenous religion of the Indian subcontinent. Hinduism is a conglomeration of distinct intellectual or philosophical points of view, rather than a rigid, common set of beliefs. Hinduism is formed of diverse traditions and has no single founder. Among its direct roots is the historical Vedic religion of Iron Age India and, as such, Hinduism is often called the "oldest living religion" or the "oldest living major religion" in the world. The earliest evidence for prehistoric…
of life, create a desire to get nearer to the world of Eternity and truth prepares the soul for a higher and spiritual life, or does it? Philosophy can cause doubt and confusion causing one to question already held beliefs. One can argue that philosophical study is a misrepresentation of God’s word it is the misguided thought process of man’s pride and vanity of himself. It is the destructive words or ideas to separate God from the world, and the world from God. An argument that one cannot ignore…