The war against animal inequality (defined by some, as humans being morally more significant than nonhuman animals) has begun. Peter Singer, in his article “Ethics and Animals” makes a few valid points. The way that these animals are treated on factory farms is indeed horrendous and should definitely not be occurring in the 21st century. But, to compare animals to humans is completely preposterous. Bonnie Steinbock in her paper “Speciesism and the Idea of Equality” stated, “ human beings have a different moral status from members of other species because of certain capacities which are characteristics of being human. We may not all be equal in these capacities, but all human beings possess them to some measure, and non-human animals do not. For example, human beings are normally held to be responsible for what they do.”(Steinbock 252) I’ve never witnessed a lion on trial for murdering a gazelle or a cat cleaning up a mess that it made. This by no means condones the torture and suffering that animals may go through, but it does show a sense of moral superiority.
Singer’s argument is that humans being superior to animals in sense of reasoning and other intellectual capabilities, is not enough to justify the line we draw between humans and animals. He argues that if reasoning and intelligence are the only characteristics which dictate whether you live a life of pain, that of an animal,or a human one, then infants and people with profound mental disability who clearly lack these skills have to be subject to that life of pain as well. He believes that this idea justifies the use of infants and people who are mentally ill for painful and lethal scientific research instead of animals who are superior to such. ( Singer 2) Evidently, Singer does not know the purpose of scientific research. We spend millions perhaps even billions of dollars a year on scientific research for the benefit of humans. So it would be very contrary to use humans and risk harming them, when our ultimate goal is to save and benefit their lives. Steinbock agrees that, “If we can free human beings from crippling diseases, pain and death through experimentations which involves making animals suffer, and if this is the only way to achieve such results, then I think that such experimentation is justified because human lives are more important than animals lives,” a point which Singer fails to acknowledge. (Steinbock 253)
Even though, Singer may not agree, intelligence is definitely a factor in how we treat others. Just take a look at society, anywhere that one tries to apply for a
substance that allows electricity or heat to flow through it easily 4) Electrical energy: one of the most useful forms of energy. It is used in heat and light, which are two very valuable things that would be difficult to live without 5) Electromagnet spectrum: the wide range of wavelengths from lower frequencies such as radio waves, short wave, AM, FM, TV, and radar to infrared rays, visible light and ultraviolet, and, finally, the shorter wavelengths of x-rays and gamma rays 6) Electrons: negatively…
Much of history is dotted with brave, shining examples of revolutionaries that rise up against governments who dare to oppose them. Yet how are revolutionaries so different from terrorists like al-Qaeda? How can these two rebels be on the opposite sides of the spectrum of moral and immoral? For example, George Washington is hailed as a founder of our nation since he led the American revolutionaries against the British. On the surface he seems to be a man who could not stand injustice, but he was a British…
Jennifer Sladky SPD 160 Article #1-Due 8/28/13 Autism Spectrum Disorders “Autistic spectrum disorders refer to a range of disorders related to the core disorder of autism and including Asperger’s syndrome” (Lewis 110-121). The ASDs have 3 things in common. They all have impairments in the areas of social and emotional understanding, all aspects of communication, and the flexibility in thinking and behavior. The actual core of autism has been acknowledged for 60 years. ASDs have not been recognized…
survivors and their descendants almost thirty years after conquest. These were similar because they weren’t taken at the time or directly after the event but some years later. In contrast, these two primary documents were accounts of people on opposite sides of the spectrum. A Conquistador’s View discusses the events of his journey into Tenochtitlan and the following battles. He discusses the greetings his troops received from Montezuma’s people, their long journey into Tenochtitlan and the battles that…
ideology associated with Thatcherism and is the opposite of what socialists believe in. Socialists believe in collectivism and equality in society and would say that individualism is selfish and creates inequality. Blair did this as part of the process of triangulation, where the core Labour party principles were melded together with lessons learnt from Thatcherism. This demonstrates that Labour was moving away from the left of the political spectrum. Conversely, evidence that Labour did not move…
Just as Jack, many people and countries have the desire to be the best; to run the world. They have a passion and they yearn for power over others, giving Jack the symbol of the desire for dominance. Whereas Ralph and Jack stand at opposite sides of the spectrum between savagery and civilization, Simon stands on a completely different plane. Simon embodies a kind of innate, spiritual human goodness that is deeply connected with nature, where he also represents the innocence and goodness of humans…
Frederick Taylor pioneered the principles of scientific management and his work remains not only relevant but evident across the spectrum of industry today. A quick glance into the organizational structure or operations procedures of just about any employer will reveal aspects of Mr. Taylor’s studies and teachings. My experience has been within the casino industry so I will cite examples from this. It seems ironic that we can find so much evidence of scientific management in casino megaresorts…
theories could be implemented for a particular context and practice. Roger’s theory is based on a humanistic approach, while Skinner’s theory takes a behaviourist approach; each theory has both benefits and shortcomings. Their views form opposite ends of the learning spectrum. These theories will be examined as their respective works address the underlying issue of how children learn to behave. This essay will also discuss the advantages of teachers creating a positive and happy learning environment…
democratic, and laissez-faire (Changing Minds, 2011). This paper will focus on these behavioral theories of leadership, primarily concentrating on participative leadership. An autocratic leader tells employees what to do and how to do it. On the opposite extreme, a laissez-faire leader allows employees to make their own decisions with little…
MUS 320 Developments in Rhythm from the 18th to 21st Centuries Music can be broken down into a number of aspects. Each aspect influences the creation, study, and performance of music. Music is composed mainly of harmonic and melodic progressions, and rhythm. Rhythm is the organization of the time element in music. Music is often composed between the two parameters of pitch and rhythm. Rhythm is made up of beats, which is the heartbeat (pulse) of any piece of music. From the beginning of…