Gabby Bell
Mr. Lincoln
English 12 AP
November 14, 2014
Researchers have been in dispute for many centuries about whether nature or nurture has a stronger influence on early human development
.
Nature is inherent traits from birth and Nurture is one's environment
(physical, cultural, social, and familial) and how each plays in one's physical and psychological identity (doc 1)
.
In my opinion, I believe that nurture is a more powerful influence in the human experience.
Nurture strongly influences early human development for many reasons. th According to John Locke (17
Century), the mind of a newborn infant is a
“blank slate.” As the baby experiences and interacts with his world through his senses, the knowledge becomes built and is written down on the slate (doc 2).
Locke clearly believes that we are born with a variety of faculties that enable us to receive and process information (the senses, memory, our ability to use language) and to manipulate it once we have it, but what we do not have is innate knowledge or ideas
.
2
Bell
In my own real world experiences, my best friend was completely bullied out of his school district. The way his friends nurtured him adequately changed his entire life. The environment around him, his friends harassing him, altered his everyday life and has put off his graduation from high school two years (so far)
.
But in his nature, and up till he met those friends, he was a completely normal child. The nature aspect of his life allowed him to grow up in a stable home with a loving family, and allowed his academics to prosper as well. The actual nature of his person, his genes, allowed him to be biologically structured with a high IQ. But considering the nurture aspect again, the environment he grew up in forced him to drop out of high school and attempt to get on track to receive his GED for the second time.
Michael Bamberger illustrates both nature and nurture in his true story,
Wonderland.
The introduction of characters such as Harry Stymiest and Bobby
Speer briefly exhibit both nature and nurture aspects of one’s physical and psychological identity (doc 3)
.
Bobby Speer was incredibly skilled at all the sports he participated in even though they were widely varied. He was the captain of the football team, a part of the wrestling team, and the center fielder on the baseball team. Bobby was a solid B student, which helped him get scholarships from many different colleges. The only setback was his brother, Danny, four years younger, who had
3
Bell
been born with spina bifida, with his spinal cord bulging through his skin.
Bobby is the only person who could actually take care of him, which includes lifting him up, bringing him to the bathroom, changing Danny’s diapers, and cleaning up after him. Karen Speer, Bobby’s mother, would tell him, “You’re gonna go to college and then to the pros, and Danny’s gonna be your agent.”
Bobby would always silently agree with his mother. He knew his dreams, and so did his mother, but he also faced the
and what is taught to us. We are taught by our parents, by our teachers, by grandparents, by siblings, friends, ect.. but ultimately a parents wants there child to grow up knowing they taught them to do what was right and wrong. This is where Nature vs. Nurture come into play this is where we learn ones interest and abilities such as creativity, social skills, problem-solving ability, and so forth. Parents are the keys to intellectual development for almost all children in the care and education…
Nature vs Nurture: Do You Choose Your Sexuality, Or Is It Genetic? The nature vs. nurture debate is one of the most enduring in the field of psychology because of the many different topics that can be attained in this single field. Psychologist have thought and asked questions of how far are human behaviors, ideas, and feeling, innate and how far are they all learned? These issues are at the center of the ongoing nature versus nurture controversy. The French philosopher Rene Descartes suggested…
Nature vs. Nurture The dubious history of the heredity environment controversy can be easily traced as far back as the start of the present century with at least some historical evidence placing the roots of this dispute in the time of John Locke. This controversy has continued despite continual reiteration that the critical question is not how much of a trait is due to heredity and how much is due to environment, but rather how environment transact to influence development." ( Wachs ,…
Nature vs. Nurture “we all born mad,some remain so”.(Samuel Beckett) want it or not,we come to this world with a pre-determined identety that we have no power over it.A set of parameters, like our parents, form the blueprint of what we are.from this point,we are somehow consciously aware of the influences we are exposed to.I am going to discuss the superiority of nurture over nature, in the process of what we become.The issues involved, are family,values of the society, and the…
7th Nurture Vs. Nature There has been a large controversy over whether parental teaching effect our way of thinking or if the environment influences and effects our way of thinking. Some people believe that it is strictly parental teachings that effect our way of life, others believe that it is the environment that effects us, and some believe that both of these influence our behavior. Either way, people have been struggling for a long time deciding whether our personalities are nurture or nature…
The debate nature and nurture has been going on for years and is still unresolved due to no one quite knowing which one is true. Nature vs nurture is about what makes us, us. The genetic makeup (nature) and life experiences (nurture). Many theorists think that it is nature, what we have inherited and our genes, makes us the way we are and how we develop. Where other theorists believe it is the way we are brought up and our experiences, that make us the way we are and how we develop. A wide variety…
Nature Vs Nurture I am familiar with “Nature over Nurture” and I’ve seen it firsthand. I have seen it in small children who make toys that they want while ignoring the room full of toys they have. I’ve seen it in adopted children taking after birth parents in their interests, weaknesses and strengths, regardless of the surroundings that they were pre-exposed to. It is the nature that radiates who we are no matter what our environment is. It is the nurture that builds our psyche…
The nature versus nurture debate is about the roles of innate quality or genetic inheritance versus personal experience or environmental factors. This notion is part of the fundamental themes in psychology that is known as heredity and environment (Wayne Weiten & Doug McCann, 2013). Theorists have argued about personal traits and abilities and their connection with nature and nurture. Some theorists believe that personality traits and skills are governed by genetic predisposition. However, environmental…
Keith Mierzejewski Methods of Critical Thinking Research Paper December 11, 2010 Nature vs. Nurture One of the most enduring debates in the field of psychology is the controversial idea of nature vs. nurture. Throughout the endless history of the debate, no clear conclusion has been met, only hypotheses have been formed. At the center of the debate, human behaviors, ideas, and feelings are being determined, whether they are learned or inherited. Determining physical traits, such as eye color…
Nature Vs Nurture Your physical features can be identified as identical to that of your parents, like your eyes from your father, and the hair colour from your mother. However, your personality and talents may have come not from your father or mother. The environment where you grew up may have a lasting effect or influence on that way you talk, behave and respond to the things around you. Nature asserts that development is dependent on biological programming or genetic make-up that an offspring…