Collin Calloway has an interesting view on the practice on the writing down and recording of history. He makes a few good points in his interdiction that stand out and challenge other historian’s views on the documentation of early Native American history. History has been documented and recorded since the beginning of time, but different people have always portrayed events in a different way.
Calloway makes the first point that history cannot be told from a single perspective. There are always two sides to every story. Sometimes there are different ways of remembering the same events. This leads into the second point of the perspective of cause and effect. Europeans saw the Americas as free open land for the taking when the Native Americans after 1492 were suffering and dying off from European diseases brought by Columbus and future visitors. Thirdly Calloway points out that Native American history was rarely written down. Oral history was more of a tradition to pass stories about the past down through their ancestors. Finally Calloway’s last argument that made the most sense was the fact that people weren’t always educated enough or truthful enough to record history as it actually happened. We see this throughout history when military leaders embellish their war stories or when history is modifies to make one person or country look better than another. Calloway makes all valid and believable arguments that somewhat agree with other historians, but he may be missing a valuable argument that other historians have already thought of.
In the reading “Thinking like an Indian”, Hoxie makes an interesting argument that not every native American had the same experience He argues that with every tribe being a little different, that oral and recorded history will vary from tribe to tribe. In his article he explains how Neolin, a Delaware teacher theorized that Natives and whites should be completely separate societies. This theory was followed by Tecumseh’s brother Tenskwatawa when he helped spread Neolin’s theory and he also started more of an anti-American movement among Natives. This theory wasn’t so much supported but more or less modified by Seneca Handsome Lake. He saw the Europeans just as another
Related Documents: Collin Calloway's View On The History Of Native American History
29 January 2015 Ceramic Vessel L.E.D Around the technical abilities that I gained from making the ceramic vessel, I learned a lot about Native American culture and Native American storytelling and how it relates to the making of the vessels during that time. We watched several videos in class about Native Americans and their vessels and they taught me that Native Americans are sub divided into groups all around the United States. Each group has its own legacy or significant stories, and they reflect these legacies and stories on their vessels…
Dominique Peso Mini Paper 6 My Native American Culture I am a Mescalero apache who grew up in the reservation of Mescalero NM. I am very proud of where I come from. I am also proud of the traditions that are in my culture. There are three main traditions in our culture which is our language, the feasts, and our traditional foods. It is very important that we keep our traditions strong by passing them along. One of our main traditions that need to be passed on is our language. It seems as I…
Native American Challenge to the European Dichotomous View of Sexuality Throughout the early modern period, Native American and European cultures differed greatly. Europeans used these differences to judge “the sexual lives of the native peoples as savage, in contrast to their own ‘civilized’ customs,” and to justify “efforts to convert the native population to Christianity” (D'Emilio and Freedman 6). Native American sexuality deviated considerably from European sexuality, primarily in the areas…
Burial Rituals of Native American Culture At some point in our lives, we all come to realize that death is a part of life. Cultural diversity provides a wide variety of lifestyles and traditions for each of the unique groups of people in our world. Within these different cultures, the rituals associated with death and burial can also be uniquely diverse. Many consider ritualistic traditions that differ from their own to be somewhat strange and often perceive them as unnatural. A prime example…
Native American Culture and Modern Society In the novel Tuesdays with Morrie by Mitch Albom, Morrie talks about the importance of creating your own culture. Morrie says, "The culture we have does not make people feel good about themselves. And you have to be strong enough to say if the culture doesn't work, don't buy it" (Albom 42). Throughout Morrie’s life he was constantly observing the differences and similarities between different races, cultures, and societies. Many times during the book…
In 1974 the Administration for Native Americans was established and remains the only federal agency that serves all Native Americans including 562 federally recognized tribes. The goals of the ANA include; the creation of jobs, the establishment of tribal employment offices, formulation of environmental ordinances, strengthen governmental functions of tribes and to establish local court systems. Native Americans also have a strong belief in their culture today. There are many other organizations…
America truly is the salad bowl of cultures from around the whole world. However, there is often times a dominating cultural structure that makes it difficult to attain peace among the diverse cultural groups of America. Sherman Alexie’s short story, Because my Father Always Said He Was the Only Indian Who Saw Jimi Hendrix Play ‘The Star-Spangled Banner’ at Woodstock, displays the difficulty of the Native American people having to cope with the dominating culture that they are inevitably being shoved…
the effects it had on Native American people. The mascot and symbol was associated with the university’s intercollegiate athletic programs for over 80 years and was portrayed by a student dressed in Sioux clothing. The student performed dances during football, basketball and volleyball games to entertain fans and help build school spirit. Chief Illiniwek was the center of controversy for over 20 years because many thought that the Chief misappropriated Native American culture and brought about harmful…
Waischu:One who takes best meat for himself, or selfish. The Native Americans moved from their homes to reservations. White settlers took the Native Americans land because they needed space for cultivating, living, the valuable gold on their land, and most of all greed. The Trail of Tears which caused a high death toll, began in the early 1800’s and continued for several years. The reservations take place in the mid/South West. Later on Andrew Jackson signed the act which formally removed the Native Americans from their homes. The country had rascists…
Native American Storytelling November 12, 2012 ENG/301 Native American Storytelling Native American literature is the root of cultural storytelling, which is told through oral tradition, this consist of stories and songs verbally. Native American literature use literary conventions in the root of myth and symbolic examples in storytelling. The book “Native American Literature: A Brief Introduction and Anthology” gives good insight into the Native American ways of life and how storytelling is…