Imperialism: Imperialism and Elephant George Orwell Essay
Submitted By AdhamAbdelhameed
Words: 641
Pages: 3
Adham Abdelhameed 2/26/13 Outline
Intro:
Throughout history, the Western world employed imperialism to exploit the indigenous populations of underdeveloped nations. In the beginning of the 19th century, Europeans saw their chance to expand their dominion over the world under the nationalistic impression that they were of “master race.” Ideally, imperialism is an opportunistic window for the subjugated peoples to learn from their subjugators. As John Stuart Mill suggested in his piece, “A Few Words on Non-Intervention,” there has to be certain “reciprocity” for imperialism to succeed and benefit humanity as a whole. Such a reciprocal relationship between oppressor and subject is not possible and it contradicts the true nature of imperialism.
Thesis: In actuality, the theory of imperialism is a paradox, it is all one large contradiction; imperialism is un-mutual, immoral and self-destructive.
Paragraph I: Address flaws with the theory presented by Mill- no reciprocity
Point 1: Mill’s idea of reciprocity is completely hypothetical.
Point 2: Fanon tells us the reality of the situation:
From Fanon: “The zone where the natives live is not complementary to the zone inhabited by the settlers. The two zones are opposed, but not in the service of higher unity... No conciliation is possible, for of the two terms one is superfluous.” Paragraph II: Theory in context vs. Theory in practice the issue of morality Mill said that exploiting a civilization for ones one good is unwarranted. “He cannot rightfully be compelled to do or forbear because it will be better for him to do so because it will make him happier, because, in the opinions of others, to do so would be wise.” Consider William’s letter to King Leopold Williams: The flaw with Mills’ theory relative to the events in Williams’ letter is that Mills assumes the morality of the imperialist. Leopold promised the Congo would benefit but failed to uphold his responsibilities as a leader. Mill said that the imperialists were responsible for the well being of the colonized, but again we see Mills theory fails in practice. Consider Orwell’s Shooting an Elephant George Orwell was “disgusted by the inhumanity of colonial rule that he witnessed while stationed in Burma” (2835 Longman Anthology).
Obviously, Orwell agrees that imperialism fails in practice, just as it did in Leopold’s case. In shooting an elephant, the narrator is faced with an internal conflict that is symbolic of the nature of imperialism. No matter which road the narrator takes, he reaches a dead end. He has to uphold
Related Documents: Imperialism: Imperialism and Elephant George Orwell Essay
are completely incapable of helping themselves.After reading "Shooting An Elephant", by the fascinating George Orwell, many things caught my attention. The main focus point for me was the theme of Imperialism. Throughout the story Orwell gives many signs that he is against it and sees it as an unjust act. Looking at Orwell's side of things I completely agree. Imperialism is evil. I feel through Orwell's symbolism imperialism humiliates the occupied people. It seemingly lowers the people to a level…
Composition December 11, 2011 Instructor: Prof. Daniel Linker George Orwell: A Literary Genius Eric Arthur Blair, commonly known as George Orwell was born in India in 1903. His father was a minor British official. Throughout Orwell’s childhood he felt a deep sense of isolation, a factor that later influenced his writing. He attended St. Cyprian’s preparatory school and, later, Eton College. Having completed his education, Orwell then served as Assistant Superintendent of Police in Burma between…
long-lasting effects. In “Shooting an Elephant,” written by George Orwell, writes a short story about a past event from his life when he had chosen against his conscience while serving as a British police officer in Burma. Orwell’s misery, moral dilemmas, and his pride prevents him from feeling satisfied and fulfilled with his life. Being apart of British imperialism that Orwell hated, along side of his job, and the hatred towards the Burmese natives. Orwell felt isolated and mentally weak being…
Technique Analysis of ‘Shooting an elephant’ Written by George Orwell Essay by Arthur Diennet In 1936, George Orwell published his short story ‘Shooting an elephant’ in an English magazine. Since then, it has been republished dozens of times and holds a place as a definitive anti-colonial piece of literature, in an era where the British Empire was at its peak and covered almost 1/3 of the Earth’s surface. George Orwell believed that “…imperialism was an evil thing...” and uses much themes…
14 December 2014 White Man’s Burden I. Plot Précis “Shooting an Elephant” is based on George Orwell’s experience with the Indian Imperial Police during the early twentieth century. The essay is set in Moulmein, (Lower) Burma and begins with Orwell, the presumed narrator, questioning the presence of the British in the Far East. As one of the colonial policemen at the time, the speaker advocates his disapproval of British Imperialism but confesses that his “greatest joy” was being a tormenter, poking…
The struggle from which any reform comes greatly engages those who wager in it, which permeates the outcome. To that end, George Orwell draws a parallel to Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution in his Shooting an Elephant by raising the chaotic nature of human behavior with respect to political reform. He dramatized the harmful political behavior by metaphorically expressing imperialistic ideas and their effects, and in doing so, he inadvertently showed that ideals arise gradually. Darwin, on the…
brutality for a selfish display of dominance. In George Orwell’s short story, “Shooting an Elephant”, Orwell is a sub-divisional police officer in Burma, a country under British control in the Imperialism era. Orwell, who represents the British as a Superpower, is confronted by the obligations of duty and integrity when he has to shoot an elephant that went “must.” So he is forced to use brutality to display his dominance by shooting the elephant in front of the natives; he later justifies his brutality…
Susan Chapman ENC1101_Online Essay Three Professor Matthew Brooks Due 03/09/15 Learn From Your Mistakes George Orwell was a man of bad circumstance. He was an Englishman, thrust by his own nation, in the country of India where his country was trying to claim dominion. He was forced to do things for his country that he didn’t believe in to inforce his countries dominance, describing in detail such as, “the scarred buttocks of the men who had been flogged with bamboos-“ (2) Because of this, he was…
Isaac Talavera 10/10/2014 ENG 101 MWF 1-1:50PM Mr. Andrews The Price of Pride A Closer Look at George Orwell’s “Shooting An Elephant” After receiving the call I quickly sprang to my feet, grabbed a hold of my 44 Winchester rifle, and headed out the door towards town on horseback. When I arrived, I immediately saw the destruction in which the beast had made. The sight of such horror left me in great shock and amazement. I began to search for the animal but what not successful in my attempts. I had…
start with something is an influence. According to The New Lexington Webster’s Dictionary, an influence is a person’s indirect power over men, events, or things. All authors have some kind of influence to their writings, so what was George Orwell’s? George Orwell was born on June 25, 1903 in Motihari, Bengal, India. He was born with the name Eric Arthur Blair. At the age of one, his mother took him to England where he received most of his education. When he turned five, he attended a small Anglican…