How many objects can you track?: Evidence for a resource-limited attentive tracking mechanism
Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences
Massachusetts Institute of Technology,
Cambridge, MA, USA
George A. Alvarez
Steven L. Franconeri
Department of Psychology Northwestern University,
Evanston, IL, USA
Much of our interaction with the visual world requires us to isolate some currently important objects from other less important objects. This task becomes more difficult when objects move, or when our field of view moves relative to the world, requiring us to track these objects over space and time. Previous experiments have shown that observers can track a maximum of about 4 moving objects. A natural explanation for this capacity limit is that the visual system is architecturally limited to handling a fixed number of objects at once, a so-called magical number 4 on visual attention. In contrast to this view, Experiment 1 shows that tracking capacity is not fixed. At slow speeds it is possible to track up to 8 objects, and yet there are fast speeds at which only a single object can be tracked. Experiment 2 suggests that that the limit on tracking is related to the spatial resolution of attention. These findings suggest that the number of objects that can be tracked is primarily set by a flexibly allocated resource, which has important implications for the mechanisms of object tracking and for the relationship between object tracking and other cognitive processes.
Keywords: multiple object tracking, MOT, multi-element tracking, attentive tracking, FINST, FLEX, attention, capacity
Citation: Alvarez, G. A., & Franconeri, S. L. (2007). How many objects can you track?: Evidence for a resource-limited attentive tracking mechanism. Journal of Vision, 7(13):14, 1–10, http://journalofvision.org/7/13/14/, doi:10.1167/7.13.14.
Introduction
Tracking moving objects over space and time is a fundamental part of making sense of a dynamic visual world. Whether driving on a busy highway, playing team sports, or watching one’s children at the playground, one often maintains attention on multiple moving objects simultaneously. To explore this ability in the laboratory, researchers have employed the multiple object tracking task (Pylyshyn & Storm, 1988). Typically, a set of identical items is presented and a subset of target items is cued, then all items move randomly about the screen for several seconds. During this time, all of the items appear identical and the eyes can only fixate directly on one target at a time. Thus, to track multiple targets concurrently, observers are required to “mentally track” the target items as they move about the display. At the end of the trial, all of the items stop and the observer must indicate which items were the original targets.
Studies employing this task have been used to investigate a wide range of topics in visual cognition, including determining what counts as an object for object-based attention (Scholl & Pylyshyn, 1999; Scholl, Pylyshyn, &
Feldman, 2001), the dynamics of attention in depth
(Viswanathan & Mingolla, 2002), the coordinate systems underlying attention (Liu et al., 2005), the limits on divided or multifocal attention (Alvarez, Horowitz, doi: 1 0. 11 67 / 7 . 1 3 . 1 4
Aresenio, DiMase, & Wolfe, 2005; Cavanagh & Alvarez,
2005), age differences in attention (Trick, Audet, &
Dales, 2003), and deficits in attention for different patient populations (Ho et al., 2006; O’Hearn, Landau, &
Hoffman, 2005).
Given the broad range of work that employs the multiple object-tracking task, it is important to understand the nature of limits on tracking at a basic level. In the current paper, we investigate whether the limit on the number of objects that can be tracked is fixed (the fixedarchitecture model), or whether the limit on tracking is set by a resource that can be flexibly allocated to objects depending on the demands of
Related Documents: How Many Objects Can You Track?
Table of Contents TQM Origins Abstract 4 Quality in History 4 What is Quality? 5 Joseph M. Juran 6 The Juran Trilogy 6 Quality Planning 7 Quality Control 7 Quality Improvement 7 Road Map for Enterprise Quality 8 Decide 8 Prepare 8 Launch 9 Expand 9 Sustain 9 W. Edwards Deming 10 System of Profound Knowledge 10 Theory of Management Components 11 Appreciation of a System 11 Theory of Variation 12 Theory of Knowledge 13 Psychology 13 Fourteen Points for Management 13 Point One: Create Constancy of Purpose…
Gilchrist 2003). The eye movement control system enables us to fixate and hold our gaze through moving our eyes 3-4 times a second. The eye muscles themselves are regulated by motor neurons, however both subcortical and cortical brain areas play critical roles in the production and control of saccades. Schiller (1998) proposed two neural pathways for the generation of voluntary and reflexive eye movements: the first being the anterior pathway that flows through the Frontal Eye Fields (FEF) and Supplementary…
Going to Market – Marketing channel - network via which firm goes to market. channel first must generate demand for a product and service and n fulfill that demand and provide for after-–sale service. Finally channel often serves as a useful function in transmitting feedback from custom. back to manufacturer. When a company thinks about going to market it must consider what each of functions will specifically entail and who will do m – manufacturer or a chosen partner - distributor or retailer…
academic researchers have studied the industrial revolution periods along with their socioeconomic impacts. Back in 2000, Dr. John D Kasarda, University of North Carolina professor and acknowledged developer of the ‘Aerotropolis’ concept introduced his vision for a revolutionary development capable of meeting the demands of 21st Century globalization. Dr. Kasarda’s idea centered on a new urban development form comprising aviation-intensive businesses and related enterprises extending up to 25 kilometers…
Sometimes, evil works. Over the past 100 years, management theory has followed a smooth trajectory, from enslavement to empowerment. The 20th century began with Taylorism — engineer Frederick Winslow Taylor's notion that workers are interchangeable cogs — but with every decade came a new philosophy, each advocating that more power…
Contents 1) Executive Summary 2) Objective 3) Mission 4) Marketing Objective 5) Key to Success 6) Company Summary 7) Company Ownership 8) Management Summary 9) Industry Analysis – Porter’s Five force 9.1) Rivalry among existing firms 9.2) Potential of new entrants into industry 9.3) Power of suppliers 9.4) Power of buyer 9.4) Threat of substitute products 10) Macro-environmental – PESTAL analysis 10.1) Political and legal environment 10.2) Economies environment 10.3) Social &…
Wk 1: Gerontological Nursing N410 Young-Shin Lee, PhD, RN School of Nursing San Diego State University 1 Learning Objectives Examine the history of gerontological nursing. Discuss the nurse’s role in caring for older adults. Identify educational preparation and certification requirement for gerontological nurse generalist and specialist. Related course objectives: 1.1~1.4 2 **Gerontological Nursing Gerontology: study of aging; a branch of science that deals with the aging population…
CONTENTS: CASE STUDIES CASE STUDY 1 Midsouth Chamber of Commerce (A): The Role of the Operating Manager in Information Systems CASE STUDY I-1 IMT Custom Machine Company, Inc.: Selection of an Information Technology Platform CASE STUDY I-2 VoIP2.biz, Inc.: Deciding on the Next Steps for a VoIP Supplier CASE STUDY I-3 The VoIP Adoption at Butler University CASE STUDY I-4 Supporting Mobile Health Clinics: The Children’s Health Fund of New York City CASE STUDY I-5…