Should the government provide health care? In most developed economies health care is one of the two largest government expenditures. However, there has been a huge debate over the decision to provide health care to who cannot afford to provide it for themselves. Even though many believe that the government should not be responsible for providing health care, there are many sick uninsured people who would disagree. People without health care should not be discriminated against for getting sick it should be their civil right to have access to decent health care provided by the government. Access to health care should be a civil right in the United States because the preamble of the United States Constitution includes the terms “to promote The Preamble states that the government must “promote” the general welfare of the citizens. It does not say that the government has to provide it. Universal health care is not a right because the Preamble of the US Constitution states that its purpose is to "promote" the general welfare, not to provide it. It is understandable and almost a given that America has the moral responsibility to help those who are less fortunate. If one looks at past and present history, it is clear that our government helps out third world countries all the time. But, it is not the requirement of the government to spoon feed each citizen his or her own needs and demands. If universal healthcare becomes a civil right, every citizen will have the right to free healthcare. John Campbell, MBT, US Representative (R-CA), wrote in his July 13, 2009 OC Register opinion article "John Campbell: A Right to Health Care?": “…the Second Amendment guarantees the right to bear arms. It does not however, say that you get guns for free if you don't have one. This is analogous to the issue of health care 'rights.' (http://healthcare.procon.org) This is a great analogue and example how one must read the constitution carefully and not twist around the wording to lobby for a cause. President Gerald Ford said the following statement at a joint session of Congress on August 12, 1974, "A government big enough to give you everything you want, is
Related Documents: Government Healthcare Debate Essay
U.S. Healthcare Reform I.) Stakes and Positions Healthcare reform continues to be one of the most contentious subjects of debate in American politics. Healthcare accounts for over 16% of federal expenditures, forecasted to increase in the years ahead1. The two main political parties represent the interests of an array of interest groups and providers at state and national levels. Republicans protect private interests, promoting the view that healthcare should be a privilege, and quality should…
affordable healthcare to millions of Americans that are unable to afford it otherwise. Still there are two very strong and separated views on the issue of this new national healthcare plan. Questions on the constitutionality of the plan are thick in the air and a matter of serious debate, and there is no question why; both sides have very valid arguments. The answer is, the law breaches a line protecting our liberty, yet can surely on some level be considered a Positive Liberty as the government is providing…
Democrats, Republicans and the Medicaid Debate Tanya Z. Cuellar Excelsior College Dr. Mitchell Rosenwald HSC510 Democrats, Republicans and the Medicaid Debate Originally intended to help the poor, pregnant, and disabled, Medicaid has become widely abused by many young, healthy, able-bodied adults. With President Obamas Affordable Care Act (ACA) each state was given the option to expand Medicaid coverage to many more individuals. Like the ACA, the debate on Medicaid expansion appears to be split…
own vision on America’s large corporations, such as the Bush administration’s foreign policy, financial crises, and the American healthcare system. Although all of his…
Health Reform Plan Paper Health care reform has been a controversial topic between the government and public alike for many years now. President Harry Truman in the 1940’s was the first to recognize that our country needed some sort of universal health care (McLaughlin 2008). Fast forward to the year 1990 and little has changed since then. The health care act of the 1990’s proposed by Clinton was one that originally gained momentum but eventually didn’t pass. This was because of a major disconnect…
without hearing all the paranoid ideas that right wing television personalities flood the media with. I am a republican; however, feel that our nation needs the influence of democrats, republicans, socialists, and liberals to maintain a balanced government. Looking through the past generations we can find great ideas and programs influenced by people claiming all different parties. In this article, Fuzzy Thinking by Walter G. Moss, we learn that progressive and socialists were responsible for pushing…
decades, spurring a number of opinionated discussions amongst the public and the government. Over the years, a number of changes and revisions have been presented to improve the quality of care at an affordable rate in an effort to maintain a reasonable budget, but none have made enough of an impact to reduce spending. My position on the matter of national health care spending in the United States is that the government is spending more money on minor items and less money on important areas, resulting…
Negative Resolved: The U.S. government should not require its citizens to have health insurance. In a country where we leave 1/6 of the population without means of health treatment we look to the obvious answer. Required health care is not only overall beneficial to the American Public, but also allows for the system itself to become more efficient. The burden for the affirmative team today will be to simply prove that there is more significant good than harm by requiring health insurance. To lay…
Brandon Standridge Prof. Kelly Paul English 102 November 1, 2011 The Future of Healthcare: Are We Heading for Disaster? With healthcare costs rising at an alarming rate, twice the rate of household income, many will agree that the reformation of healthcare now before the number of uninsured reaches epidemic levels is the best course of action. While this is widely agreed upon, people must understand that this problem will not go away overnight and to overcome this looming issue will take a…
HSM541 Nonprofit versus For-profit Healthcare and Organizations Healthcare facilities and organizations are based on either nonprofit or for-profit. Nonprofit and for-profit organizations have many different characteristics. A nonprofit healthcare facility is designed for people that are not able to afford healthcare. Most nonprofit hospitals are created for the community and may have a religious background. With the economy being in a serious recession, the nonprofit organization…