INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH CARE FRAUD AND ABUSE 2009 AHLA/HCCA FRAUD AND COMPLIANCE PROGRAM
James G. Sheehan Medicaid Inspector General/former Associate US Attorney Albany, New York 518 473-3782 JGS05@OMIG.state.ny.us
USUAL DISCLAIMERS
• Focus on Medicare and Medicaid • Propagation is not plagiarism-if you see a good idea, I probably borrowed it • if you would like to use these slides in your own presentation, or pass them to others, feel free • JGS05@OMIG.STATE.NY.US
TRENDS IN THE LAW OF FRAUD ABUSE AND COMPLIANCE
• OLD MODEL-FRAUD-INTENTIONAL CONDUCT • OLD MODEL-ABUSE-SUSPECTED BUT
UNPROVEABLE INTENTIONAL CONDUCT;PATIENT NEGLECT OR MISTREATMENT NEW MODEL-FAILURE OF COMPLIANCE SYSTEMS AND CONTROLS NEW MODEL-”IMPROPER PAYMENT”-
• •
TREND IN THE LAW OF FRAUD, ABUSE, AND COMPLIANCE
• OLD MODEL:CRIMINAL PRIMARY, PROOF BEYOND • •
REASONABLE DOUBT (DOJ) RECENT MODEL:CIVIL FALSE CLAIMS ACT PRIMARYSETTLEMENT INCLUDES $, CORPORATE INTEGRITY AGREEMENT, MISDEMEANOR PLEA (OIG) NEW MODEL:DATA-DRIVEN REVIEW, RECOVERY OF IMPROPER PAYMENTS (RACs, Medicaid Integrity Contractors), FOCUS ON COMPLIANCE OUTLIERS IN PAYMENT AND QUALITY-ADMINISTRATIVE ACTION (CMS, state program integrity agencies);arbitrary and capricious
CHANGING LANGUAGE IN MEDICARE AND MEDICAID PROGRAM CONTROLS • OLD LANGUAGE-”FRAUD AND ABUSE” • NEW LANGUAGE-”PROGRAM INTEGRITY,
IMPROPER PAYMENTS” • “any payment that should not have been made or that was made in an incorrect amount “ • “Improper payments” require neither intent nor faultI
CHANGING EXPECTATIONS OF HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS (particularly large institutional providers)
• Effective compliance and internal controls
– Billing – Quality – Reporting – Credentialing – Governance – Compliance process
WHAT IS FRAUD
• • • • • • • • • • •
– “Fraud” is intentional breach of the standard of good faith and fair dealing, as understood in the community, involving deception or breach of trust, for money (USA v. Goldblatt) – In health care practice, “fraud and abuse” has come to includes far more than the Goldblatt definition-kickbacks and Stark violations – Health care fraud, mail fraud, false statements and instruments, insurance fraud statutes – “false or fraudulent claim” in False Claims Acts (state and federal 31 U.S.C. 3729 et seq.)) – 42 CFR 433.302 definition of fraud for Medicaid
ABUSE
• • • • • • • • •
WHAT IS “ABUSE”? • “ABUSE MEANS PRACTICES THAT ARE INCONSISTENT WITH SOUND . . . MEDICAL OR PROFESSIONAL PRACTICES AND WHICH RESULT IN UNNECESSARY COSTS. . ., PAYMENT FOR SERVICES NOT MEDICALLY NECESSARY, OR . . .WHICH FAIL TO MEET RECOGNIZED STANDARDS FOR HEALTH CARE.”
HOW DOES “FRAUD” DIFFER FROM “ABUSE”?
• “Fraud” requires evidence of the intent of a • specific individual “Fraud means an intentional deception or misrepresentation made by a person with the knowledge that the deception could result in some unauthorized benefit to himself or some other person. It includes any act that constitutes fraud under applicable Federal or State law. “ 42 CFR 455.2
HOW DOES “FRAUD” DIFFER FROM “ABUSE”?
• “Abuse means provider practices that are inconsistent with sound fiscal, business, or medical practices, and result in an unnecessary cost to the Medicaid program, or in reimbursement for services that are not medically necessary or that fail to meet professionally recognized standards for health care. It also includes recipient practices that result in unnecessary cost to the Medicaid program.” 42 CFR 455.2-similar provisions in state regulations-(see, e.g., 18 NYCRR 515.1 (B)) No evidence of intent of specific individual required At the beginning of an investigation, neither prosecution nor defense can know whether matter will be a fraud case, an abuse case, or no case.
• •
ATTORNEY AND COMPLIANCE OFFICER ROLE IN FRAUD AND ABUSE ISSUES
• How do people respond to perceived threat? • 18 U.S.C. 1512-obstruction by destruction of evidence, • • • misleading or corrupt persuasion of
Related Documents: Fraud and Health Care Fraud Essay
Insurance fraud occurs when any act is committed with the intent to claim fraud to obtain some benefit or advantage. Fraudulent claims account for a significant portion of all claims received by insurers, and cost billions of dollars annually. People claim insurance fraud on every and anything home, car, health, and even life insurance. Insurance fraud has existed ever since the beginning of insurance. Insurance fraud can be classified into two types hard fraud and soft fraud. Hard fraud occurs…
Blowing the Whistle on Healthcare Fraud: Should I? Diego Guzman Professor Al Williams MAN 2010 February 21, 2010 Blowing the Whistle on Health Care Fraud : Should I ? A whistle blower is defined as an individual who raises a concern about wrongdoing occurring in an organization or body of people, usually this person would be from that organization. This article brings to light the ordeal that individuals, specifically nurses, in the healthcare industry face when contemplating the possibility…
(healthcare fraud). Some hospitals bill services for doctors who are not even alive (healthcare fraud). Some of these people who commit these crimes are hospital administrators (healthcare fraud). These people are very clever. As a result, they set up complicated billing structures to cover their tracts (healthcare fraud). This can, therefore, make it difficult for healthcare investigators (healthcare fraud). One of the most egregious healthcare fraud is false billing (healthcare fraud). Sometimes…
accountants to see where their revenue is going and makes profits and losses visible and proper adjustments to be made. Financial management plays a vital role in a company’s success. The health care industry is a service, but also a business. There are four elements of financial management are essential in running a health care organization successfully. The first element is planning. A financial manager must know and understand an organizations objectives and be able to identify the steps they must take…
Running Head: Fraud and Abuse Fraud and Abuse in the U.S. Healthcare System Tenisha Howard Keller Graduate Professor Cutspec June 12, 2011 Background People can be affected by healthcare fraud and abuse directly and indirectly. Fraud is defined as an intentional deception, false statement or misrepresentation made by a person with the knowledge that the deception could result in unauthorized benefit to oneself or another person. It includes any act that constitutes fraud under applicable…
Dealing with Fraud Demetrice Armwood Dr. James Coon, Jr HSA 515 Health Care Policy, Law, and Ethics June 16, 2013 As the Chief Nursing Officer of the state’s largest Obstetric Health Care Center, this author is responsible for complaints regarding fraudulent behavior in the center. The purpose of this report is to (1) evaluate how the Healthcare Qui tam affects health care organizations, (2) provide four examples of Qui Tam cases that exist in a variety…
Chris Zurcher Prof. Floyd ENG 101-C10 Medicaid Fraud in America The U.S. spends more than $2 trillion on healthcare annually. At least three percent of that spending — or $68 billion — is lost to fraud each year. Fraud accounts for 19 percent of the $600 billion to $800 billion in wasteful spending in the U.S. healthcare system annually. According to the Coalition against Insurance Frauds national website, Fraud amounts to between $125 billion and $175 billion annually, including everything from…
of people that suffer from identity fraud is at astonishing numbers. In 2013 alone there were 13.1 million that fell victim to this illegal act. A report at the end of each year is produced by Javelin Strategy & Research (Ellis). These victims are not only falling victim to credit card and social security theft, but also health care fraud. In 2013 alone 44% of people that were victimized by identity theft were victims specifically of health care fraud (McNeal). The Target and Niemen Marcus…
would be able to decrease cost and it would have no effect on the quality of care. The Institute of Medicine (IOM) has created a Committee on the Learning Health Care System in America. This committee is working to develop methods of "Better Care at Lower Costs" and has discovered three major areas that require focus in decreasing unnecessary spending. These three areas are; "the rising complexity of modern health care, unsustainable cost increases, and outcomes below the system’s potential" (Smith…
information being exposed. According to the Chicago tribune article Health Records Lost, Stolen, or Reveled Online stated that in the fall of 2009 more than 400 large health care breaches affecting at least 500 people and more than 50,000 smaller breaches have been reported to the federal government. The impact of personal information such as medical being exposed can lead to problems like identity theft, credit card fraud, or fraud against Medicaid or Medicare programs. According to Pam Dixon, executive…