Nicholas Michnik October 22, 2014
1. According to Thoreau’s argument in “Civil Disobedience”, if the law requires you to uphold an injustice to another, then what should you do? What types of examples/rationales does Thoreau give? And in your opinion, in what way does the “Higher Laws” chapter of Walden correspond to the argument made in Disobedience essay (or not)? Cite at least 1 direct quote from the essay and from that “Laws” chapter in your comparison.
If the law requires you to uphold an injustice to another, what should you do? Thoreau states that you should do what you believe is right; do not conform to a government that you do not agree with. By not conforming you are you are not obligated to eliminate evil from the world rater you are obligated to not participate in its evil. A rational of Thoreau’s is his refusal to pay taxes; he is “washing his hands” and refuses to support a system he does not a free with. His refusal to pay taxes is not based on the desire to boycott the government but to refuse his allegiance to the States as a whole. "I quietly declare war with the State, after my fashion, though I will still make what use and get what advantage of her I can, as is usual in such cases." (Civil Disobedience)
The “Higher Laws” chapter of Walden agrees with “Civil Disobedience” in the aspect that we have control over how we live, think and what we do. In High Laws Thoreau lives a life that completes him, a simple life with minimal obligations. With the freedom to do what he want on his land, and to become the person he wants to be. “Every man is the builder of a temple, called his body” (Higher Laws.) We are what we make of ourselves, and we have the freedom to think unrestricted that makes us who we are. “The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think right” (Civil Disobedience.) You have complete control to do what is right, your conscious assist you to do what you want to do. You are obligated to do the right thing because if you go against what you think is right then you are not living an honest life.
2. Review the steps to spiritual independence and enlightenment according to Emerson’s “Self-Reliance” essay. (They were laid out in your class authored power-point, and you can feel free to look at that again). Then explain how the “Nature” and “Experience” essays provide some guidance to achieving those steps, in your informed opinion. Cite at least 3 quotes directly in your answer.
The first step is to figure out how not self-reliant you are when you think. “To believe your own thought, to believe that what is true for you in you private heart is true for all men.” Believe in yourself, if you think that something is right or wrong do not conform to anyone else if they think the opposite or differently. Stay true to yourself and be an individual. That is step two; trust your intuition. Your intuition is when you understand something without hesitation, there is no conscious reasoning behind intuition. Intuition is a “gut feeling” and it may feel like an instinctive way of thinking. Step three is taking responsibility along with living honestly. With the freedom of thoughts and actions comes responsibility. The last step is the hardest and it is to execute all of the steps in the crowd. Having thoughts that are nonconforming are not very popular against the majority. It is hard; the majority public opinion has a heavy persuasive effect.
“Build therefore your own world.” (Nature Emerson) Is the Goal to Emerson’s steps to spiritual independence and enlightenment, Emerson believes that everyone must develop a personal understanding of the universe. “To be yourself in a world that is constantly trying to make you something else is the greatest accomplishment.” (Experience Emerson) Emerson’s stresses that God is the source of man’s power, and insight to divinity are the ultimate goal of living. “Do not go where the path may lead, go instead where there is
Phares 1 English 2130 25 April 2013 Unit 3: Emily Dickinson A Representative Author: Emily Dickinson is an excellent representative of Unit Three because of her literary contribution. Emily Dickinson is known as one of America’s greatest poets. According to Wikipedia, Dickinson was born in Amherst, Massachusetts December 10, 1830. Her grandfather, Samuel Dickinson, was the founder of Amherst College. Her father, Edward Dickinson, followed his father’s footsteps in the academic life. He did…
Emily Dickinson Emily Dickinson's unusual character and style has made her become one of the world's most famous poets throughout the 1800s. In her poems, she expresses her feelings about religion, nature, death and love. Her poems tell a great deal about her lifestyle, which was very secluded and withdrawn from society. Even though she was a famous poet, less than a dozen of her nearly eighteen hundred poems were published during her lifetime. Emily Dickinson was born on December 10, 1830 in…
Raquel Olmedo Professor Cook English 165 NT 18 October 2011 Emily Dickinson Paraphrase/Commentary “668” By Emily Dickinson “Nature” is what we see- The Hill- the Afternoon- Squirrel-Eclipse- the Bumble bee- Nay- Nature is Heaven- Nature is what we hear- The Bobolink- the Sea- Thunder- the Cricket- Nay- Nature is Harmony- Nature is what we know- Yet have no art to say- So impotent Our Wisdom is To her Simplicity. Paraphrase: This so-called “Nature” thing everyone seems to talk about…
what extent did Emily Dickinson's isolation have an effect on her poetry? Emily Dickinson was born in Amherst, Massachusetts, where she lived almost all of her life. She was raised the 1800s. She was a very private person and as her life progressed, she became more and more secluded. As she rarely left her home, she found her voice and her way of communicating through her poetry. Only seven out of over 1,775 of her poems were published in her lifetime (anonymously). Emily Dickinson died in 1886 in…
Emily Dickinson, regarded as one of America’s greatest poets, is also well known for her unusual life of self imposed social seclusion. Living a life of simplicity and seclusion, she yet wrote poetry of great power; questioning the nature of immortality and death, with at times an almost mantric quality. Her different lifestyle created an aura; often romanticised, and frequently a source of interest and speculation. But ultimately Emily Dickinson is remembered for her unique poetry. Within short…
to your prescribed text and one other related text. Belonging is a multifaceted concept that differs for each person. An individual’s interaction with others and the world around them can either enrich or limit their experience of belonging. In Emily Dickinson’s poetry, she explores belonging through different aspects and representations in order to further develop the readers understanding of the world. In particular ‘this is my letter to the wolrd’, I died for beauty’, ‘I had been hungry’, and…
haunting in the tunnels or corridors of your mind. We all know this as being scared or getting spooked. In life we've all been spooked! Regardless of our upbringing and/or size, we have all been caught jumping at that last moment. Why is this? Emily Dickinson addresses this in her poem. She says whether you are a small chamber room or a large house you will be haunted. The haunting comes from within...the corridors of your brain. When we sit in a movie, attend a haunted house, sitting in the dark,…
weaker than men therefore they had more domestic roles while men did hard work labor. Emily Dickinson, a female poet, was raised in a different environment. Dickinson grew up disliking her mother due to her absence in Dickinson’s life. (Biography of Emily Dickinson. http://www.vcu.edu/engweb/webtexts/ED303/emilybio.html) Many young women forced to into the domestic sphere once they are married. Dickinson was never married; instead she lived in her father’s home her entire life. Due to this, she…
Dickinson’s Idea on Nature of Suffering and Death Many of Emily Dickinson’s works revolve around human emotion and the great detail of the process of death. The abundance use of death or suffering symbolism takes the focus out of the present reality of the human life. However, the importance of Dickinson’s works consists of the nature of suffering and death and how both world, reality and eternal life, parallels each other for these subjects are uncontrollable by humans. Death is personified…
Peyton Henye and Nickel Booth Emily Dickinson Poems- SHARE After finding a partner, copy and paste this chart in one group member’s Google Drive. Title it Emily Dickinson Poems- SHARE. Be sure to share the document with your partner, and put each group member’s name on the document. Discuss your responses to the Emily Dickinson Poems- THINK assignment. Fill out the Emily Dickinson Poems- SHARE chart with the answers you and your partner decide are correct. “Much Madness is divinest Sense-” nd …