Do you agree with the view that, in terms of reform, the ‘lessons of the Crimean War were not learned’ Explain your answer using sources 4,5 and 6 and your own knowledge.
Sources 4,5 and 6 agree and disagree that the lessons of the Crimean War were not learned. Some sources disagree that that the lessons of the Crimean war were not learned as there are some short and long term reforms as a result of the war. Some sources agree with the statement as they suggest it is because of other factors such as; the new Liberal government, Prussian military success and limitations of the short term reforms made immediately after the Crimean War.
There were some short term reforms made as a result of the Crimean War, these reforms are stated in sources 5 and 6. Source 5 says ‘there was some improvements in the conditions of service for army recruits’ and source 6 says ‘some improvements were made in the British Army’. These two accounts speak accurately as there were military immediate reforms following the War. The commissariat was dissolved, and it was replaced by the War office aiming to ensure efficient management. Military developments included the establishment of the Victoria Cross in 1856, awarding and recognising achievements for the first time in British History, of the ordinary soldier. There was also recruitment criteria and training schools to make the British army competent and better skilled.
There were also some long term reforms made as a result of the Crimean war. There was better military medical provision, an increase in doctors and the understanding of gunshot wounds. All these reforms arise following the war to improve medical issues, which were inadequate during the war. It is stated in source 6 that ‘following Florence Nightingale’s work in Scutari, nursing was taken more seriously in Britain’. It is after the Crimean war that there were medical schools alongside with nurses training schools and nursing was recognized as a profession, providing medical aspirations for British women and improved healthcare for the public.
Some sources agree with the viewpoint that the lessons of the Crimean War were not learned and that the Prussian military success was a stimulus for real reform. Source 4 says ‘the public had no interest in military questions. However, the discussions generated by the Prussians recent success against Austria have changed my opinion’ and source 5 similarly says ‘reorganisation of the infantry was delayed until Prussian successes had awakened public opinion’ suggesting that Britain feared a Prussian threat as the Austrian army, far better than theirs was easily defeated in six weeks. Thus they carried out reforms only due to the possibility of a war against Prussia and not because of the inadequacies exposed during the Crimean War.
The limitations and failures of short term reforms made during and immediately after the Crimean War show that the lessons of the Crimean war were ultimately not learned. Source 5 says ‘there were some improvements for the army recruits’ implying that although there were improvements, these improvements were not maintained and therefore insignificant. Source 6 agrees that the reforms were limited as it
Related Documents: Do You Agree With The View That Essay
Do you agree with the view that Suez Crisis of 1956-57 did no damage to the fortunes of the Conservative party? For many, the Suez crisis did major damage to the fortunes of the conservative party, as there were many major problems in Britain as a result of the crisis (socially, politically and economically). In Harold Macmillan's words, the British controversy over intervention caused rifts in friendships, divisions in families, and stresses in political parties. In addition there were negative…
To what extent do you agree with the view that Prospero is an unsympathetic hero? Prospero is a powerful magician In ‘The Tempest’ and is in control of all others on the Island. It appears he suffers from two major betrayals, however, the sympathy one would feel for him is marginalised by his actions. Prospero was the Duke of Milan, an extremely powerful between the 13th and 15th century. Although Prospero’s betrayal and banishment, by his brother Antonio, is unfair, Prospero is by part responsible…
How far do you agree with the view that German miscalculation explains the war in 1914? The outbreak of the First World War in August 1914 was not unexpected. Diplomatic tensions between the Entente powers and the Central Powers (Germany and Austria-Hungary) had been increasing for a number of years, for example Weltpolitik had contributed to increasing international tensions. As suggested by Layton German leadership undertook a policy of ‘calculated risks’ in the hope of strengthening Germany’s…
Do you agree with the view that it was largely as a result of the work of Florence Nightingale that Medical care for the British soldiers improved during the Crimean War? Florence Nightingale was a small factor which lead to the medical care for the British soldiers to improve, the sources which give very different perceptions of what she did and how she was portrayed, but she wasn’t the sole factor if it wasn’t for the sanitary commission and Mary Seacole then the medical care wouldn’t of improved…
Do you agree with the view expressed in source three that the diplomatic situation was the main reason for Henry’s failure to obtain an annulment of his marriage to Catherine by 1529? We can clearly see that there is more than one reason why Henry wanted to gain an annulment to Catherine in 1529, and that it wasn’t purely down to reasons all diplomatically related. Although saying this, it’s also clear that the diplomatic situation at the time was a huge contributing factor for the failure.…
ensure the existence of both certainty and flexibility in common law. I will talk about the advantages and disadvantages that contribute to the doctrine of binding precedent including examples of previous cases. Finally I will come to a conclusion if I agree overall with Gardiner’s practice statement of 1966. Doctrine of Precedent is a legal term to describe the practice where decisions established in previous…
It’s clear that Gandhi’s campaigns of non-cooperation and attending political meetings with high ranked British officials during the early 1930s, were hugely significant as they mounted pressure on the Raj, leaving the British with no other alternative than to make concessions towards the nationalists. However, Purna Swaraj wasn’t achieved by Gandhi’s campaigns in the 1930s, due to the limitations of his methods as he was unable to cooperate and negotiate with the British. Conversely, demands for…
There are some countries in this world with a GDP less than $750, with populations earning less than $1 a day, life expectancies barely reaching past 40 years old and devastatingly poor levels of health care, school enrolment and adult literacy rates. These are the defining indicators of people living in low developing countries (LDC’s). Populations living in poverty and the majority with an income too small to accommodate their basic needs and the resources in the national economy, even when equally…
This pack is not designed to replace your own revision. You should use this as an added extra! Make sure you prepare yourself well in advance of the exam. Revise in the way that suits you and make sure you cover EVERYTHING that you have been taught. Ask your teacher for help if you are stuck on any topics. READ THE QUESTION - what is it asking you for? HOW MANY MARKS IS IT WORTH? ANSWER THE QUESTION - don’t waffle on! CHECK YOUR ANSWER MAKES SENSE DON’T PANIC! Religion and animal rights…
Australian morals 3. Do you think migrants “absorb” Australian values? Why/why not? * I believe the Australian values affect migrants as it’s all around them every day. 4. Is Remi’s father’s view justifiable? * Yes. 5. What do you think happens if someone stays within their circle? * They get lost in their own circle and don’t compromise with others 6. Why does Mohammad’s father hold the view he does? How are they different to Mohammad’s? 7. Do you think it is possible…