Critical Analysis Report
Title of Article: Does seeing the doctor more often keep you out of the hospital?
Authors’ Names: Robert Kaestner; Anthony T. Lo Sasso
Name of Journal: Journal of Health Economics
Date of Journal: January 2015
Volume: 39
Pages: 259-272
Summary
The health reform that began in the last decade and is beginning to take a firm hold of the United States has several provisions that help the utilization of primary care outpatient care for the United States population. The idea and reasoning behind these provision and ultimate goal is to improve the health of the population through primary care and this will ultimately improve healthcare costs. The article focuses on studying a health insurance company’s data in understanding the value of outpatient care and if it truly does improve healthcare costs for the employer sponsored plans that were being examined. Through this study, the authors found new causal evidence in the relationship between outpatient primary care and inpatient admissions. The results indicate that greater outpatient utilization and spending increased the probability of an inpatient admission by 1.9% and increase inpatient spending by 4.6%. It was also found that this increase in inpatient admissions as a result of outpatient spending was for conditions that it could be argued that the outpatient physician could have exercised greater discretion and curbed greater costs by exercising this discretion.
General Theme
The general theme of the article was that increased access to outpatient care and increased utilization of outpatient services by the population does not decrease health care cost. In actuality, more primary care and outpatient utilization results in greater inpatient admissions and greater cost based on the study completed.
Point of View
Based on the data collected and used by the authors through an insurer to arrive at the results of the study, I believe that their point of view was objective and based on facts. It was not a summarization of a theory that did not have any basis and was based on data from an insurance company. My only issue with the analysis was the sample size of utilizing a small Midwestern insurance company and only using data for members in a high deductible plan between 2000 and 2006, when the use of these plans was much less prevalent.
Issue Analysis
The issues that are presented in the article include:
1. Plan characteristics and outpatient spending – The study is based on high deductible plans, so the first issue brought up was the impact that the plan design, deductibles and contributions to a health fund (HRA) may have on the spending of outpatient services. It found that an increase in deductible found decreases in outpatient spending, drop in office visits and drop in pharmacy spend. An increase in HRA employer funding resulted in greater outpatient spending. The is conversely what was found with outpatient and inpatient spending later in the study.
2. Relationship between inpatient and outpatient spending – All of the statistical analysis that was completed point to estimates that outpatient spending and inpatient spending is positively correlated. This was found to be inconsistent with the argument that healthcare reform and other healthcare experts have made that outpatient spending and utilization decreases inpatient healthcare costs.
Conclusions and Recommendations
The authors came to the conclusion that the increased use of primary care physicians and outpatient treatment actually increased inpatient admissions and did not positively affect the cost of healthcare. The recent healthcare reform has placed an importance on the access to primary care physicians and the benefits of utilizing the physician in a timely manner. The argument of reform has been that this will assist in overall population health and bend the cost curve of healthcare improving overall healthcare costs and expenditures. Using the data from an insurer, the authors made
Related Documents: Critical Analysis Report Essay example
comprehensive analysis of the problem.This writings will talk about critical thinking. Critical thinking: “the intellectually disciplined process of actively and skillfully conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing, and valuating information gathered from, or generated by, observation, experience, reflection, reasoning, or communication, as a guide to belief and action”( Scriven and Paul ,1997). Critical thinking can positive and negative aspects of the problem from the analysis, it can theoretically…
PD 2: Critical Reflection and Report Writing Waterloo, Ontario Prepared by #42-80 Strathaven Dr. Mississauga, Ontario L5R 3V9 July 17, 2012 Mr. Tim Paci, PD2 Instructor Professional Development Program University of Waterloo 200 University Avenue West Waterloo, Ontario N2L 3G1 Dear Mr. Paci, This report, entitled “Professional Skills: Emotional Intelligence” was prepared as my 1B Work Report for PD2: Critical Reflection and Report Writing. This…
Case Template Critical Issues In order to succeed (definition) Company X must address the following: How to (Solve problem/take advantage of opportunity) so that (consequence) How to (Solve problem/take advantage of opportunity) so that (consequence) How to (Solve problem/take advantage of opportunity) so that (consequence) Notes: No need to provide background of the case 3-5 critical issues that must be resolved within the next two years to survive/thrive Issues are solution-neutral Issues…
end product by the customer. The Close Project process involves performing the project closure portion of the project management plan. A Stage End Assessment should be held at the end of every stage in the project. The Stage Manager and Project Team report their progress and recommendations to the Project Board to gain the Board's approval to either to proceed with the next stage, or to confirm that project has been satisfactorily completed. This assessment reviews the overall progress of the project…
Executive Summary – Setting of Context. (to be no more than one page) Ability to effectively present the aim of the management brief. Giving a clear structure of the brief and arguments with an explicit identification of areas of analysis and evaluation supported by relevant background information of the case study organisation INADEQUATE LIMITED ACCEPTABLE PROFICIENT ACCOMPLISHED EXEMPLARY Very brief attempt at an Executive Summary. May be more an Introduction…
CT050-3-3 Project Management In-course Assignment Company : Healthy Living Pte. Ltd. (HL) - Singapore Service : Global IT Services (GITS) - Malaysia Project : Global Supply Chain Management Project (GSCMP) I. Assignment Learning Outcomes 1. Decide the aims and objectives, deliverables and scope of a typical IT project within the wider context of IT management, create appropriate standards and procedures and communicate the outline of the project effectively to a variety of stakeholders, discuss…
Table of Contents Introduction 3 Company Background 3 The Case 4 Literature Review 5 Change Theories 5 Leadership 5 Psychological Contract & Motivation 5 Critical Analysis 6 Recommendations 6 References 7 Introduction Changes have never been as fast-paced as in the modern world, driven by technological advancements, consumerism, easy information sharing, and knowledge intensity. Businesses have to be constantly aware of their external environment and of the potential changes…
The Career Leader report shows that my interests are strong in Application of Technology, Quantitative Analysis areas with a score of 81% and 69% respectively, which are my personal highs. In Application of Technology it details interest in learning about and using new technologies, enjoys analyzing and designing business processes such as production and operation systems. In Quantitative Analysis it details preference of solving business issues by “running the numbers”, and enjoys building computer…
Strategic analysis is used by an organization to help in identifying key capabilities and resources possessed by the firm to help them gain a competitive advantage in the market in which they exist. Strategic analysis is also used to help an organization figure out the best way for them to achieve their goals and objectives. In order to conduct a strategic analysis a firm must conduct an industry or external analysis in which they must define the market in which they compete and the product or…
Assignment No 1 CRP102SA 2/10/2013 G Vellasamy Clinical Study Design – Critical Issues: A clinical study is a planned experiment for the purpose of evaluating one or more beneficial therapies or treatments. Study designs are the critical elements of a clinical study and they are important in enhancing the reliability and validity of experiments. Some important elements are listed below: Phases Objective of the clinical study Clinical study elements and description o For scientific evidence and…