Introduction
Criminal offending is one of the most persistent barriers towards citizenship and socialization. For most criminals and former convicts, finding their place in normal society has been considered a difficult process because of personal and societal issues. Opinions differ in relation to the issue of effective re-socialization among former convicts with various criminologists arguing that it is possible for former convicts to become normal citizens and participants in political and community matters (Laub and Sampson, 2001). The public including government officials is, however, wary of this claim and points out that former convicts may continue to pose a threat to the rest of society and that it is not possible for them to reach the point where they can safely participate in normal citizen activities without posing a threat to the safety of society (Sherman, 1993). This paper will now evaluate the evidence that as people stop offending, they also become citizens, becoming more engaged in political and community matters. It will first present a discussion of the theories involving criminal recidivism and desistance, including re-socialization. A more critical analysis of these concepts will follow, including an assessment of the details involving re-socialization and its impact on former and released criminals.
Discussion.
Desistance is a difficult phenomenon to evaluate because it refers to the non-existence of events or criminal offending; such non-existence of criminal activity cannot easily and objectively be measured (Maruna, 2001). Desistance basically means stopping, in this case, stopping from committing crimes (Maruna, 2001). Some criminologists argue that this concept of desistance is supported by the fact that even the most hardened criminal cannot persistently commit crimes and that there is a termination point for most crimes and criminals (Shover and Thompson, 1992). Offenders do not consistently offend either, and individuals may go weeks or even years without committing any more crimes. Still, evaluating this phenomenon with its associated certainties can be a difficult process to undertake (Shover and Thompson, 1992). Moreover, theories can be used in order to understand desistance in criminal offending.
Maturation is one of the theories, which help establish an understanding of desistance, with age and criminal offending being associated with each other. In the maturation theory of S. Glueck and E. Glueck (1940), the theorists discuss that for as long as there are no neurological or biological issues, individuals develop well mentally and physically; moreover, they eventually break from offending. In effect, those who persist in their offenses in their older years may not have reached maturity as yet (S. Glueck and E. Glueck, 1940). S. Glueck and E. Glueck (1940) also discounted external transformation; however, they did not indicate a specific chronological age in human development. Such point was later emphasized by McCulloch and McNeill (2008) on their observation about chronological age not having meaning on its own. In effect, without any specific age, it would be difficult to indicate the point of maturation and then to assess developments within a specific chronological understanding (McCullogh and McNeill, 2008).
Other theorists developed a different understanding of crime and desistance, with crimes being defined as short term events which presuppose a specific set of necessary elements or conditions and criminality being founded on stable differences, which affect the possibility of offending (Messner et al., 1989). Gottfredson and Hirschi (1990) also discuss about self-control as an element of offending with low self-control indicating a tendency to offend. They further elaborate that those with low self-control are more likely to participate in impulsive risk taking in order to secure immediate gratification (Gottfredson and Hirschi, 1990). These qualities are associated with
Criminal Behaviour Criminal act is when any behaviour breaks the law. Some people may argue that crime only occurs when someone intends to break the law. Other people say that its when crime is intended and causes harm to people or their property. Criminal behaviour also depends on time and culture. The problems of official crime is: * statistics count the number of criminal acts rather than the number of criminals. So they make a mistake by counting one crime that might be committed by a group…
people, their behaviour and their interaction in society. The Age of Enlightenment, an intellectual and scientific movement of 18th century Europe, was characterized by a rational and scientific approach to religious, social, political and economic issues. It was during this period, the idea that human beings were self determining entities possessing fundamental freedom of choice, or free will and rational thought was put forward. Once people were seen as having control over their lives, crime was seen…
Crime and Deviance Revision notes, exam requirements and exam questions GCSE Sociology 2012 Agent of social control | An individual or group that is responsible for ensuring members of society conform to socially acceptable behaviour. | Anomie | A situation where large numbers of people fail to follow the generally accepted norms and values. | British Crime Survey (BCS) | A victim survey conducted annually by a team of researchers at the Home Office. | Capitalist society | An economic…
the ego acts as mediate to strike a balance between the primitive desires represented by the id and the moral and social constrains represented by the superego. (Siegel, 2005) The extreme guilt resulting from harsh superego is a source of crime, since the behaviour aiming at being caught to decrease the feeling of guilt. A weak superego reflected in inability to delay immediate gratification. The deviant superego, for example, will make a son raised by a criminal father feel acceptable and perform…
Criminology can be described. Criminology is defined by Larry, J, Siegal 2007 as a scientific approach to studying criminal behaviour. It is a social science that looks at societies reaction to laws which have been broken and also focuses on the nature and extent of crime, the causes of crime, and the patterns of behaviour. “Criminology is the body of knowledge regarding crime and deliquency as a social phenomenon. It includes within its scope the processes of making law, of breaking laws and of…
will outline and discuss the various theories used by psychologists to explain criminal behaviour. According to White and Haines 2008 crime was seen as the result of externally caused biological problems or internal psychological factors that were treatable. They believe the criminal was made, not born. Psychological theories tend to focus on how characteristics of an individual lead to criminal behaviour, however these theories may also be irrelevant, challenge existing thinking and make people…
and using your own words – compare and contrast: * classicism * positivism * social constructionism The role of theory in contemporary youth justice practice is crucial in shaping and conceptualising relationships between youth and crime. It provides a structure for how youth justice is practiced and helps make sense of today’s issues surrounding the topic. Approaches to youth justice have evolved throughout the centuries and it is important for youth justice practitioners to be aware…
This mean that the criminal has the choice to commit the crime. They believed that punishment should be prompt and fair to all people , depending on the crime committed . They punished criminals to deter people. People believed that severe punishment was making no difference to crime rates , this meant that criminals were not deterred and recidivism rates were still high. The solution to this , to understand the cause of crime , to solve crime. Positivism occurred in the late 19th century and early…
There is evidence to suggest that genes may influence criminal behaviours, highlighting those individuals biology may increase the likelihood of them turning to crime. The role of serotonin is an important factor which regulates behaviour such as impulsive aggression. This neurotransmitter works in the brain to inhibit the firing of Amygdala, a structure in the brain which controls emotional responses. Therefore individuals with lower levels of serotonin means there is less inhibition in the Amygdala…
environmental factors. The Chicago school is a leading creator in theories to explain why individuals carry out particular behaviours especially in relation to crime. They argue that any behaviour acted out by an individual cannot be explained in individualist terms but needs to be viewed in the terms of problems within a social environment being the cause for that behaviour (Burke, 2009). Ernest Burgess (1924) developed a theory called the concentric zone theory which argued that modern cities…