Imagine being a distraught, young woman whom has tragically lost her child while in a
Jewish concentration camp. She’s emotionally unstable; in dire need of relief from her recurring dreams of her deceased daughter, Magda. Imagine a life of a shoemaker whom works for a very meager salary, but remains there because of his attraction towards his employer’s daughter. Both of these two people have taken risk and live independent lifestyles that cause for them to involuntarily develop the quality of selfreliance. All of the preceding qualities are of American literature. The purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast “ The First Seven Years “ and “
The Shawl “ in the three areas of setting, characters, and symbolism; further on analysis will relate the selections to the essential question: What makes American literature American?
The Shawl is set in a concentration camp in Poland, Germany during the unfortunate
World War II. “ The concentration camp, the exact definition of hell on earth , was sure to be
Rosa’s inopportune death.” ( Ozick 9 ) The previous quote explains the malicious conditions that many Jewish people in concentration camps struggled to survive in. Also, it shows how small and unlikely the chances of escaping or being released from a concentration camp. Fortunately,
Rosa managed to escape from the camp and moved to tiny hotel in America where she tried to begin a new life after her difficult life in Germany. “ Rosa destroyed traces of Germany and established a new life in a tiny hotel” . ( Ozick 47 ) The hotel was very compressed, depressing and symbolized Rosa’s pessimistic mindset. She no longer had hope nor did she feel the urge to continue living. Rosa was emotionally troubled after she lost her daughter and needed comfort.
Unlike “The Shawl”, “The First Seven Years” took place in a shoemaker’s shop in New
York City during the early 1950s, during the winter month of Februray. As the story opens up,
Griffin 2
Feld, looks through the shop window and the following quote foreshadows his restless mind.
“The shoemaker shrugged once and continued to peer through the partly frosted window at the nearsighted haze of falling Feburary snow. (Malamud 1029). The owner/shoemaker, Feld, had an uncertain view of what he was going to do with his opposing daughter. Feld also desired for her to begin dating one of his young customers, but that would only cause more problems in the future. Feld’s helper, Sobel, was a stocky immigrant from Germany; he did the majority of the work due to Feld having a weak heart. With the money he had earned while working at the shop,
Sobel was able to afford a small apartment that was just enough for his needs and also it was a convienient place due to its nearness to the shop. “ The room twas a small, poor one, ... contained a narrow cot , a low table, and several stacks of books. (Malamud 1037) The room was much like Sobel and his personality and his frugal lifestyle. He didn’t request for much, but whatever he did ask for he never wanted for it to be too elegant. Although, he was poor and didn’t own much, Sobel was able to portray his feelings to Mariane, Feld’s daughter.
Much like Sobel, Rosa was poor ,but she recieved financial support from her niece whom survived the concentration camp with Rosa. Rosa could be described as crazy, emotionally unstable, demented ,or maybe even suicidal. However, this couldn’t be very suprising for a mother whom watched her daughter be murdered barbarucally.” Rosa Lublin a madwoman and a scavenger, gave up her store she smashed it up herself and moved to Miami. It was a mad thing to do...” ( Ozick 39) Rosa no longer wanted any items or belongings that would bring back memories of her life while imprisoned in the concentration camp , or worse, her deceased daughter. This explains why she destroyed her shop and moved as far as her money would allow her to.
27 May 2014 Dachau Concentration Camp Established on March 22 by Heinrich Himmler, Dachau was first of the Nazi concentration camps to open in Germany, and was in operation the longest from 1933 to 1945; all twelve years of the Nazi regime. Dachau is located on the grounds of an abandoned World War I munitions factory. The first buildings served as the main camp until 1937, when prisoners were forced to expand the camp and demolish the original buildings. The new camp, completed in mid 1938…
Samee Johnson Mr. Marshall; Period 2 Term 4 Social Studies Writing Benchmark Auschwitz Concentration Camp 4/4/3 AuschwitzBirkenau is the general term for the network of Nazi concentration and labor camps, established near the Polish city of Oswiecim. Together this complex was the largest of all the Nazi death camps across Europe and could hold upwards of 150,000 inmates at any given time. The majority of prisoners held at Auschwitz were killed in the various gas chambers though many died from starvation…
would overshadow their city still today. The citizens of Dachau were oblivious that their city was going to become the origin of concentration camps and of the Holocaust, the mass murder committed by the Nazi s in World War II. Dachau Concentration Camp, which would soon be placed on the edge of their community, would serve as a model for all Nazi extermination camps. This perfect prototype of a Nazi killing machine has come to represent the start of the horror-filled Holocaust and the Nazi's determination…
Good morning Mr. Newman and fellow class mates, today I’m going to present to you my project on Mila 18 and on Auschwitz concentration camps. Q#1 : So first off my segment of the book is from page 522-544. The dates of the story start approximately at the end of april 1948. Q#2 : last time as Offir presented his project we remember 2 things - the Nazi Germans try multiple time to capture the ghetto and they fail to infiltrate Mila 18 - the Nazi Germans drop bombs on the ghetto and burn down…
Schacter is foreshadowing and describing the horrible fate that awaits for so many Jews at the concentration camp in Auschwitz. This passage horrifies me because she was foreshadowing the fate of many Jews who arrived in Auschwitz. it is also horrifying to know that people that thought she was crazy realized that her prediction was true when they arrived at the concentration camp. The language the author uses to describe this passage is graphic because when you read this passage…
created concentration camps to destroy the Jews. A Nazi was a member of the National Socialist German Worker’s party. The Nazis worked for Hitler to capture the Jews and send them to concentration camps. During the Holocaust, concentration camps were horrible places because the Nazis treated their victims like filth and criminals and few were left to survive. The concentration camps were ordered by a cruel man named Adolf Hitler to concentrate enemies of Hitler’s Reich into prison camps. A concentration…
Buchenwald was a concentration camp in Germany that opened in July 1937 and was a labor and extermination camp. It was one of the largest extermination camps in Germany established by the Nazis. This camp was built 5 miles northeast of Weimar in east to central Germany. In 1937 Buchenwald was open for male prisoners, until 1944 when woman were admitted into the prison as well. The main field in the camp was where the prisoners were held. The SS guards and the camp administrators were…
Elie Wiesel born was born Jewish American on September 30, 1928 in the town of Sighet, now part of Romania. During World War II he with his family and other Jews from the area were deported to the German Concentration and Extermination camps. Elie was separated from his mother and sisters. His mother and sister Tzipora were killed in the gas chambers upon arrival. In 1940 Romania lost the town of Sighet following the second Vienna Award. In 1944 Wiesel and his family lived in the larger of the two…
gave him the strength to keep going until the end? A: I believe he never necessarily wanted to die. I think he was dreaming of getting out of concentration camp. He must have been hopeful in some aspects in order to continue to the very end. Otherwise, if he wanted to die enough, he probably would have just let himself out of concentration camp the easy way. 2. Q: What do you think happened to Elie’s mother and sister? A: At the end of the book, it is probably assumed that they died…
we label as “good” and other “bad”, are involved in this everlasting loop, showing that even the pure evils we never thought could reprise their role in evils neverending twist of fate have their own slot. With the corralling of human beings into camps, surrounded by fences and trapping those concealed in a man made Hell, it seems that it would be a “one time thing”, but in reality? The past is repeating itself as we know it. In World War II, the human race saw a genocide of those of Jewish descent…