University of Manchester
Complexity in Defence Projects
A dissertation submitted for the degree of B.Eng.
Petar Galabov
December 2014
School of Mechanical, Aerospace & Civil Engineering, the University of Manchester, M13 9PL
Contents
Chapter 1 Introduction 2
1.1 Project Background 2
1.2 Aims and Objectives 2
1.3 Outline of the Report 3
Chapter 2 Literature Review 4
2.1 Complexity in Projects 4
2.2 Defence Industry 5
2.2.1 Definition 5
2.2.2 Platform Projects 5
2.2.3 Military Expenditure 6
2.3 Main Problems Associated With Defence Projects 7
2.4 Case Studies 8
2.4.1 Astute Program 8
2.4.2 Eurofighter Typhoon 10
Chapter 3 Methodology 12
3.1 Research 12
3.2 Data Collection and Analysis 12
3.3 Sources of Information 12
3.4 Future Work 13
3.5 Gantt Chart 13
“Complexity in defence projects”
Chapter 1 Introduction
1.1 Project Background
Defence projects are considered to be among the most complex projects in the world. They usually suffer from substantial cost increases, big schedule delays and frequently fail to meet the original requirements.
This project will assess the nature of project complexity and will relate the learning to the main problems associated with defence projects. In addition to that, management of big projects in other major industry sectors will be considered and the conclusions drawn will be employed to suggest ways in which future defence projects can be managed in order to minimize the problems.
1.2 Aims and Objectives
The aim of this project is to identify the main problems associated with defense projects and suggest possible ways in which future projects can be managed more effectively.
The following objectives will be discussed in order to achieve the aim:
To identify and discuss what project complexity is in general
To identify what defence industry is and to describe its main characteristics
To identify the main problems that arise with defence projects
To review two/three defence-related projects so that the problems can be put into context
To identify how large projects in other industry sectors (possibly civil aerospace) manage their problems
To use the learning from other industry sectors and establish whether these lessons can be applied to the defence industry
The project will be undertaken between October 2014 and April 2015.
1.3 Outline of the Report
Chapter one gives a general overview of the project scope, aims and objectives and sets the context for this report.
Chapter two is the main body of the report and contains within it the results from reviewing the literature. It discusses the concept of project complexity, gives a general overview of the defence industry and introduces the main problems arising from defence projects. Some of the problems are put into context by reviewing two case studies (the Astute program and Eurofighter Typhoon).
Chapter three describes the methodology behind the research undertaken. It discusses the concepts of primary and secondary sources of information and qualitative and quantitative data as well as the methods of data collection and analysis. At the end, it gives a general overview of the future work to be completed in order to achieve the aim of the project.
Chapter 2 Literature Review
2.1 Complexity in Projects
According to Kerzner and Belack (2010), complex projects are different from traditional projects for multiple reasons. Complexity can arise from the size and length of the project – the larger it is in scope and cost, and the longer it is, the more likely it is to undergo a change in scope, which will affect the budget and schedule. Consequently, complex projects tend to suffer from schedule slippages and substantial cost increases.
Complexity can also arise from the multiple interactions involved in the execution of the project. This includes the interface between numerous subcontractors or suppliers, which could be located in different time zones around the globe, as well as the cultural differences
Steve Phillips, head of the Huxley Maquila project team, had to make a suggestion about moving production to Mexico. After six months of investigation, a final report outlining the results was prepared and was given to Steve. His job now was to give some recommendation to board of directors about whether to establish the manufacturing plant in Mexico and if so, where and how. Sub-Problems/Issues: • Increase in knowledge intensity of defence product, resulted in higher development costs.…
its definition, problems with estimation in software creation and how FPA can be used to rectify these problems. The outcome of the following content is to give the reader an overall understanding of the process FPA.’ 1 Project Management 641 - Essay on Project Scheduling. Function Point Analysis & its Characteristics 02.04.14 The technology boom towards the end of the twentieth century and the much into the twenty first century sees our society held up by a blind reliance on…
writing. Weakness However this article provides an argument as to the benefits of using grounded theory and builds a rational line of reasoning in defence of the argument. Although his article was logically written, it is somehow lacking some practical…
presented an “eight-point plan” for improvement, which included protection of human rights, the political parties’ promotion, lifting media restrictions, freedom of word and advancement in reconsolidation with North Korea. He was more aware of the complexity in ruling than Chun. The Olympic Games, held in South Korea in Seoul in 1988, were under the supervision of President Roh’s government, and happened to be a huge success for the country. They were a symbol of transforming from dictatorship to democracy…
about ‘great clients’ or effective solutions. For us, it’s about something far bigger. It’s about pushing boundaries. Sparking ideas. Being surrounded by insightful people and far-reaching resources. At IBM, there’s a huge variety of clients and projects to get stuck into. We are not interested in the off-the-shelf or the been-there-done-that. Quite simply, if there’s something new to explore, or something challenging to develop, we’re there. In other words, this isn’t the kind of work –…
people in matrix structure is assigned to both project and functional department, they could communicate across each project and department. In this company, however, is not providing any information about the communication across each project and functional department. On the other hand, Schermerhorn(2010) also talk about the team structure. In this structure, it convenes people with different skill and speciality to accomplish a particular task or project. As the information described, U-shape Unlimited…
within budget. - Support others, or write themselves reports on key issues for the Executive Team or Council. - Responding to upset customers in the field and addresses non complying activity that contravenes the Reserves and Beaches bylaw WORK COMPLEXITY (describe the most challenging duties typically undertaken) - Contributing to the culture at Council, by demonstrating behavioural competencies and encouraging others to do the same. - Make customers and the wider Council the focus in daily work…
Biology in Context The Spectrum of Life SECOND EDITION Peter Aubusson • Eileen Kennedy • Peter Hickman 2 1 253 Normanby Road, South Melbourne, Victoria 3205, Australia Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Bangkok Buenos Aires Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kolkata…
Quo vadis? Towards an effective predatory pricing provision Garth Campbell* The level of criticism directed at s 46 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) for its inability to capture predatory pricing indicates that smaller businesses are extremely concerned about this practice. Such criticism reached its peak following the High Court’s decision in Boral Besser Masonry Ltd v ACCC (2003) 215 CLR 374, which rejected a claim of predatory pricing. Since then, the Birdsville Amendment and other recent…
Fiscal Policy in India (An overview 1991-2011) Abstract This essay examines the trajectory of India’s fiscal policy with a focus on historical trends, fiscal discipline frameworks, and fiscal responses to the global financial crisis and subsequent return to a fiscal consolidation path. The initial years of India’s planned development strategy were characterized by a…