Civil disobedience is peacefully protesting against laws or governmental demands that are viewed as immoral. Throughout history this strategy has been used as a way to stand up for one’s morals against unjust laws. People who have used, and strongly believed in this method include: Henry David Thoreau, Frederick Douglass, Malcolm X, The Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Mahatma Gandhi, and many others. After analyzing several documents concerning dissent, I can conclude that one should use civil disobedience to support their conscience and defend their beliefs about unjust laws. Henry David Thoreau was a man who strongly believed that much of what the government was doing at the time was morally incorrect. In his essay “On the Duty of Civil Disobedience” Thoreau asserts that if our conscience tells us something is unjust, it is our duty to act against it (1-5). He demonstrated this by refusing to pay poll taxes, which supported the Mexican War. Being an abolitionist, Thoreau was strongly against this war which purpose was to expand slavery into the western states. He suggests an interesting point by stating, “I saw that, if there was a wall of stone between me and my townsmen, there was a still more difficult one to climb or break through before they could get to be as free as I was” (10). In jail, he felt free because the state could not hurt or demolish his thoughts, they could only punish his literal body, and being locked in a room did not affect his spirit. Thoreau points out that the government believes that a revolution would be far worse than the injustice. He then questions, “Why does it not encourage its citizens to put out its faults, and do better than it would have them?” (6). The point he is making is that by resisting unjust laws, and showing them their flaws, the people would be helping to create a better government. Thoreau declares that no man should ignore his conscience just to maintain the integrity of the state (2). He uses a significant metaphor that gives the reader a clear picture of how doing what is right might be hard, but it is still the morally correct choice when he stated, “If I have unjustly wrested a plank from a drowning man, I must restore it to him though I drown myself” (3-4). This clearly shows that despite the convenience of ignoring one’s conscience, the just decision is always the right decision. The Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. had gone to Birmingham to
Civil disobedience, also known as passive resistance is the act of refusal to obey the demands of a government or occupying power without resorting to violence or active measures of opposition. Its useful purpose to force concessions from the government or occupying power. Civil disobedience has been a major tactic and philosophy of nationalist movements in Africa and India. Martin Luther King Jr., Henry David Thoreau, and Gandhi are three men who put the use of civil disobedience into play very…
I would draw the conclusion that civil disobedience could be used as a good or bad thing. I also feel that violence is not the answer to any situation no matter what. I also feel that sometimes if force is given then you have to return it to get your point across. Violence is never the first choice though; you always should find other ways to handle problems. Parents sacrifice thing to better their children the right way, an example is sitting down and talking to them instead of beating their child…
“Civil Disobedience” Henry David Thoreau’s essay, “Civil Disobedience,” begins by saying, “I heartily accept the motto,-’That government is best which governs least,’” he believed realistically that this is how government should be (177). He goes on to say what he really believes is, “That government is best which governs none at all” (Thoreau 177). Thoreau does not agree with many of the governments laws and believes that in order to follow many of the laws it would mean not having a conscience…
Diaz 1 Scarlett Diaz Period 2 American Lit. January 16, 2012 One Pager: Civil Disobedience In the article “Undocumented Immigrants Take Cause to Defiant New Level” by Daniel Gonzalez, the author states that illegal immigrants of Arizona and other states are protesting the new “show me your papers” law. The “show me your papers” law was passed in 2010 in Arizona by a majority vote. This new law would allow government officials to ask anyone who they suspected to be in the country illegally…
Well thats just like, your opinion, man; an essay on Civil Disobedience Much like The Dude in regards to Jesus, I believe the basis of our current government is merely an arbitrary cataclysm of opinions. Two select groups of inherent, feuding opinions that, if one is an accepted member of American Society, is forced to pursue. Of course, these organized parties of opinions allow for some individual choice but only to the extent of deciding to be an active member of the democrat or republican…
Wintermantel 1 Clayton Wintermantel Mrs. ButellHuntoon Composition ll 5 March 2015 In his essay “Civil Disobedience,” it is clear to see how Henry Thoreau expresses his disapproval for the United States government. His multiple rhetorical appeals such as logos, pathos and ethos invoke the reader to side by focusing his ideas around our democratic government. The three main ideas that Thoreau relates to are the idea as government as an expedient, the government will not enterpr…
“Civil Disobedience” Imagine living in a world where you completely disagree with a law or rule. Everyone in this world is required to obey this law, but your beliefs do not allow you to do the same. You can not carry on with being an obedient citizen so you break the rules. In the conclusion of breaking the laws, you have gotten into serious trouble. You are no longer living safe and in harmony. You are asking me if it is justifiable to break the rules in certain circumstances. I think in no circumstances…
Jade Green October 17, 2013 Civil Disobedience Laws are made to ultimately better the people, yet some laws are not always made to better all the people. This fact is not stated to be overlooked but to be altered. The Declaration of Independence states, “all men are created equal”, but the word “all” somehow excluded African Americans, women, and others; words mean nothing when the actions do not follow them. Henry David Thoreau’s “Civil Disobedience” challenges individuals to stop shying away…
pay taxes, the objection to cast a vote, and the rejection of personal property are all declarations of disapproval directed to an unjust government. The people of any unfair system are obligated to tailor their government through relentless civil disobedience or rebellion. For the sake of the governed, immediate action, or lack of action, must be taken when a government deviates from its course. It is not a man’s duty to eliminate any wrong, but he must not participate in any wrongdoing. With such…
Andrew Richardson ENGL 1001 Paper #2 Mr. Thoreau, My name is Andrew Jay Richardson, and like many other people, I read your inspiring paper “Civil Disobedience.” Even though I am a farmer from the great state of Indiana with a low education (according to most), I understood your paper quit fluently. If you would take the time to read my thoughts on your revolutionary paper I would be most obliged. Now Mr. Thoreau, you start off your paper stating “I heartily accept the Motto” “”That government…