Censorship: Supreme Court of the United States and School District Essay
Submitted By IsaBugqueen1
Words: 1528
Pages: 7
Isabel Montgomery
Mrs. Love
Pre-AP English 10
8 March 2013
Free, but Not Free
Censorship is the “suppression of information, ideas, or artistic expression” (Haimon). Censorship has been around for a long time, since ancient Athens. Socrates was killed for “corrupting the youth” with ideas the government disapproved of (Haimon). In the United States of America, students are still being affected by censorship that happens in their learning environment. Books are being taken away, stories to be put in the school newspaper are being removed, and clothing is being censored. Courts determined that students in America’s public high schools do have First Amendment rights, but their rights are limited.
Every person has their own viewpoint on censorship. A reason against censorship is everyone has First Amendment rights. Freedom of press and speech should give students the right to write and publish all the stories they want to put in the school paper. Freedom of assembly and religion should give students the right to express their beliefs without getting penalized. (Haimon) Things censored could help a student when they go off to college, such as Shakespeare. (Marino) A reason for censorship is people being afraid of ideas, thinking that ideas will hurt others instead of benefit them. Books that are censored contain profanity, graphic details; they also illustrate “unpatriotic or immoral ideologies” (Haimon). Textbooks and library books are often censored because people feel the book could undermine children’s values (Haimon).
Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District was a United States Supreme Court case that set the first precedent for student rights in public school. In 1965, siblings John and Mary Beth Tinker joined their parent’s protest against the Vietnam War by wearing black armbands. School officials heard of the idea and said if they saw a student wearing an armband the student would be asked to remove it. If a student did not remove the armband they would be suspended till it was removed. The Tinkers were well aware of the consequences that would follow their actions, but they did it anyway. The Tinkers took the school to district court to ask for “injunction preventing the school board from taking disciplinary action against them” (Mikula and Mabunda “Tinker” 585.) The court ruled against them, the Tinkers then took the school to federal court. The court ruled in favor of the Tinkers, saying they were “engaging in symbolic political speech” (Mikula and Mabunda “Tinker” 585) which is also protected by First Amendment rights. The court made the decision because the Tinker’s protest was not disruptive. (Mikula and Mabunda “Tinker” 584-586.)
Like Tinker, Lowry v. Watson Chapel School District also involved a uniform policy. The reason he controversy started because the school banned jewelry and other accessories that went over school uniforms. On October 6 the 11th and 12th graders wore black wristbands without covering any part of their uniform. The students who wore the black wristbands were suspended. However, students who wore white wristbands with the verse 1st of Timothy 4:12 had no disciplinary action taken against them. Chris Lowry and a few other students filed suit, saying that the school had violated their rights. On February 22, 2007 the students redid their claim; it now said that the school had taken away their rights according to the 14th Amendment. On August 22, the judge ruled against Lowry, saying the school had not violated any of the students’ rights according to the 14th amendment, nor had the uniform take away rights according to the 1st Amendment. The judge also said that the school had the right to suspend any student that did not follow school rules. (Zirkel 308)
Like Tinker and Lowry, Island Trees Union Free School District Board of Education v. Pico also had an issue with censorship, only instead of uniforms it was with library books. The problem started in September 1975,
Related Documents: Censorship: Supreme Court of the United States and School District Essay
Knowledge A Discussion about the Freedom Censorship of Books in Public School Libraries Collier Wimmer High Point University Introduction Book-banning in school libraries is only the latest battleground in a centuries-old war over the censorship of ideas. Twenty years after Johann Gutenberg’s invention, the first popular books were printed and sold in Germany; within another 20 years, Germany’s first official censorship office was established when a local…
Significant historical events, court cases, and ideas that have shaped our current system of constitutional First Amendment jurisprudence: 1215 Abuses by England’s King John cause a revolt by nobles, who compel him to recognize rights for both noblemen and ordinary Englishmen. This document, known as the Magna Carta, establishes the principle that no one, including the king or a lawmaker, is above the law, and establishes a framework for future documents such as the Declaration of Independence…
“Give me the liberty to know, to utter, and to argue freely according to conscience, above all liberties.”(Goodreads 2010) Freedom of Speech serves as the foundation of the United States’ governmental policy, which, with the establishment of the First Amendment, guarantees every citizen liberty and freedom. The first amendment states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the…
Internet Censorship Should it be illegal to publish literature with "indecent" content on the Internet but perfectly legal to publish that same work in print? This question has spawned the debate over Internet censorship, which is currently raging in the United States Congress as well as in other political forums around the world. The question as to whether the Internet should be censored will continue to be debated for many years to come. As with any political topic, the debate over Internet…
the United States District Court of Maryland erred, the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of Rice. The district court first dismissed the case stating that the state “does not provide a civil cause of action for aiding and abetting,” and then ruled in favor of Paladin using Brandenburg as precedent and affirming that the First Amendment protects abstract advocacy, “the freedom to criticize that which constrains,” “one of the ultimate safeguards of liberty.” (Trager, 312) The Supreme Court…
understanding of the structure and functions of government and politics in the United States. Historical Documents Magna Carta (1215) First document that limited the government! Declaration of Independence (July 4, 1776) Helped to establish democratic ideals in America. Articles of Confederation The first government of the United States. Why did it fail as a government? States had the most power. The federal government was weak…there was NO PRESIDENT (or…
pertaining to privacy. It states that all persons born or naturalized in the United States are citizens of both the country and the state in which they live. The amendment prohibits the states from creating or enforcing any law that would deprive citizens of life, liberty, or property without due process, as well as guaranteeing that all laws protect every person equally. (Cornell University Law) This addition to the Constitution has been instrumental in several Supreme Court decisions, including the…
Ancient Greece. It is the concept that a select group of people are chosen to represent the people in government. For example, our congressmen and women are our representatives to Congress and, in theory, should best represent the people of their district that they possibly can. private goods - A product that must be purchased in order to be consumed, and whose consumption by one individual prevents another individual from consuming it. Economists refer to private goods as "rivalrous" and "excludable"…
religious beliefs nor may it interfere with the way you worship. One of the most heated debates of our time involves the issue of prayer and schools. Do students have the right to pray in class? Or would a prayer interfere with another student's rights "not" to pray? A number of cases have been brought before the Supreme Court to settle this matter. The Supreme Court has held that prayers or even a moment of silence would violate the principles of the First Amendment. Freedom of Speech This freedom…
A library is a place where free exchange of ideas is available to all patrons regardless of their background. An example of this is the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) is when “public and school libraries cannot receive federal monies to provide access to the Internet unless they have an Internet access policy, and employ filtering software that blocks child pornography, images that are obscene, or items deemed harmful to juveniles” (Rubin…